02.06.2013 Views

Volume 2187, 1-38544 PHMCKHII CTATYT MEXCIMYHAPO IHOFO ...

Volume 2187, 1-38544 PHMCKHII CTATYT MEXCIMYHAPO IHOFO ...

Volume 2187, 1-38544 PHMCKHII CTATYT MEXCIMYHAPO IHOFO ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

[ RUSSIAN TEXT - TEXTE RUSSE I<br />

<strong>PHMCKHII</strong> <strong>CTATYT</strong> <strong>MEXCIMYHAPO</strong> <strong>IHOFO</strong> YroJIOBHoro CYA<br />

OpraHH3atumt O6beAIMCHHix Haioifi<br />

[ The text reproduced herein incorporates the corrections effected by procis-verbaux<br />

of 10 November 1998, 12 July 1999, 30 November 1999 and 8 May 2000. These<br />

proc~s-verbaux are reproduced following the text of the Statute.<br />

Additional corrections were effected by procks-verbaux of] 7 January 2001 and<br />

16 January 2002. These are not incorporated in the text reproduced herein but are<br />

reprintedfollowing the text of the firstfour procis-verbaux mentioned above. --<br />

Le texte reproduit ici incorpore les corrections effectu~es par proc~s-verbaux en<br />

date des 10 novembre 1998, 12juillet 1999, 30 novembre 1999 et 8 mai 2000. Ces<br />

proc~s-verbaux sont reproduits apris le texte du Statut.<br />

Des corrections additionnelles ont gt faites par les procks-verbaux du I 7janvier<br />

2001 et 16janvier 2002. Elles ne sont pas incorpories dans le texte reproduit ici,<br />

mais sont de prifdrence reproduites apris les quatres premiers procis-verbaux<br />

mentionnis ci-dessus.]


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

PHMCKHI <strong>CTATYT</strong> MEACYHAPOAHOrO YroJIOBHOrO CYJA<br />

!IPEAMBYJIA<br />

rpcvrEac'TBa - V'aCmmK .acrpomeero CmTrr'a,<br />

cO3HBm, 'TO BCC H8pOPAM 0LCeANHHLaI O6ftzH y3aMH H'ro o3amoioepcifeHHc HI Kyjzb7yp<br />

06pa3yCT COBMecTUoe HaCACJHe, H 6yrH o6eCncKOCHHbe TM, 'ro sra Toma M03amn1 MOXeT Gbrm B<br />

jo6oh MoMenT BpcMeHH pa3pyweHa,<br />

naMMY 0 TOM, T'TO 3a HZHCUI ife cTOJe4e MHArIHO AeTre, XCHIJH H MyX'm CTH xCewm<br />

HeMCMW bUX 39loAegHH, rjzy6oKo trpiczx cocc-m 'Ienobeiecrsa,<br />

nPH3Ha88, qT TirarI uHe [peTCHMA yrpOWMOM KeO6teMy aopy, 6eaonacHOcrd H<br />

6OlarononyHyq,<br />

none , Wo CaMle cep?.e3He npcCryuoemu, BW3BaOfMHe o38o'emqoCHr 3ccro<br />

MezjYxapoioro coo6wecna, He AOJIM 61 ocraaamcz 6e3Haxa3aaHMMH H q'O Ix ,AIeIoIa oe<br />

npecIe,OBame OOSXHO M'r OCneqCHO Kax mepamm, npxHxHmaeMmMH Ha HmUHOHaJbHOM YPOBHe, Tax H<br />

aK'rHBH3aUIIC McZfl'MapogIo corpyBnImqecmra,<br />

6vnv' npeHcnonHCHN pemHMoCTU noJoXr KoHeCi 63Haw3amo r Jmi, coaepuamoumx 7811<br />

npcCryfe HR, x Tem camum cnoco6croaa'Bm npejzynpezemno no~o6Hwx npecryMnemd,<br />

HH11OMHHaE, 'R0 O513aHHOc1io KiO rocyjapciia zsfserca oyutcym1IemO cro yTnoo<br />

IOPHflH H HaA JIHIJMH, HeCyUZHMH COTeThCr OCTH 3a oHeplfeRH MaKyH8apoaM npecxymefk,<br />

EHORb nomrsepaxA uejH H npHHWom Ycraaa OpraumaLI 06 ewenemma Hauz., H B qacTHoCTU<br />

TO, 'TO BCeCYPPCIR Bo 3CP p OTS 1 yrp03bi cIIok HaH ee npHeMeHL KE npoTmi<br />

TCppHTopHa o H-enpxKOcHOBCHHOcTH HJ.H nO.HTH'leCKOR He3aBHcH ocTm .,Jldowo roCyJapcmra, TK H<br />

KaKHM-IH60 AIpyrm o~pa3OM, HCCOBMCcrHMuLM C Lk.enMH O ,ejimx Ha]ig,<br />

9o~gep 8 9ATOA CBU3H, 'o HHT0 B HJIITOUIO.M CTaTyTe He AOnxHO HocapKHHkHA cx xKa<br />

Aatonee KaKoMy-jfHO rocyJ~apCTBy-yaCTHHKy<br />

snyrpBHMme ,ea n o6oro rocyapcrsa,<br />

[1paBo EMCIHBaThCg B BoopyXCHHItI KOH4)JTHKT HnH BO<br />

dymuor' n lDcnoBuHeIu pewmwo c moA ticam H Ha 6naro HhEtefmero H rpJ H n0KOACHHA<br />

y'pemAu Hme3aHcm, b nocrogH.if MCIHapomfi yrouiosm, t cyA, cn3am fth C CHCrCMOff OpraHH3a8mH<br />

06%e3mcH.Ix HaimA, o6 jaJa8ouxf iopxcIHKuxHcI B OT mOcHH camux ccpbelk,, np¢ OcmHHl,<br />

B,3MBuOBa lH 0360O'I HOCT BCero e MexJYHapoAHoro coo6iuecma,<br />

uoAD~Sm imo MexqnaponHmf yrouioBnmk CYA, y'IpezuCWHAb HR ocRouAMo HacTmero<br />

CTMTYMa, , OOMO RrCT HaLxOHaJihMhle opraHu y 0ojiOBHO IOCT1IOH,<br />

npeHcnomacmmIe pCeHMOCH Co3ua npo hc rapafmf yBaXCHHA 9 OCYMOCrV eHHO MeZ mHapo0DHro<br />

npaocyO H o6eeeumH ero co6mJoumm,<br />

cornaCHAlch 0 HuxecqeaVIOyfleM:


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

qACrb 1. Y'IPEAILF=JI CYJA<br />

cmi<br />

Hacmmima yqpeZ, aCrr Meximmpom,. yromoak cyA (,CyA"). OH nuemrca nocTommum<br />

OPIUOM, Y]IOJHOMDWqeMHM OCyU3CCTMMJt IopHCAR4f p<br />

a OThOMea lMM, o01s dXem 3 C8aMue<br />

copihci we Upecrt7anmmi , ams louBmaI e o3a6oqemioc'rb megJxyapoworo coo6amc'na, yxa3amue a<br />

Hacroamem Cra'rc, m Aonomier HamXofam e cx'are.m yrooauoro npCnoCYa. IOpaBwnzMi a<br />

*,y'maxwmpoaame CyAa peryjimpyvoca nonzoxexnm Hac'omuem Craiyra.<br />

Cnim 2<br />

Omomiema Cyna c Onrm-n~..ueA 06mmmnmaemn. ImA<br />

CYJ ycraHaamff Omemz c Opamamnel O6ftejAmicm Hami nocpejcmM cornamemm,<br />

wo6psemom Accau6neet rocy~apca - yqacrmaos lcwoaecm Ciaiyra a mocneAJcrumz au qa xorm<br />

UpIecA- ei CYA or e Cyja.<br />

MecmnneIuanma C=c<br />

1. Mec-inpe6umatme Cyja nnaerc raara, HHAepnanu ("rcyA&pcmo nlapeuaazm").<br />

2. CyA crynaeT c rocynapromm npct6aam cornamemie o urma6-uaprape, ojo6psiemoe Accu6nef<br />

rocyjapc-yqacralKoa i anociegcTaxa 3aum.o'aMoe f'lpei.,jlaTe.m Cyjia or ee ma Cy&.<br />

3. Ecia CyA curae'r m10 xelal'Cfml[nm, OH MOecT 3accI2tb 9 06UrX Apyrx MC~rRX, KaK 9M<br />

nUPyeA MPeHo a HacimgMeM Cmiyre.<br />

llpoaeni craTc m noUmoMoqM Cria<br />

1. CyA o6.aaer NeXjyaapOoflk npa3ocy6-rMocMW. OH Tame o6 W r T c upaBoMoo6nocmo,<br />

Kam, m oae oa3amhcz HeodxojwAoi A ocyMec'njmfl l er 4ymumT a Rocrazenus er enei.<br />

2. CyA loxer ocymecram r Bica aymaum a noaoo , Kax mo npei oorpeo o Hacrom~em<br />

Cmyre, Ha TeppErrpN mo6om rocyalapcTa-y'acnmua s, no cnaieznomy cornamenmM, ua TeppEMopHH<br />

rno6om Aipyroro rocynapcraa.<br />

qACTb 2. IOPHCIHKIIH, IIPHEMJIEMOCTh H IIPIMEHEMOE IIPABO<br />

U~e'rvln~wl, rnm'RnBHLlIe rl L,=nwn 6n<br />

1. IOp c mAx Cyjia orpam CMlfU cpb3HmH nlWT.cErEUU, sli3UEWUUIMU


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

o3a omo'r ecem MxZiiHapoxioro cooft5ecma. B comwrmim c Hiacm a CEMO CY oCaJAU r<br />

iopuct mruetJ i OnOmmm cnc woux npecryinmix:<br />

a) npeceyn ,eC rCHOW(J;<br />

b) upecry u ipon -m wqcaoaqwocnh;<br />

C) SoMMcO npeCynCHIis;<br />

d) npecrywaeme arpeccRu •<br />

2. CyA ocyl3ecu-r mpx.,mmzao B omomfeim nlw-ryniCtmC arpcccimi, Ku Tnreo 5yJrr Npmro s<br />

coOmewmm co ccmmn4 121 m 123 nosoxeme, coJepxMnecOfeJmf¢ awe-MTyUDHMB s'rro<br />

H<br />

mnaraomuee yeCosH, a KOrpux Cy,0 ocy c€z r mpcwmupo xcarcjmao smoro npecrynaeHam. Tazoe<br />

noaoXenne coo0paiycmz c coOeTrymmwaw nonoxemiua Ycrmw OprainImui 061XIemnI Haumfl.<br />

fnz uiemeH eamnero CTrM "rwo=A" oaa'matr -m6oc H cneaomuwxz , HAesi , cowpmamme C<br />

HaMepemt yMloM, OiOCTW KO RC'rMMIO, iKiio-B6o HEM(OBSIHYIo, 9THmeCCyO, paw0ym<br />

ml pemmosmio rpymy Kai TalOByo:<br />

rpymni;<br />

a) yd iimco 'tEOB Taxor.O rpyimu;<br />

b) npmcuin ie cepesT mw uozpecxmR mm yacmmnoro pac -pokcm waeaam TaKoA<br />

?Cac ~X<br />

c) np mmmmeinoe o3Jami ,An Kaxok-zHdo rpymw TAINI Xm emCmi-x ycao3H*, WOIOpc<br />

paccunmwm Ha riomoc Rm qacimoc duiai'ecoc ympt'rozcuii cc;<br />

d) mcpW, pcwrannme Ea aptnompaw cae ,omopoKeim a cpce= Taxol rpym;<br />

e) Hacnmemmrsi napeoja We H3 o)Wok 4cnoacmccok rpymnl a jPyryqo.<br />

1. uud Whz uacom oem Ca'ryra Hpccrynemc npomm gfonwocm3" o3 u'fT m06oe in<br />

CjiAytOUHX ,c.IlHi, KOrI", ai0 Colspm nawTC a1 pamwax wapOxomac1m HOrO wo ciacroMa1'eI" OrO<br />

RanAHiBiH na ifl6ha rpBZJIBHCsHI mm,31 H can TuKoC HuameJ~lI coBC4HDaiC CO2MnHo:<br />

a) y6nRcmo;<br />

b) Hcrpe6.azeue;<br />

c) nopa6omcnme;<br />

d) RcnaopTanai HacHII.Cicmmoc nepeMfellnjeau iaceucHa;<br />

e) 3aB1oq0HC B TW/Uy IN OIYWe XCcrOtoC IMeM e 4I R O Co6oW o B aapyinHe


OcHOBOnlloaraWmHx HOpM KCBYHapOtHOrO flpasa;<br />

f) WAT";<br />

<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

g) m3aciIoJIOBaHHe, oopan=eHee S COKCyaMnHOe pa6crMo, pHHy CHHe K IlPoCT)iiYURH,<br />

npmHyAHeIt as 6epepCeHHOCrb, npHHynmlTebHag CTepmEH3BUH HMi modhic O ,yrue i 4)opMhi COKcyaJibHoro<br />

Hamcu conocraBwo0i TxecTm;<br />

h) npecszenosaaMe MO6OA K. HTH pyeMO0] rpynmi HUH o6UIHOM no nofHT~ecKJTM, pacOBMhM,<br />

HaMOHaRHUM, 91UHqeCKHTi, KyllbTyPHUM, PCEHrHO3HUM, reHiepHM, Ku am onpeceac'rcg B nyHim 3,<br />

HAM Apyn ?I MOTMM, KOTOpMl¢ noacemecrnho npM3HaHl HC OnyCTHXWMH cOrliacHo mex)JiHapomIOmy rlpaBy,<br />

B CBI3H C O6IMH nCRHHRMH, ymIuIhUMH B AaHHOM IInYHKC, HI n"M.MH npeCiTYMeHHJIMH,<br />

no.naA Ollnmi non IOpHCAHKgMo Cyna;<br />

i H aacewrselmoC Hc'e3oaeHe moneff;<br />

j) npeCMyiiieiie anaprew~;<br />

k) ApyrHe 6eceieHao e AesuHs alanorWMoro XapaKrepa, 3aKnioqalOlgueCA B YMhfECHHOM<br />

np'nmema CHMiX c'paJmaHu HnH CCPhC3 W mtneCHwX nopexaCHMA Hm Ccpbe3HOr yMep6a<br />

nO HlAeKoMy Him (bH3,iCecKomy 3AOpOabLO.<br />

2. Anil ueneA nymra 1:<br />

a) " HBaAlCHHC Ha nmo6hix rpaxlcKix aim" 03Ha'iaCT AKHMa nOB¢AeHi , BaYMoa'loyio<br />

mioroKpamoc cOBepnieHue axroa, yKa3aHHux B yHKrTe 1, npor u 111o6uIx rpuvmax cxmx juia,<br />

npefnpmHmiaemwx B ixnux nposeAeimsi noraIIHTH rocynapcmBa Ham Opratm3am, naripabneHmo Ha<br />

COBepMeHRe Taloro HalianaeH , HEM B ttcex cogenfcrBH TabOI nomTHxc;<br />

b) "HcrpefteH~e" BmoqaeT ymamnmeiooe co3AaHme ycjioHAi XH3, B qacmom m HHme<br />

Aocryna K npoAYKraM lHTaH H JleKapCTnd, paccgwramix Ha TO, NTO 6 u y uTMXHMS qac'm iacjieim ;<br />

C) "nop96oeHHe" o3Ha'aeT oCyUgecrlaeHme mo6oro Hum Bcex npaaoMoRHf, cal3aHoax c npaaoM<br />

co6cTBcHiocTH a oTmoineHul H'mOClu, H Bxmo'iaeT B ce6a ocyntecraeHH TaxHx npasoMo'h.g B xone<br />

TOpFOB1IH h1lOA;MM, H a "laCTHOCTH KeCHUHHaMH H LerThMH;<br />

d) "leIOpraTa RHI Him nacvambcmeHroe nepemeaHe HaceneHm" o3tqaieT HacHm ¢eOc<br />

nepemeuxHHe lmi, noAcpruOxCg BceneRMo w.ri mm npHMynnelnl. nAcrBmV, H3 paHOHa, a<br />

KOTOpOM OHo 3KxoHMo npe6dwamso, B oTCYTCTHC OCHOBaHHR, nOiyCKaCMbIX MCXJLvHaPOHLM lipaBoM;<br />

e) " l"WMH" o3sa'aeT yMusnnleHoe npwm'HMCme cmHofbii 6oaH Him cpanami, 6yni TO<br />

4m3ecxex Him nCHXHoCCKHX, A1y, Haxo tMemycg nox Crpamek Him noA KoriTponeM O6sHHeMoro; Ho<br />

nuamm He ciHraeTC olb M ii" crp&aH, Ko'opbiC Bo3HmxaoT nmmu, B pesyaba-M 3aKOHMUX CaMIIW,<br />

Hemtnemoad or mm cixWg mmn siw3IBai'r mdH cryiaftHo;<br />

f) "npmyAHTreamasi 6epeMeHoCr" o3Haae'T se3axoHHGeo meme Bo6omj KaxO f-H5O<br />

xcHurmnm., KoTopag cTa 6epeMeHHiol B npM puMnYT HOM nopJIe, c tnenio H3MCHCHRII amH'I4ecKoro<br />

cocraa KaKOro-,60 HaceieMHl Hm coepmem maux cepbc3MLix iiapyienHmf maelyHapoAIoro npaaa. 3ro<br />

onpeAeneMe HM B xoem cayaaC He HcTojIKOBLIBaCTsE gaK 3aTpaMBalIO HaUHOHaOnHOC 3aXOi0 ,aRelibCrO,<br />

KacaloMeeca 6epcMeRHOCril;<br />

g) "tlpeClenOBaHe' o3Ha'iaeT ymmuieEHHoe H Cepbe3HOe IMueMHe OCHOBHX apaB sonpeKH<br />

mexWJ6yapoA oMy npasy no npH3naBy npMHa. exMocn K TOH Mlii HmHo rpynne Hm mok o~ulioc'm;<br />

h) "npeTyfneime anapTeHs" o3navaeT 6ecqenoge'ooue AcficTm, aanoni'mue no CROemy


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

xapatrepy TCM, KO'OpbIe yKa3aKW B RyH erC 1, CoBCpMaCMIC 9 KOMKeCre CrKTKyUoaa.HKpoaMaoro<br />

pexMa ccremaorwemoro ynl€eeHHB m rocno1cma oAof pacozok rpylma HaA t pyrofh pacosoik rpyrmol<br />

Kil rpyrmaml H coBepUeM]e c Ixeabo coxpaIeHH Taxoro pexama;<br />

i) "HaCAhfbCrfeHHoe HCqe3HOBeHHe moogeft" o3Haqaer apeCCT, 3aXepalMH KRH noxaI=eae ntojel<br />

rocy~apcMoM M noMflrwtCoA opraHX3a1 a HlenH C ax paapCOeHsM, np ax nowuepxxe am. c ax<br />

COrcAa, npH nocnelyloeM OTM83c rpIH3H8Tr TaKoe JImaHH. Coo6oAl nRH o0001tmr 0 Cy~bOe anH<br />

MeCTOHaxoneHHHXgmx<br />

nCpHOA a BpeMeHH<br />

moa1d c LWxIO JimHmCHHj Hx 3a1HTh CO CTOpOHh 3aBOHa B TeeHH nAjrenbHoro<br />

3. JAu uenef Hacrolugero CTa'yra nonnaI'rcR, rTo repnmn "reailepabfj" a KoHTregc, re o eC<br />

omocrcs K o6om nonaM, MyxciOmy H XCHCKOMy. Tepnmm "rean ep l" He HaeeT Kaoro-.il6o mioro<br />

3HaI'CHR, OThH'4HOFO OT BbIlUCyrfOMf9yTOrO.<br />

Roeakme npoacnIegu.<br />

1. CyA oaaiaeT iopmcjIaUIef] B o'HomeHH oeHuix npecrynen1, B qacmocrm Kor a onm<br />

cosCpmeHu B paMKax nAana H.AH nojm",H amH npH KpyrToMacraOHOM coBCPMeHn T8xsX npecrynnem .<br />

2. An ileaci Hacro ero CraTyT socHue npecrfyrnmet o3maqwr:<br />

a) cephemmhe HapyiUcHuI )KeeBcKxx KOHBeHk oT 12 aarycTa 1949 rona, a mmeHao mo6oe H3<br />

CnlejYiOUX AeCAHiR nlpOTHB jii<br />

AceeacOfe zoHe=ma:<br />

Kl HMyuLCCrIa, OXPaHACM x cOraCHO nOfOXCHIM COOTheTCTByMeIi<br />

i) yMLnDCHHOe y6miicTio;<br />

ii) imhr' anaH 6ec'.eOBeqHOe o~pautenn, ino'mma (o, orm'ene sxcnepmwem-a;<br />

iii) yM~mnenHoC npHHnHeHHCe CanMblX vrpananafl HnH cepbe3KHx wenecnUx noBpexA HMAr Him<br />

ymep6a 3,iopoaslo;<br />

iv) HCe3OHOe, 6eccMucnemoe H KpyHoMacnaft6Hoe ymRqrozeue a npHcaoeHae xabwecrza, He<br />

Bba3BI mHoe BOCHHO1A HeO6xO11OoMo;<br />

v) npHmyxAeHee Bo onn,emoro Mien Apyroro oxpaHnemoro amea K cnyx6e a aoopyxe-nux caiax<br />

HCrlpHaRebCKOH pAepXaBI;<br />

vi) ymmumemoe namenHe BoeHHoneHHoro Hnm Apyroro oxpaiemoro amna fpasa Ha cnpanen moe<br />

H HOpMaJrhHOe cynonpoa3Bo crBo;<br />

vii) He3axoHaag AenopTatUn aH nepeMceItHme KAH He3aoHHoe amumeaHe cuo6om;<br />

viii) 3WMe 3a OXHKKOB;<br />

b)Apyre cepwe3Hc HapYIenXIM 3aKOHOB H 06 'acB, npHmeHlmobx a Me=yHapogHiX aoopyzennHiX<br />

KOarraX a ycTaHoaBnCeUx pamKax Mewnyuapomiom npaBa, a H MeCHo mo6oe HSi cne.ynowmx ueam.M:<br />

i) ymminemwbe HaIa.HKu Ha rpaxaHcKoe Haceneane KaX TaXoBoe o-rueawuhx rpazxancKxx<br />

JIHU, He nfpHRHnaJOWlHX HenocpecreHHoro y'iacrug B aoeHhiX AeAcjftK;<br />

ii) y'm mniJcH. e HanaJeHHx Ha rpaxaHCKa e 06C Mt , T. e. 06LCTe r, KoTopue He n ,giBDTCE


ROODDIMhf ixexumm;<br />

<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

iii) yamhfnmemoe Haiezcm¢e yiapoB no nepcoHaJiy, o6 m, MaTCpllaM, nojpa3gcaemmg mix<br />

TpaHcnOpiiiMM cpee'cam, 3aclflCTnOBaIuWM B oKamauu ryMatorapHOl noMoim mui B HUCOIi<br />

no noj tepxamo Mpas B cooTrmmum c Ycraom Oprumaam, 06mcjiHmwx HauA, noxa<br />

osa HcaioT npao Ha 3aIIWTy, KOTOpOiR flozwLymomT rpamUmCi as=IUS miii rpaZxnsHcKHe<br />

o6brrar no MCJZYHapORHoMy npaBy aoopYXemw J1 OHt 3rO;<br />

iv) ymw am aoe coacpIme HanajHeuuui, KOrn H3BCrMO ro TAKOC HarIJLHMC REUM fnpi'OuRih<br />

cjay'a"ioi nm6e amu Ysems,. rpazAamcvix mw mii ymep6a rpa a~ncwr o66exram mm<br />

o0tmpHoro, Aoircpaoiioro H cepheHoro yumep6a oKpyXWW¢Cf nppojwok cCjCA, KoTophift<br />

6y Tr RuO Hecowiimepum C KoHKxpCT H HenocpcACTeoHHo ojaCum o6nx IoCHmm<br />

flliBOCXOiiCUOm;<br />

v) Hffla=eHi¢ Ha HCUM ¢eHUC H He SMZ0M HeCq RH aOA LXAmKH ropoia, nepeaCM,<br />

wmnma a man 3Aamms mu Hx o6crpw C IpUMCHCHHC a9x 6U TO NIn 6bWO CPCACTE;<br />

vi) y6KRCMo AHu paaithme 1oM6afatuf, xoTopu, caoxmu opyxiie mi He IMCZ 6ovee cpeAcTa<br />

3anuu, 6eaoroaopoiio cAauicz;<br />

vii) HeRwexamne icno oaanme diaara napnaMciTepa 4iara mii noeHmH Hazon paamrum H<br />

4opum Henpirres wma Opamrsa=H Oftewcumnx Hawmf, a 'axe ol 'K4reflhimiaX<br />

su.qiem, ycranoeHHmI )KHeMH KOHniIi , caInCACMCM KoTOporo zmzeycM cbgePn<br />

mw npmEHCmHc ymepa mmocni;<br />

viii) nepemeimae, npSMo Bu KoCBCHO, OKKYUpyIlDICA AePXaSOl Racri Cc cadvrcmmoro<br />

rpaNxMcKoro HaccneuH Ha OXYiUpyeMyo eWc TeppiTOpIO, HU ACIOpTLB H B<br />

nepe ueiieme HacezCeim oKKyinpyemofi T'ppmopum nfl OTAe Jmmldx qacTe, cro a pe~ezax<br />

wHa 3a IIpe cma mTof Teppwrropan;<br />

ix) y]aMhnheuO HaH-icHe ynAPON no aHR4aM, WpeAu Halueim Am W I Cxe peRNIimm,<br />

o06paso uams, HCKYC-rsa, HaynH mI 6narorapPiire OCm, HCTOpIi'iCKHuiMaX THE B,<br />

VOCUMr'M H MecraM cOcpeAOTOqcmu 6oJMKUX R pHeX, ipH YCROBH, Ri OHM He<br />

zanmoTcA aoeinaMM Uemuii;<br />

X) npiMMCexMe¢ zaM, cOTOpMe HaxoARrfI no acTMO fpOTOHOA CMpOKl, 4PhiHiCCKHX<br />

ys¢auf n m coepecie uaA Hm mi eAiwMcx wa mm iayqHux sKcnepimaefros mo6oro posa,<br />

Ko1opuc He onpasAfamu tCo6xoxmoCrbjo MCumamucKoro, 3y6opaqe6Horo mii 6oumam'oro<br />

eqlCeHK cooTiaemTytoiiero ma H He OCYIeCTBSHO a 3 ro IpPecax H KOTOpLIC B3UBaOT<br />

cMepm MM CCphe3HO yrpoxaioT 3iOpOBIO Tl Koro mwa mm Jmu;<br />

xi) aepojobmoe y6Kwcrno Hm paaeuie ma, npimaAeexamU K HK 1piTMRa CKO iaW mm<br />

apMmH;<br />

xii) 3asit enic 0 ToM, 'R" noluajp He 6yner;<br />

iii) yui'OoeCHHe miii 3axaT HmyieCvma ilpHiirenR, 3a HCXMiOCeHM CyQ'eB, KOrA TaKOC<br />

yMHirOXeHHe mm 3aXaaT Hacrrenl.BO ARI i U R HOC HO6xOAKHOcMO;<br />

xiv) oftmeme amewmubH , npROCmaHOMlUCeMMi u U HeAonYCHMyCW B Cyne IIpaB K iCKOB<br />

rpawAaH npO"HSHOI CropoHm;<br />

xv) npunyxAeai rpaxjwi npO-HOi cropo-m K VqacTrwO a oeffgibx jwelcmH npax<br />

IR1lX<br />

co6craemoi cipanw, naxe eciJm oHu HaxomuRAci Ha cYx6e o0ouOeUI cFopoliw Ao Haqajia<br />

Rogmu;


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

xvi) pa3ra6nc me ropoma mm1 Na CylC14oFo UYHmr, uue emCCI oH 3Iuaqc1 mn2pM01;<br />

xvii) npCxmlec IA AH oMAN MgMHorO opyxaf;<br />

xviii) oPHUCHe Y)M'1UaMU X, XAOSUXIM IllE hipyfh raMsA MI H o6i,1X aHU 'awonMx<br />

HlOlOCTChI, MaWtpHJIO3 Jiu cp..CIB;<br />

Xix) npHUeHeHN n1YAS, KOTOpMl¢ B"e"O P3PpUMOTcI Hi1 CnDmJonW.H38OcI TJtIC VC.O8eKa, 1aKH,<br />

ux o6ozoq €ue nyim, TsepAui o6ozo'u coTopwhI He nioKpUmae DCero cepAeMUUK m<br />

HDCCT HaAPC36 ;<br />

xx) UpPeH RCHCH opyxHR, 60enpmIacol R Tae up,a ISIXt 10O4I ECH 01M1 TUKOrO<br />

Xparepa, KoTople aiU3aamT '4pesMepMdw no0PeXUM WIN RHeyxmhe CTpanAm Eim<br />

KOTOpbiC AMfMOTl HCHS HpamJIHmlImH no cmoel cyI a Hapymeaxe sopm e MHapoworo<br />

hlpaa BopyxCmwx KOHIbJHMo, npu yczoami, 'TO TAKoC opyXH, TaK€ 6oenpnacM,<br />

raa TenHm TKn mc0101 TOelmum 30i*4 mns npeMeToM acco6,CMmax01erv<br />

3anpe H H axJnoqaema m pomxma K macromuey Omrry nyreu nonpaBKx cornacHo<br />

CooTraerc yOnMy nonoxemao, Hmo3XHtomy 3 cTSTuK 121 w 123;<br />

Xxi) flocammem na qnofleaecmot locTomHHcI, a 'iacmgoci ociop6menwo H yffinalonzee<br />

o 6 pameamc;<br />

xxii) mmacxnoamm¢, o6pamcme a ceKcyanbhoe pa6cmo, Upxy'JeMCfe K npOClwryx1M,<br />

npmqymrne ag 6epeemHocrb, Kxa oa onpeencHa a nyme 2(f) c€ran' 7,<br />

npHmyl9Tenwa cTCpHimmmH H mo6uc jipynhc amp ceKcyumom Haama, Tame<br />

sn,8,0umect rpy6um sapymweHeu )KC1escJ xo mcHWI;<br />

xxiii) HcnonhsoaaemC npHcymCm1H 1IAIJAHCXOMo MW12 HE ,yroro OxpaHlIeMOro Jma An<br />

3all14Hr o1 sOCHHuX ICHCTmmH Ofpe114HHWX uynxKoa, paloaol ix boopyxemmHlx cmi;<br />

xxiv) yaaxmexoe iiaaccC14 yhApOB 0o 3AHMM, MBTepBI8, MO MHCKHM Y'(pc" HIgM H<br />

TpaHrcIOpn cCeACTM, a Ta1e ncpcoxaiy, HMoWJW63M M 8 COMM MIK C<br />

MeXMapoAHMu np80oM oTn4%M'Wr U sMUUeM, YCMTDUIMe C XKC1CNCKM KORHDMOULO ;<br />

Xxv) yMUMj rexoe coacpmeame ,eAcTIN, Houepraomm= rpajaaxoe HUICCflOHI roDO.Wy, B<br />

Kaqecre cnoco6a ACeHM aoSnu nyre nmeuxg IXeCM cr0 ¢leroa, HWeo6xaxl =l<br />

a111438414, 8K81'al ywhlmemoc cosjzaxe npmcniTB An11 npcmC~uC11H 11011111 gaK<br />

gTO npec loypewo s 3Ke~ascma KoHwmII;<br />

Xxvi) H p60P M CP6OKa nercI B. Bo3pacr ,A0 1MTHa 8 T B UCOraS H8HIOHaM81W<br />

OopYNCH4b[X c11 C m u XC1OZMM3o h Ans i1ro yacs a 6"oaBux AeicnhLfl.<br />

c)B cnyac eoopyxeHworo KoHdimKar HCMeCxyHaNpoorO xparTCpa celpICe3Hie HapyIemg craJTm 3,<br />

o6aleft wm qeTupex )Ke cmx xonsem o" 12 auycra 1949 ropa, a 11mo: o6oc H3 c€cj4i0oiI<br />

,,eMMA, coepmIeHH1x a omOfe4HRM M , HC OpHU aMm armworo yacr-I a BoCeHh ecrimu ,<br />

aKlM,,as DOMOCYIAopie,OI MI OPYXH, H M, UBCAMMUx H3 0rpo 1 pe1IbTwe 60,,e111<br />

pg4tMe1 cey,COh4P2sM no Crpzc8lk M no moo*1 ipyrok npamlm¢:<br />

i) nocxrTeJmhC ITa m a a1miOCm, a ,acrmo1 y6*crBo a mo6A 4opme, npmmcHae<br />

yBC'fi, xecrKoe o6pae.1e m1 ummx;<br />

ii) MocI1rT081SCll0a<br />

q,1CboseqecKoe AochTONHCIo, a qacm0c0 oclop6wIbHaoe H y'HHXIOIM<br />

o6palmame;


iii) r¢ 3RnOXHHXKOB;<br />

<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

iv) mu emet c npmroopoB m npH mH m B HComeHme 6m npemapw emuoro cyjge6nor0<br />

pa36HpaTeamc~ha, npoBeCeHHoro co3AaHiM B YCraHoBRCHMOM nopAU€ CyAOM, o6ecnCE'IBaloxovm<br />

co6nioAemHe scex cye6Hbtx rapaHTmA, Koropie no aceo6Mcmy npHmamm go,,Bmmos<br />

o63aTeJH L [M.<br />

d) UyHyTr 2 (c) npHmeHercB K BOOpYXCmOHUd KOH4florbaM HeMexWapoioro XapaUrepa H, TUM<br />

o6pa3om, ne npHMeCICTC K cnyuz HapymmeM BarpCrmero HOPIJUB H BO3HMKHOBCHHA HaplxCHHoCTH,<br />

TaKmm, KUa 6ecnopAtM, OTArmze H cnopaAqecme am HaCuMaI HR T le BmuhE aHanomHoro<br />

xapaKTepa.<br />

e ) Ipyrm€ cCpbe3HUe HRpYIICHMA 3aXOHOB H 06b aep, IPKMeHHdl~IX 8 Boopy-ICHHx KoHimirTax<br />

HtMexwnapoAHoro xapaxiepa s ycraHoauneHix pamKax mezJyHapoAHoro npaaa, a MCHmo M0o6oe H3<br />

cjq c9lyxou~ax €.aaH*:<br />

i) ymmiuimemHoe Hafeceme yJApOB no rpa,'UHcKOMY HaCeIeHlO xKa TaKOBOKy, a TaKXe<br />

yMbunaeHHoe HanaeHme Ha oTIenaiwx rpaz~iUHCAI .zmI, M He nPmHMoUMX<br />

Henocpec-meHHoro y'acTu a PoeHowx ¢Aegc'm ;<br />

ill yIbim eHHoe Haecemee y~apoB no 3AM , MarepRaUaM, MCMHIIUCKIH y'qpexACHM H<br />

TpaHcnOpThILM4 cpencAra, a -WXe UepcoHajUy, HCnO.n3yIOltHM B COOTBeTCrlHiH C<br />

Mex Hapo H M apaBoM oT rjne bwe qM6aemlm, npeacmoTpetHMe )KeHeacxamm<br />

KOHB HW4IMH;<br />

iii) yMmlueHHoe HaMeceHme yj apoB no nepCOHaJy, O06exRaM, MaTCpHaRaM, lOIPBAegieHHxM HuM<br />

Tp&HCnOpTHbIM CpeCnCTB3M, 3BAef4c'BrIoW?M s oKaaBHMH IU aHHTapHot nOMOH MHR B MHCCHH<br />

no noj.epxa'mo mpa a comrreacmHx c YCTBBOM Opramuagiw O0feARemux Hawlft, nona<br />

OHN Hmei0T OpaBo Ha umIBIIM , Koropok nomiaaymourv rZpaHCKHe JIHHa HiI ipa., I cKMe<br />

o6"earm no mexjyHapoA oMy npaay BOOpyXeHHU KoH4IJ,.oZWB;<br />

iv) ymmIuIcHHoe HaHeceHme y~apoB no 3aMHim, npelau3aweMud An gee penum,<br />

o6pa3osam, HcZYcCTR, HayKu HAR 6zaioTvopHTmaHocTH, H CopHqCCXM naMrnmI am,<br />

rocfHTaXM H MCCTaM COCPeAOTO'iCHMB 6OJhHMX H parMetal, npH yCJIOBMH, '0 OeM He<br />

RBJTIOTCB BOCHHUMH LteAIMH;<br />

v) pa3rpa6nem ropoea HEM HaCe.lelOrO nyarraT, Aaxe CU OH 3fr IyIPMOM;<br />

vi) H3HaCH1oBHMe, O~p1)CHHe B CCKcya.JlHOe pa6CTBo, [IpHHyxJeHHe K npOCniTRyw.,<br />

npHHyMrebHaA 6epeMeRHocrn, Ka oa onpe. ese a BB nYHM 2 (f) cramis 7,<br />

npmHyIHTwl.H crpuH3aBW H m6u€ Apyrn€ RHAW CegCyIalorO HaCamII, TamXe<br />

npecranhoue co6oi rpydoe Hapy€lu€me cramie 3, o60eil = qeTIpex )KeeBcKX<br />

KOHeHUMA;<br />

Vii) HB6oP Ham Bep6oBxa Ar a ospacre ADL9raM o<br />

neT a cocraB aoopyxemmx cHE HnM<br />

rpynln H u HCOJW3OBaHHC HX AnnB aKmHOriO y'acTrH B 6oenax Aefcu=;<br />

viii)oTrata pacnopaxeM,,i o nepeMemeRum rpaxaHCKorO MaceneMxA no npH'WMM, CMB HHUM C<br />

KOMIuJTHKTOM, CCH TOllbKO TIrO He TpegyioT coo6pasenmz 6e3onacHocm coo'emmcpyonero<br />

rpaXMWCKorO Hact.CHI HAl HacToKfreThMm HeO6XO)IHMOCrh BOeHmOrO xaparepa;<br />

ix) seponomMoe y6Hkcrao HmaH paeeme Kom6amarra HcnpxHIeI;<br />

x) 3ayJCHHC 0 TOM, q'TO nOgaAM He 6yAer;


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

xi) UpH9MCHae nHrWtM, KOThpLe HaXOWM' C 0 BUM N AfC'h 1pJro7r CpOHE a KOH4JMH , H3HCCKKX<br />

yseqHA IH coacpuieHle naA HHmIH mCOHLHx xaH HamY'mix sxcnepImemwoB .o6oro poa,<br />

KOTOphi He onpaaH Heo6xoAHmocmlO MeHiwUcxoro, 3y 6 oapaqe6Hon HJIH OMniawwoo<br />

neqeHHR CoaMCeTey1o0 ero 0H111 H He OCYUecrBoTcB u erB<br />

CMHrepecax H ICMPLe<br />

npw iurOT CMePTh HnH CepbC3H0 yrpoXaloT 3jiopOBWO TaKOrO jima HMl iMM;<br />

xii) YHKVMXCHie HH 3aXBaT Hmywecra HelpHgre.n, 3a uCKmmICemed cxyqaea, K0or'a 'axoC<br />

yHH roXCHI HAH 3aXsT HaCTOI'reTbHO lMKo O6Cr'M'CToITCremmaMH KOHU4lrTa.<br />

f) nyixr 2 (e) nPHMCHXIeCR K BOoPYXeHHMM KOH4bAHKTam HCMCN.HapoAJHoro XapawPa H, TaXHM<br />

o6pa3oM, He npHmeMLeTCa K CI YaE HapyCeNHI sHyrpeHmero nopxa H ao3HoKHOeHHA HInpzxeaHoCTH,<br />

TWW, KU 6eCnopgjia, OTAMJbHLe H CopaqeCKHe ax1 HacHJIHKa Hi mie a.xT8 alllao uoio<br />

xapawrepa. OH npnmeHxe-ae B 0ToiUeHHH BoopyxeHHwx KOH4IArrB, KOTOpblC 8140r MeCO Ha<br />

TeppropIIH rocy~apCaa, 0o1r HAV'r nWrmMuft BoopyxeMM KOH4)HKrT MeXM Upaawemme m<br />

BA8CTIMH H opraHM3OBa-btM4H BOOpyXCHHeMH rpy'nraMH Hi MMM CaHa, TK848 rpymnaMH.<br />

3. Horro a nyuHrax 2 (C) H (e) He 3aTparHiaeT OTCTCrCmHoCrH fpas ma 3a nOJflACpXHHC HJIH<br />

BoccraoTSH0 e 31oa H nOPABJIa B rOCyuapc'BC ME, 3a 381U11Ty CJI8 HCTI H TeppHTOpHaUioa 1lei1ocHOcIT<br />

rocyIapTsa BumH 3aKOHHIfhMH CpeIcraam.<br />

'4nCMCHTM nn&MeIICHtkm<br />

1. S.ze.eeemu npccHAe a nokoraMor Cyji a ToiKoaamm H npHmmedeH N craTei 6, 7 H 8. OHM<br />

npIaWrc G0ME IC8OM B Oe TPVM rOIOCOB IneHoaB ACcMa6acH rOcyapcB-y-'acrHHKoB.<br />

2. 'lonpaxH K 9JreMeHTam npecrynveHf Moryr 6um npe~noxclm:<br />

a) modu rocy1Apcmom-y(a1H4Kom;<br />

b) cyaun , apHHmHmaiomm peeHHe a6comormTi 6onmlcrmom;<br />

C) fpoxypopoM •<br />

Tamen nolpaBKm npmH8ammr 6onhm CmoM B A3€ TpeTH ronocoB 'JUCHOB Accam6nem rocyiapcrB-<br />

YUCT HKOB .<br />

3. 3Jcuemi ,pcCryrMeHHA H nIIonpaKH K HEM Haxora t 8 cooavercH c HacroxwHm3 CTaryrmm.<br />

Crams 10<br />

HHxrro a HamCromeft acTH flonoxemta 0 HCHaHCCHHH yMepda He on Eo ncroJmKal8u88r x1<br />

Ka8M 6b1 TO HE 6Ueo 0opa3oM orpaHH' =oet Hae ,AeJ-rMyim e 11 cMaWmazouIeca HOpI<br />

MaYapoWoro npaBa Him HaHocxiuce 8m yatep6 Am LUeack, oTar8Hb1x OT 11en11K Hacroimero CTaiyra.<br />

CraMS 11<br />

IOoVHcn mHs ratione temporis<br />

1. CyA 061a1Cr IoPHcJAHKI~f TO810 B OTHOIICHHH flpeCrYnCHA, COepIMeH x nocue Bcryre8HHR a<br />

cmO HaCrtUero CTaTra.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

2. Em Kauo-.mJo mcyiapcmo crnoamu ytacrmmtom HacrotCro Cyrm nocij cro acryuems<br />

cHay, CYA MOleT OCYtMCCEM CBOO IOPXCMoIO JimXM a oBmomMM npcczmMI, coepnCHm, zx nocie<br />

Bc17UOCK B CMY H8cTOoUZCIt ClaTy'a JAS roro rocyJapcrMa, ecM TO Jo aM rocyXpcra He cACMr<br />

3anaheHe moraumo yHtrry 3 crmma 12.<br />

Cramiv 12<br />

Yong" o 0=i..1msufo~rmm<br />

1. Foc M , Koopoc craoaM yaCTHO siacAaMizcoM C'rayra, UpMsSer reM caTOM<br />

mpHcmIwI Cya B omomemm npmeC'ym€n , yxa aim i craie 5.<br />

2. B coyt noiwyarroa (a) m (c) crami 13 CyA MOXer OCymCMH CaOIO IopaW=M, e=M<br />

OANO H HOCKOiJMO H3 HXCYKe3a=HIHX rocy apm anmorca yMacnmaMM HgCrauC O CTarv Ta HAM<br />

nPIIa3 IO wpEamMo Cyja B co raa c nyarrom 3:<br />

a) wcypp=, n Teppmopa Koropom meyo MCro AmHEo Aunt m, le upecincwamm 6bmno<br />

CowpMeHO Ha 6opTy MOPCKOo KU aI mOS3UMrO CywHa, rocyjKapcrao pCrllc'pN 9mm MOPCO0 aHIM<br />

B03aVMHOro cyAla;<br />

b) mcy~Apcmo, rpa~mom KoTopoO suzerc ,nuo, 0oBallemot B coapmcaaa npecwiznea.<br />

3. Ecm a coomrcma c nymmm 2 Tpe6yerca npaaama apcxmm roqAy ,pcrom, He aumon ca<br />

y'acmrOam iaacromneo Crmyra, io rocyiapfrso MOXlr nocP MM 3rs Nem, npcAl eimoro<br />

Cexperapio, npm am ocymecrnem Cywm iopxc wm a oBmomemn ABIHOro n'pecrYnaemm.<br />

RpH3Hmaauje rocyjaprno cwpyiIaeT c CyAoM 6e3 Kalx 6a To m 6wzo s pxCe a acHJn l Om¢lq B<br />

cooTrMC aa C 'aCmio 9.<br />

Crama 13<br />

CYA MOXCK'Mwmnm caoxO IOpRcjaiUMo S oMOMCMW KaKoro-M.o fpeciynefau, y9a8awero B<br />

c"aT5 5. B cOO Ta C nOozcleMnn Hacmzzero CTya, mm:<br />

a)calyax o opH KOTpo~f, a nupeJuc1ahlarci, 6hmia Co] mCHMl OjwO ann lIC1K0.bO TaI X<br />

npecmmome , ne.eam~ Ilpoxypopy roCyapcrOamo-y'acrmlom B coorshClC co c~rt'eiI 14;<br />

b)cwiyaua, apH KopoR, KU tpeCMM¢CM, didSH co pmiz 0aiO KIDM HtCKOJfhKO TIM<br />

npec rYnMH, rCPeIC8Ia lpoypopy CoeroM e nona CRo , A[ecrsyionpea HR ocaoBaa ri.iam VII<br />

Ycraaa Oprianauna O6wiemiux Hatmfi; Kua<br />

cTimek 15.<br />

c) lpoKypop Havfaf pa 0B8eJI Bosa omomcIm EOe TaKoo npwDyeim B wCOOTBn co


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

CTanhg 14<br />

flapoeaa Cm'VWTm mcajacm-w3aenmzou<br />

1. rOcyfpcBK o-Y'acnlHK MOXC' UepCeAM lpoypopy cH'yaWH0, ripH KOTOPOA, KX DpcJMcruamemc1,<br />

6hWHa cOcpIUCl OO -- n HCxKOMKO Upccw'rUm1mfi noAna4r, umX noA IpHcAHI Cyfa, o6paMucb it<br />

flpoKypopy C npocbof npocm paccue,uoC ane yTmo cmaxmm An onpeAcem -ms oiDo, C€eMTyr im<br />

npegiim o6imeRe O.lHOMy HM HeCKOJIbKHM KOHKPenMWM jjMflaM 3a coaepmeHme Tamxli npeCynneHni.<br />

2. Hacioazo 3,m BO3MOXHO, 1pM n peit a CmaHm Kau Tailom oHq-'fmhe coaru~vM uxfe<br />

o6CroM T -rsa i npHKarae=cs TBKBa nOATBePX aa JoyAOKYMeHTBRI, KOToPag HmOC7S B panopzzexHM<br />

rocypapcna, nepenaioMero CMyauWo.<br />

ormns 15<br />

1. Ilpoxypop MozeT Bo36yzA' pacenoBaHme proprio motu He OHOBC HHtOpMBIgIM o<br />

upec .yniw, nOOAIMOUMx nop pHC~ CYaR.<br />

2. ilpoxypop oilemaeT cepbe3HocTh no. n y' oft HH(bopMaw. C mfot Ulea OH Hu 0ia Moxer<br />

3aflpaia jflo'b feflbHylIo pMaHIO Y McyapCTB, opr-B Oprmaw 06 ammxn Hammi,<br />

Mexnp Bh"TCtHIOmX mm He¢pa.mwenrH-mx opraH3alEDi MAR R13 Hlux HaACWHM iCro'MMxOB,<br />

KOrOple OH Ml oK a Co0 r nOXIOAM1fflM, H MozOT nO'yRiM nmCMHRIe WIM YCIMe COMATeaJC a<br />

MCCrC npe6mzaiuu Cy~a.<br />

3. Ecu rlpoxypop Aezaer BMoA o Hamm AocITommm ocMoBami An B0o6yXJICHem pacdaetoamm,<br />

oH mm oHa o6pamaerc B flaary npwapwremmoro upoHBomcn c npoc-6oiArm f- caHKMMO HB<br />

apoAcmp e pacczejwamMz BeUCC C .nO&M llORKpCWtMMMp. M M17 FnPOCbY CO6PaMMMH MATCPHaxam.<br />

floepntam~e Moryt AcaTr npel€racneHm, rlua aa Cf npefapWmtAHoro Tl IPOMRI 3CrAa B COoTC CrCM C<br />

flpamaa npotle;Wph H ,loxa3bBaHMt .<br />

4. Ecim HBaTHaIr npcflBApmvnhHor'o npomOJcTes nocne myqcmm Tof nipoch6ba H nouwpenammoex cc<br />

maTrpeanOn covmT, 'To xmemOxca IocnrvOmIbie ocnonaZm- Au B036yxReBn pacc=eo~amn H rm sro<br />

ACJO, CN 170 SCCM, nlolfafaCT FiOfi IOPUCAMMUHO Cya, OHA AaCT CKHEIO Ha B3o36yzeI iR<br />

pacccAoBSaHas 6w, yngep6a noczcpy'owmi onpeeacemn Cypa B oMOWcHmN EoPHCIImam H IpHeM.I¢MOCrm<br />

ACZa K nPOH3BOACY.<br />

5. O'ram auaTh npcemapwmCIuhoro npoH3aoAc paT, calIItmo Ha paCC.I€OB8Ue He McxMoqacT<br />

Bo3mommocm nofal'M nocn1mteik upocb m [IlpoKypopoM Ha OCHOISHHI HOB, IISaKro HJI CBKieTCI ,<br />

naeOnmx OTHOmCmw K TOA XC cryMIM.<br />

6. Eczn nocae npelaapliTcnmworo st, nmu, o Ko'opom roBopmwZ s nymr1 1 H 2, flpogypop<br />

npHxoAiT K BLeSooM, ,no npe mcJCBIHHaeU mH4)opMaliZM He COICpZxT B c6e AocTaToqmx OCoBaLUIR AU<br />

paccjiI.oBaHMI, TO OH HMH oHa HMoopMHpyer o6 3OM Tex, To npeATSamn sry m H114opMaixHuo. 3ro He<br />

HCK,.,lameT BO3moXHOcTH paCcMOrpem FipoKypopOM nrocJyloneCmmel HHcbOpMBwo, np l'mnM k Cy emaI Mm<br />

eik B OmoUmmm TOk XC cwryauWH B CBwrC HOBbx 4IBXTOB mum CzaCtICrecB.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

CTBMM 16<br />

Oreno'ies a lcatnogaBW WT vnrnmnomenag<br />

HHaxoc pacca¢oamme Hm yToinoBfo npecaouHeo~aHe me0N T HHwuawa A16o npoomwmca B<br />

coorarcmem c ac-imwmm CTaTyOM s Teqeem nepHoa B 12 MectueB nocne TO, KaX CoaeT<br />

Be3o'acliocr B pe3oIrAoliI, 1HRpWM0A Ha OCHOBaHWH FiB.BMw VII Ycrua OpramiHwH3 O1.cAK"ewC MX<br />

HaLmui, o6pamaeica B CyA c n poa6oik Ha ww cqe; ma npoc6a MoxeT 56um noTopeCHa COBeChM<br />

Be30oacHocrI rpH Tex ze yCJIOBIX.<br />

CTaMM 17<br />

Bornpem flDHCmiTCmoC<br />

1. C yqcio.M nymrra 10 npeam6yJim H cTaThm I CyA onpeActenT, ,To JleJio He MoeT 6hm npHHMrro K<br />

rnpOH3B0ACMy B TeX CMy'IOX, orla<br />

a) Am-ioe jAca.o paccjiw€ercm Hm oTHomemmu cro BO36yzJWo yrOroBHoe apeCAoBBme<br />

rocy;apcraoM, KoTopo e oSjllaT B OTIOwenHm ero iopHC oHuefs, 3a HCKJIIO'CHeM CA SB, Korea M<br />

rocy~apcBo He esaceT MM He cnoco6Ho Bec paccfe1oaamHc Hm Bo36ywm yronoBWoe npecneom e<br />

AOmawIM o~pa3oM;<br />

b) ej o paccnexoBao rocyapcsM, KOTOpOe oftlAacr iopWcAm eie B o'rHoiueWmJ Hero, H 9Th<br />

rocyMapcrao PCfHZl O He B036Y1ATh B OTHOUCHWM ZHma, KOTOpOO MTO KBCacVcI, YrOJIOI'Oo<br />

rFpCCeAosaHHS, 3a HCKmOqeHHeM cnyaeB, Kor1a 3TO peme¢HHC C'a O pe3yT1aTBoM HexetamIs Ha<br />

HecnocoOHocTm ocyAapcrga B036Y11W" yrojioo p meoRaHHC AOa1 HiM O6pa3OM;<br />

c) mmo, Kmlporo 9Th KBcacacB, YMC 6LwIO CYJIKo 3a floBCueWe, KOTOPOC laUliTCa opeJMeThM<br />

AaH oro 3ama1eWmA, u upoeeHxe cyJeZ6oro pas6pBpelmcma CyAoM He pap3PCeHO Ha OCHOBaEm<br />

nyII~a 3 emv'mT 20;<br />

Cyia.<br />

d)AeJIo He maCmcJ AocrBT'omo cepC3m, 'rhMd or1paBBJAuJ8Th AaweHkwiHe ,AeicncBr co CmopoHLM<br />

2. IqTO6d B zmaB s KaKOM-aSO KOHIpYWOM ,VCfl Hex-IBWUC, CyA npmmaw s Bo BHmamic upWWuI<br />

ymJIOBHoro npoutecca, IUPH3HaWHMC MCZJQyH8POThN T1paSOM, Y'MWBBCT HanITWC, =H11 9Th IpHmexWM.<br />

o0or IrT HecxombKWX caeIYoCumWx 4)aKTopoB:<br />

a) cyAe6Hoe pa36HpabTh.Tmo 6bwo npoBtAcHO w.a npoBo1mCNA 11160 H1aIOH.aaHID peweax.e Ohubo<br />

BsweceHO c geab1o orpaBJiH cooTye¢mponlec .IO OT yronoBo OTe mCaeHocW 3a npecryuie nms,<br />

nom1nalome noA )OpHCAKXMIH HacToxmero Cy1a, o Koropux roaoplerm B craTm 5;<br />

b) mmCia mCCTO Heo6ocoeWoBaHu 3agepxKa c nrpoaemem cyAe6Horo pa36HpTem lam , KOTOpu B<br />

CIIoXwrnl xCRi O6CTOnrT aX HecOBMeoCTIB C HaMepem4cm npMam comeTCayIOUw¢e jIHIIO npaaocylwo;<br />

c)cyJedHoe pa36HpaTem.CTBo He nPOBOHJIOCh HAm He UPOB0oMU1C8 He3aHCm(Eo H 6ccpaC'pacTmo H<br />

flOpgOK, B KOTOPOM OHO flPOB0 oWIOCb HH 1POBO1WTCe, B CeIOXWm8HXCs O6cTODIATamctx 8 mBCE<br />

HCCOBMCCTMM C HadepeemeM npelamh cooTBcmyioauee amIHo npaBocyAWjO.<br />

3. '!To6U BbJIBWMT B KBKOM-AIWO KOHpMPCTOM AeneC eC1[OCOGHOCrb, Cy T i YR'WETbIaeT, B COCT OXHWH 1H<br />

11.,HHOC rOCyO pCro, B CBx3H C 11Om hNI 1114O CyIIcrCHwm pa3101M HaW orcyrc HeM CBoch<br />

Ha1IoHalo cyjie6Hok CHCTCMm, fOFlWMr B coe pacuopsxcHme o6BeHH¢Moro nH O Heo6x0o¢iue<br />

Aogaaem~mauhCTa m CBKJICMt bCKI noa3axmA H xe OO He a cocmHW ocymecrallarb cy~e6Hoe<br />

paA6mpaTcITr eme no xaBW-Hdo npHwtmam.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

Cmmih 18<br />

rlPI nw refapn~M e rpcn Tal nl tr , IACBPJD HBC npMjeMaeMCTH<br />

1. B Tex caymaanx, xora cHiyawHs 6hina nepcjaaa B CyA B cooThvCrcmh co cTaTbe f 13(a) m<br />

flpoxypop onpecam, ,o HMeOMTcI pa3yMuHC oCHOBBHfTB ,A Ha'maa paccacJourxx, HAH ccAH IpOKypop<br />

HaqaJl paccJoancJWB B COOT MTCHH CO CcTbo H 13(c) It 15, RlpoKypop HanpaiieMT yBeOMneHHe BCeM<br />

rocyapcrBaM-y'acnru4aM H "reM roCyCapCrBM, KOTOPhI¢, Y' UThZBBB UMMoeLyOM 1 4opMauHIO, o6WqHto<br />

OCyulcCIBS 6u iopHquxww B OTHomcHHH taiowx iipecrynnenl. ipoxypop MozeT yBCelOMJlsb TaKHe<br />

rocyjapcna Ha KoHubH4emWaJMlioA OCHOBC H, CJH fIpoipop cq'naeT Hco6xoj.mwim o¢cneqwrh aHTy<br />

AM,, upeponpawm y crmoxeiuee Aoxe aTbCm HaH nouemam cKpmrLCw imame, OH MOX T orpaHHImHb<br />

o6-eM mH4IopmWm , npej ocln'ueoifj rocylapcmhoM.<br />

2. B Te4ae osHoro Mocauia C MOMHTa noiyeupi TaKOFO yseZOMioHH cylOCpCTBo MOXKT COO6I.H1b<br />

CyAY, o OHO BCACT KiH UPOScJIO PaCCJICAoJaHB e B OTHOmeHHH COHX rpaP.,aH H ,YX Pl IHI,<br />

HaXOZA=H AC noA cro lOpHCKW=le1, Ha lpe~eT" yroxosHO-Ha~a3yeMux JAexHHl, KoTophie mory'r<br />

npeAcraurr. co6ol upccrynnexmn, yKa3aBH e B cTaT 5, H KoTopbMe HmeoT O'MOIUCHHe K HH4bopmauHH,<br />

cowepAZ egcg B yleoMefH , HanpaiemoM rocy. apcn . ro npoch6, aroro rocy.iapcma lpoKypop<br />

nepeace paccaJ]goBHJ4e B OTHOII CHHH TflX AHII rOCyiApCrBy, 3a HCKrOA4CHHCM TCX Ci y'Iae, Kora Tlana a<br />

nfpeJABap'iLoro npoH3ocr a no xoAaTacmy IlpoKypopa pemaeT pa3peuumr npo.A.elme paccie~oaH..<br />

3. Coruacxe IIpowypopHaHa nepeoaqy paccnenoB BHh rocyCapc"By MoxeT 6hb UepuMopCHo nlpoKypopom<br />

B 'ae e mec'rx McMlen nocie Mu BUm€mS pemeims o nepeAl e Hu B mo6oe BPCMZ<br />

riocie TOo,<br />

Ka npox3om o cyiuccTBeHoe 3MceHImCHH<br />

06CTOfTiTbCTB s pe3yJxbTa'T HexeilaHiA HAM Hecnoco6HocMi<br />

rocyapCTBa gOJIIIWM o6pa3oM upoBecrx pacci¢JoBaHmC.<br />

4. Coonm oyoige rocy apcmo tuam fpoxypop MoryT o6xanomam pememe falaTbi npami ap cnboro<br />

apow3BoAmcTB B Ane ucUMO0o uk nIBAJB B c oToCCBHH CO crahef 82.<br />

B YCKOPCHNOM UopZxe.<br />

Anemux MOIeT 6bTM 3acilyIIaJa<br />

5. Korea ripoxypop nepeeacT paccen BImIoae B cooehrc'nTm c nyitOM 2, OH MOzeT npocHrh<br />

coom'erarryiowec rocyjapcrao nepmoA'ecKH cooOuZrrb emy 0 XOAC upoiBoenHMx gm1W r0cyUapCTBOM<br />

paccneoBazA H mo6hx nocicjyOI Mepax cyeOHOrO npecjcAoaamm. rocy~apc'ma-yacThHHx oT e'alo<br />

Ha TBWc 3a.poci, 6e3 HcOnpaBlaaHux 3ajepiez.<br />

6. Io BMHMCHHI noC1oaBHen fIaToil flnpAsapffMaro rrpoxJocaTB H B mo6oe BpeMg nocie<br />

Toro, Kax Ilpoxypop ncpeqJ &aKoe-ji6o paccneoIc B coOwTcmT c HacroIIek crae, npoxypop<br />

MOXeT, B nopijexe HcxIo'eHM, 3anpocTm pa peCHe or Ilaiam npeaapfTe omo nPoH3B0ocTBa Ho<br />

opmBmTC HCo6xouHMi.Xm Mep a o iracn" paCCeJCoBaBIB As itci coxpaHcHH jeoxaaTeibcrB B TeX ciiy'aix,<br />

KOr& CyUiICCrByeT YHKK&IhHBI B03MOXHOCMh no]y'Urb BawKIOe AOKa3BnIbCTBO HIm HMeCTCB CcpbC3Ha<br />

OnacRocr TOPO, mr Taxoe Aoxa3an cow BaOCJici'cBHH no$iy]mb 6y.Cer HeBO3MOIHO.<br />

7. rocyAapcBo., octiapHBIouee UocraHoBeHec fluanan npcA~apineiinow UpoH3otCT-B B cooTeTcT'HH c<br />

HacToMef came'ct, MOxe'r OnPOTCrcTOBr npHeM cMOerh AMJIA K nPOH3Bo tCTBY B COOTBTCTBHH CO<br />

cram7be 19 Ha ocHoBuH-, ,eonoJiHHTenbmx Cyige1CCTewbix 4IaKToB in cyqecTCmHHOrO H3MeHeHHI<br />

06cTrJhcro


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

Crana 19<br />

flrmeau a ifiommmm mpucnxn amii Hi<br />

flnjlMJncTh Inejia K ITnlmrafnhi~iv<br />

1. CyA Ajgoea ywC Roacpmca a ToM, To on o60aaCr MpnRCXzaMte R OnocMOM 9.cn,<br />

HaxomferocW Ha Cr paccaMUpWHmH. CyA MOXeT CaoHM PMcWRHeM onpe m npHaccenoc, AMII K<br />

npomaoR-roay B cwmoic n co craT o 17.<br />

2. flpoVTcmW a OTHOm CHne npawcMoeMOCTH KAa K poHao, c'rny no ocnosaeanm, ywaHurum a<br />

cmTme 17, mm npoiecmi a omomen iopnmcHmxu Cyna moryr 6 m npmiecciu:<br />

a) o6ammaIm MM .OUd, Ha KOTOporo 6hL0 uBa Opnep Ha apecr um npHmK3 o Eute B CyA a<br />

cooe-rm co cm't 58;<br />

b) rocy.Apcmo, o0ilainO mM 30pgc-M eg 3 07H1OM1canE Aena, Ra TOM OCHOBEIR. , qTO ORO BeT<br />

paccao aMe AU yrooaoe npcc, oBaBae TEo AnY HEa upoBaco paceIaUMiae a yroaoC<br />

nPeCoeAaMae; an<br />

C)rC poAoMM, OT KoTOPoro "l CdyCcs npH3ARHac HplHC BKOa B cowTBrwmC m co cTmimik 12.<br />

3. Ilpoyop MoxcT npocH CyA mwmBCCR noc'razoucn ce no onpocy o 3pcxommI R amm<br />

pnTePOUCc-n. IlpH pacCMo7Pea onpca o IOPUCAUWItH aiM Up cMJIMOCTW ie, 37o nepeiw CHTYaUMo<br />

a coomcimuer co cameT 13, a Taxe novepnemme moryr uxue npccra ru Cyujy cSoR 3aXeqaHi.<br />

4. l'pHewxe om na K npoAm€sy amm iopacpl CyAa moryr 6am onporecoamz aOmno oemm<br />

pa3 mo6,,, imom Ha rocyAapmom, yumazm 3 nyarc 2. Ilpomecr AaM Owm 3asuci no nagaina<br />

UH a Haqajie pa36apaTeiorha. B acznomaurenmx cxy'vax CyA Mower paapeninn nojm. nporect 6oace<br />

oAnoro pa3 A noc.e Havana pasidparencra. flpoei a omomemm npe eoc O m eC a K<br />

npOasaOCcMy, 3ananICM~e a Hag.e pa36pZapUnM M Snoecmaa C pa3pemenan Cyna, Moryr<br />

noJaaamn TOAao Ha ocaouanm nojmyura (c) y 1 crami 17.<br />

5. rocyApeo, yKa3aanao a nozoymrmx (b) a (c) nyira 2, nonner npomrcr npa E6nunfimc<br />

S0MO]I OCTM.<br />

6. Ao yTDepxJemm o6ammenuft nporecm a omemm npncueurawm nea K upommocrHim<br />

UponeComr<br />

a omomeM IOPHPR Cyw Hanpaazmoca a Ilanary npepapwreaioro npcoznacnca. Iocne<br />

yiepzemma o6ammeaa oma naupaunmnrci a Cyie6nyio naary. Pemenna a omoMeHan cpAcMPM EM<br />

np CMmocrJI moryr 6wm o6aneaai B AnewU oRyIo naza'y a coomrecu'saa co ca~nhe 82.<br />

7. Ecma e nonp na rocyApraca a comcmcmnua c nootyH&run (b) am (c) nymm 2,<br />

flporypop npnociaaaa pacneoaaose A TOro apexcUR, ror CyA aaiaecer onpejeneane a<br />

coomercraam co crameji 17.<br />

8. Ano auNeceum nocraoaeOM CynA IIpopop MOxcT 3QPOCR y Cyja PopemeiRC:<br />

CTAmm 18;<br />

a)aa npoaenaae aKaHx Hcodxoa6 A cne'cMHox MeponIpanm', xoropuic yga3aa B nyr 6<br />

b) n nony'eaae 3auneas AM OKa3aa-eA or cBRereAA HAN Ha 2anepoCHc c6opa H Hy'MM<br />

AOKaDnT I , XoTopLue GiH Ha'"AO Ro nOaauz Kipoalcra; H<br />

c)aa npewmpamnl e, 8 corpyArecmre c cooire=MyionnMR rocynApOMaUM, no6era M, B


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

o'momem n Korophix fpoypop yle 3apocHl OpJep Ha apecT a coolf'recrmi co c'Tbee 58.<br />

9. Iojaa npoTecra He 3aTparMaer AeflCTBl OCTIH flo6oro efcrcBH, npenpmurroro IIpoKypopoM,<br />

HnH itooro opjopa HIAR pacnopxxeHmx, ormmmoro CyOM ,to no, aB'H npoTecra.<br />

10. Ec=i CyA pernn, 'ro Aero augeTcJ HenpHeMIeMhIM corzacHo crinse 17, flpogypop MoxeT<br />

npenc'rarm npocb6y o nepecCorpe 3orO pelceH, ,eCA On nOOHOCTIO yBWpeH B TOM, 'ITO OMpU lHCb<br />

HOBM 0GCTO CBJIbhTBa, B CHnIY KOTOpbIX OTiuaJaioT OCHOBaHHR, no KOTOphIM AemlO paulee dublJO nPH3HaHO<br />

HenpHeMIeMbm cornacHo crame 17.<br />

11. ECIH npoKypop c y'wrom BonpocoB, 3arpamlBaemMx B cTme 17, nepenaer paccneoABaBHe, oH<br />

MOxeT o6paiam'c x COOTehrII otMy rocy~apcTay c npoch6og o npejocraamemm flpoxypopy m4)OpMaxWW<br />

o OpOH38o0Crnc no amoMy ey. lo npocb6e coomaesc'mymmtCro rocyAapc'ma o6ecneoaae'rca<br />

xoii4 XeHI.HanbOCTb TaxoR mH4IopMausIts. Ecu anoc le fpoKypOp nl OpI-lHMaCT pcmceHe npooXMem<br />

paccIeZtoSaHe,<br />

Jelly.<br />

oH yBe¢io Mxer o6 mOM rocytapcTso, KOTOPOMy ObVo nepcnalio nPOH3BOACTMO no IaBJHOMY<br />

CTam 20<br />

Ne bis in idem<br />

1. 3a mcxan'lmeHmem cnymaem, npe oCyOTPemwx B HaCTOBeM CTyrm, HuizaKOc HUO He MOXeT 6bM<br />

CyAHMO CyAOM 3a AeJMHC, cacrnLJougee OCHOBy cocTasa npecCrynemm, B OTHOCHHH Koroporo jawmoe<br />

ITHUO 6bUIO npH3HRHO BHHOBbM HnH O paBBAaHO CyAoM.<br />

2. Hxaxoe .fHlto He MozeT 6b'r cytmo HHaKHM Apynim CY JOM 3a YUOM H-eMOO B Crme 5<br />

npeclrynpeHe, B camlN c KoTopum gro mnwo yxe 6buzo npH3HaaO BHHOBHfdM H"H onpaa, ano CyAoM.<br />

3. HaxaKoe Jun.O, KoTOpoe 6wiO CynAMO JWyrH cynoM 3a Aeawe, 3afnpeueHoe no CMuCcaY crame 6,<br />

7 iKu 8, He MONeT dbrT5 CYJIjIMO Cy,0OM 3a TO xe .esHae, 3a xcx=Ro'eHeem cny'aem, Kora<br />

pa vpabc o B IpyroM cyAe:<br />

a)npeAHa3Haqanocb Au TrO, 'TrO hI orpaAH'b COOTBCnrcTyvom¢e iTIOto OT YrOJIOBHOH OTB CTBaHHOCTH<br />

3a npec'ryneliat, noana.aIOutHe Ho BoPHCAHKUIo CyMa; HM<br />

b)no miuw npHa7axax He UGno npoBeneHo HeaBHCHMO HH 6ecnpHcMracnio B coOTmrCermM C<br />

HOPMaMH HaIeCKxaI¢ll 3aiOHHOk T'poIeaJypl, flpH3HBHHhIMHdl MeX=aJU PO, MUM npaOM, H nPOBoNOC- TaBIM<br />

o~pa3om, qTo, B CY'TeCTBYOWN1 ocrorcnrBax, He oTBeaJIo neJn npejtaT cooT McmyIoiuee into<br />

OPaBOCYJTHTO.<br />

1. CyA npmemte:<br />

CrTam 21<br />

a)o-nepBex, HacoiaHoaf CTaryr, 311emc im upecryntcHKi H CsOH fpaaena npouczypu n<br />

AoKB3hTBaHHX;<br />

b)Bo-wBropmx, B cooar-CT yioHx cJny'Iaxx, DpHMCHmImle M¢,yHapoAtHI.IC AoroBopb, ITPHH hI H<br />

HOpMM MemIyapoIHoro npaBa, BsIxIO'Ia oOnenpH3HaHmHe UpHHwmu MexJWHapoHoro npaBa aoopyxCHIWx<br />

KOH4ITHlKOB;


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

C) cR M HeBO3MOZO, CyA ripMmereT o6nHe npmMuM npaBa, 3mt M m x3 M8Ia.WoMmL<br />

3aKOHOB npBBOBIIX CHCMeM uHpa, BKmOqal, COOTBCTTBeHIo, HUMOHa. O UeC 3aK U rOCy1RpCTB, KOTOpWc<br />

pM o6wqHux o6omrencrmax ocymec'ras.h 6u wpsiuCAXLtmo B oTHOlmmeH Ammoro ncC-ryneiem, npH<br />

yCnoBM 'TO 3M T MHIUIhM He XRBMIOTCR HeMOBMCIMMUMH C H2C!O IU)IM CTnTYM H C MeJMaPO M LM<br />

PaoM H MbC YHBPOAO nPHl3HHbhIMH HOpMaMm H C7rHJ pTBMH.<br />

2. Cy Moxea npxMemM, npmMIm H HopmI npafUa B cOrneICahmm C Tem, Kai oH 6bwH<br />

NCTOJIKOBanmL a cro np=AYUU peMCHZmX.<br />

3. Ilpe-deme H 'Tmr ouaHme npaSa B cooTetcrBH c BCToumxmef cfTa'ue oJaxMo coorearcrBosarm<br />

mex0M apoJo npmI3H&HOiM npaaaM 'enosBKa H He AOHYCKBa', HIIK2&OMo He6nari'npmom upoBeumeHR<br />

pampm no TaxMM npwHmEam, xax reHiCpHR apmHax, KaK STO OUpeWeAeHO B IIYHMTt 3 CTMH, 7,<br />

Bo3paCT, paCa, uWr KOXI, 13WX, puJImrMR 1Ht BepoHmcXoBC ,loflrh'e lne (,tM mwe Y eCMM,<br />

HLIWOHabIHOC, 9rTfSMCKOC IJMM COLUMIXHbHoCI nponCXoxAme, mmyIIeCIBCmmOe, COC.iOBMOC HSH HHO<br />

qACTb 3. OBIUHE IIPMHIUI.h YrOJIOBHOrO riPABA<br />

Cmifu 22<br />

Nullum crimen sine lege<br />

I. JIM o He no, JIeaIM yronobnol oT'ner mocm no Hacrogmemy Crafy, ecm TOrerO<br />

cooTBCec'l Ormee AimC B MOC meHT cro coBepmeHm He o6pa3yeT npecynflem, nomnaAWMonero no<br />

IOPHMW)0O Cy~a.<br />

2. Onpeaenemte npectyn.ieCMm fomo OLTm TO'uO MCToSKORaBO H He ,OJIMKO UPeMMrrUC no<br />

allaormM. B c. ae AycmhcleIMoCrm onpeCJmee T01 /CZ CJ B nolhy 3JHIMa, ZOTopOe HaXOMnC nlOA<br />

cnIecTBHM, B OTHoeHxH lroporo BeHOTI CyJe6HOo pa36paTecrBo H5ma KoTopoe upmuo smomuM.<br />

3. Hacrosm a cTS He ammieT Ha KB& I ( aluMo mo6oro 11811HM Ya npocryfmoo no<br />

MeXJayMPOAHOMy npaBy, NC3aSBHCMO 0T Hacrm1ero CraTyra.<br />

Cran, 2 3<br />

Nulla poena sine lege<br />

Jhao, npmH&Hmoe CyAOM BMMOBMUM, MOXeT 6hrh Ha.3B1HO To0.1,0 B coOrmcmm C nIOoeXOMMw<br />

nacromaIero CraTyra<br />

Cmna 24<br />

OTCVCTBMe Odp&THok CH i ratione personae<br />

I. JIpo He noKiexirr yroJIOBHOfi OTTefCThIeIHHCIM B CooTHe'CTBmn c HaCTOIIIMm CTaryroM 3a nemmte Ao<br />

BcTyneJmM CB?raS , B Cmy.<br />

2. B cjiyqae sMectuMI M3McHemtM<br />

B 321o, npmme'mmA K (BmmoMy ACy o BhmOHmM<br />

oXOHUeteMOro pemuems, npMMeeC i 31011, 6oiee 6naronpHlflik An m=1 , KoTOpOe HXOAIWMCZ<br />

N0A<br />

Cfe,(CTBmCM,<br />

B OTHo0Hmm Kowporo Bec C Cye6 oO pa36HpaTeJTIO HJI1 KOTOPOe flp3HanO B, oMMM .


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

cisa 25<br />

K~mWKVlny91.HAtU VrYoJ10BHBBi 0TVerlTh6H0C'T<br />

1. Cyt o6aJA Cr iopHc zeh B MOHCHKH *bH3H4CKcKI flW. B COOeTWmma C Hacro.MM C'arf'OM.<br />

2. Jignto, Koropoe cosepumo npecrylne He, no A=O, WOWCc o IpOc.xM1mo Cyia, Hecer<br />

Hm m RaJ Hyo uOn m-eT HHocTh m noweirj HaK&aH=HN B coOTC'tBHH C HCTOslwlmd CTaT0rM.<br />

3. B COO"MeIcrhHH C HaCTO8 M CTraByOM jinuo noJICxRicx ymoBHoRt oTZv1TBCHKocTH H HaKa3aHHM 38<br />

npecrynaclme, nogmauwomee noA iopucazxwo Cyja, eCRH SM nMo:<br />

a) coBepmacr Taoe npecCyeICHHc HHJALBHJ y NO, Co CeC-HO C APYrWM IOM HMl epea Apyroe<br />

IHAO He3aCFmO OT TOrO, no,,nezmr im gro Am pyroe ai.o yronoHofi oThCTI1¢HHOCrK;<br />

b) lpHK&3BEBaeT, nOlJ exacC T HH f1o6yxAr COBCpUHTI6 TaKOC UpCCTYflICHKC, e=H RM npecTyrIeHHC<br />

coBepwae7rcg ienH ecH Hmfeer miecTo n0K)IeHHC Ha gm npeCryneHe;<br />

c) c xle.mto o6aerqm' conepmce Tacoro npeCrynnHxn fIOCOOHRUaCT, nOJ ClpCKaeT M1 KaKxm-IH6o<br />

HHUM o6pa3oM cosneAcmyV CM wOBpmemoO HA1 9OICNIKy O Ha HTero, Bxmoqaz opeJocrauenme cpe©crs<br />

=2 Cro CoBepUICHH ;<br />

d)n if um ApyrHm o6pa3oM cnoCo6cTOye coaepweamo H= roKyweM o HS coBpmcHaC Taroro<br />

lpecTynaecHm rpynnoi jm1a, ReficrByioumx c o6wlc uezm'o. Taxoa conefc'Rne Aommo oKa3-IBarbCs<br />

)Num iO R I11460:<br />

reHoUKJ1a;<br />

-) B te,Ix noJIcpzK, upecryloH crm.mocTH UH npew/eryrmok uenm rpymm a rex c ny'mx,<br />

KOr Ja T.Kal .CCMJMTJnHOCn HAMK UeJb CB23&Ha C couepenHHcM npecyr eHa, rIoWnJWoiCro<br />

noA IopHCAME=I Cyja; .Ir6o<br />

i ) OCo3HaHHem yMbiCnIa rpyrmui coBepuHTh npecryuemKe;<br />

e) oTHomen ripcCryJnHH reHowwa, nPAMO H ny6K o noAiCiplxaer jpyrmx K CoBepicHmo<br />

flnoxyavercs Ha BCoePeHec Taxoro npecrn. ¢mRS, nPcpuHHKaa )lCM.CTIC, KOTOpOc npcCAraMCT<br />

CoWO 3HaqmvChH' u mar 8 CO COBCpIeHM, o.AHazO flpeclMynfCHl e OK8 IUaCrC He3aBCP[UCHHUM 10<br />

o6croI1CJL-IaMa, He 3aHuCzU Or HaMHpeHxk JamHoro 3.. BmeCC c tCM niO, KoTopoC o'7xa3BacrCS<br />

or noniaixx cosepimTh npe c'ryfne5n0 KaH Hmum o6pa3om npejionapatuaT 3BuepLueHze ripCrCIyfllCHHS, He<br />

UOAUCXKr HaXa3AH m B CooTrecTHz, C cac'o n1T.M CTrfM 3a nOKyweme Ha COBCpflHHiIe 9MrO<br />

npecrWnJieH H, cJH 1AAaleoe into nOOcrbiO H Ao6poHojHo o1rr, ana8och 0 flpecryniKof i3jH.<br />

4. Hs ojHo nOJIOXeml€ B Hacrome Crmyre, xacaiomeec BMIWagamy oft yroloaio)<br />

OTtCTBCHHCorH, me Inmer Ka OTBCrCMHHoc rocv, apcrs no MeAJW'HapOAHOMY npay.<br />

Cnng 26<br />

HceMoqCeHIIe a IOIqKnMfl=R BAI an 111m - HC'rromf I8-ence Ag mnaara<br />

Cyn He o6a3.8 lopKCxiueo B oTHoImmII 1no6omo .14, Hc JoCfmwtmo 18-ieTHero Bo3pacra Ha<br />

MOMcR'r npenoaraeMoro COSePIICHHI fpecryCmeHK.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

Cr,, 27<br />

HennigMm~aoM cjm annp~annz<br />

1. Hammud Cr7T npmemcS a pauoA Mope Ko C mmam 63 xaxoro 6w m Hm 6wxo<br />

pasnus Ha ocHose AoumocrHoro nooxemu. B qacnmocm, AoJmxocrloe nojoxeee KU rAUU<br />

rcyzperua rm npamemMa ,MnCa npaR7bCra HM nahlaMM, Hl6pamHOrD nperMeNn HAM<br />

nOJ Hocrllaoro Z IWUWTm CThcIu Hml B KOem cJaye o ocBo6oZaer .amo OT yro.onHol OTBCTBeC.oCorn<br />

cornawo amacwm9 Y CmYiY H ne sUeUrc Cao no cefe OcHoBmiem An 'emn apmiosopa.<br />

2. HIamy em RM 1M5aUiUe UMoUeccyamime HopmM, moope Moryr 6im cwam c<br />

Aao mcThmw molXEnm nmma, 6yib To coramo HauAom Homy mm mxampoJWoMy apay, e<br />

A tMKH npcIITw n OcyMeCrBelmm CyAO CM0pIHCAMMUmH B O'MomeM T]KOO nUa-<br />

CTB h 28<br />

OI ereemocm x6nmnnHROU H ipr mqn'.mm<br />

B AonozaezcH¢ & pyrmt ocnoaam yrozomokfi aO IoTur no HacTomeuy CTrIry 3a<br />

npcCwyflaeH, IWomAUAJamu HCA IOPIACMUIIO Cyja:<br />

a)Boemw roumAWp emn mo, 4erxuo AecTsyiMoee B Kqecm mOemro xomaxnpa,<br />

1OAeMO yrojmol arWThCU M 3a npMCyn Me, U eOwBMOiiw no0 3PEWAHMIDO CyA2,<br />

cOlCpUeiHUe CExIamd, HaBOAgaxwNcs A 11O,[ emo94)4e)CITHaBm xomamUoBHmHC H KoimapoCM ,INo, a<br />

323RcHMOCTM o7 0ro6remf m, noA ero 34nmmmk UacMn H KzOpoJm, B PCYaMbaTl<br />

HeOcy) aehIc, MN K oHpo= HscxuIu. o~pa3OM HBA T8mm cn 0m, KorU:<br />

i) 'raoA aoemI COMMuP MRa TRKOC ZuA AH6,o amHo, an6o, D cnoamUMxc Ka 7<br />

MmR? Okcroutmcru, A010 6bJO 3HRMa, 'To TM CJiri COSUIBUpI R Ha PeC3RMCb<br />

COepaumIE TameC npC Ie ; H<br />

ii) Iw ko SOMeM KOMUBMARP aM Taxoe MHW fie PMMO MX eo6xoABHMLx H pa.WY mlX MCP 3<br />

PaUERB Cr0 nonORA U Ixo'0,ni C eO RU npceCeU 3PMpBCa H X COCIIIepMe inH6o RaN<br />

UeCPOA AB f DlOr BoOpoa B 9oMJIneCTc OPIMHd AA PaCCWIeOBBHH H YrOJI0oBro<br />

lPeCJICAIOBBHUs.<br />

b) Ippmtnrmeuo K 0ThOmICH[.M HtaB'IBJlR H D8IUojHCHMoIo, He OIMCAHHMM B [YHEIC (a),<br />

HniaB.8HIum noAeT ymmoaHoak Oe oc'm 3 apecrynems, noJxImAom0e uoP, iopHeAu CyAa,<br />

cosepCiIaCme niO CaIuNm, HmXO8BIIWNCE noA Cr0 Rge X[TROil BWCMO H KOrrpOJICM, B pe3yIJhTTC<br />

HeocyIUeWC~ans KoHTposE H8JeI[zXu1uM o6pa3oM HAA TBaImm noAHHmmwmM, KorAB:<br />

.) na'ImMnn nX6 aAUB, ul6o C0 m.o npomiopupoau ,OEHmopuaumo, IM'opu sMO<br />

YKA3MUB&8 HS TO, 'TO IIOI'HHCHMC iOpUNH Kn HaMCpCBaHIb COBeplIHfh TI[He<br />

npecynlamm;<br />

Ri peCMy~a=u SgTPUHU=E JASt%-cJ rboh [nojwwMzMo 1108 94WazHIy O1I~eCIIN H<br />

KOWPOJL flaquBmBK aH<br />

ii.) HsBULM&M He IRpHMIJ eCeX HeoGXOAHNU t m p y f k ep at pamax ero nonioc.min8 Aa<br />

upeAupaenCRmm npRcmeCmC C x comptuWCH 1 0 An IpeawH Amom Baopoca s<br />

KOWM MUC Opra 119 paCC.CAOBaHMi H Y7OrHOMo EpeGDAOBaRA I.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

CTryu 29<br />

B o'ruomean npecrymzeaiRe, nojsajaoi noj mpujop Cyja, ee ycmsunsemar imuazoro<br />

CPOXA JAUHOCMII<br />

cpou 30<br />

1. Ecim te 'perficoveo mo, mato no aximrr yroloBo omwclcacm B mmuzamNo sa<br />

up'eTnneun, oiAOjeaWIjRoeO noA IopHCwIM) CyAj, TOR&O a TDM CXyq8a, eCM nO UPIMHAZM,<br />

XapaKrepMryCOUlMW o6,exzUIMrye CMoPOHY, 01r0 COaCpl.C.HO HatePec a ros'eazMio.<br />

2 . A u ec.f e fl i a c1 m n c * c r a m 'u , m o Hme e T te n ,e p e a x ae C q fiy , mx K o r a :<br />

a)a omocemm eACM , WO Amo co6xpaercu COaeUPUM KaKO ,Caime;<br />

b)a omomeme nocafejcnmi, o ,n o co6ipa ci apHq'imm m ej ,oc wme Ma colam, t8 n<br />

ono Harrynw up. o6wmto xoe co6snr'1A.<br />

3. An uereAl Hac"osme craw, "coaaareaamo" Omu eacct C ocOmiatea Tom, qro o6¢Cofmre mo<br />

cymecayer Ran . o noca .AcrTe nacryuwr apm owqHom xojee coaM. "3Hrm H aiemt" Aonzu<br />

ronoaamcbCo C aOO"TCny*OWU opa3OM.<br />

Cmi,. 31<br />

1. B ,onomeme K Apyritm oca Oaau Ann ocao6oxAmm or yrouolo* o m ,emaocru,<br />

npeocxo"pee bm aecroumeeme C'ra'y'roM, JM4o tHe Heeer yroSnoao OT CHHOCtil, emu 5 xoue"<br />

a) aro mamo c'paaer ncuxweeca~m 3amojcauamex ,aN paccrpoUCehom, xoTopom Zmr ero<br />

ao3Mo~mocm OCo3aam UipotMDOpasHoCI? HmA I ApB&tp cico UOSiAeMe Hum CO 6P0 U I CDOiI<br />

AcacUmu c Tpe65oHnmn 3aoa;<br />

b)MnM o teaxo, r a coeroamoe twxcxaeuuM, [ poc mmuter erO aO nazO]Ic oc sa<br />

nPOTHBOUPaMOCrb HMl xapatrep Ccoer flOIAOiB AM C006PiOSMiM CiOM jeCtmi C TPC60lmNSm<br />

3azoHa, ecRe TOabKO STO JAHO He noacpraocb Ao6posom.o IoKCmmKAEm 1pM TmiM o0r6d enU,<br />

11p1 Koropeix WO .IHIJO 3HAJIO, TM 0 pe3yJbTie Mi r xIea , iU KOJW" 6M' Co]apWwo n IM,<br />

InpeAcMwwtoue co~oA upecirmnete, noimialtciee noA HipmcJwmim CMa, mr6o npomocpupoaaan<br />

onaIniocrS Cotepmemfa HM TaXoM ACHIM;<br />

C)9TO s amM O alc'aoaamo p83y'teo a zan.iM 006X .m ,Wyroro Ama nae, I cay'ea aoeaite<br />

npecVynneami, ewymccr, zoTOpoe mauerca oceo6o aixmwm An amummN MaOlOic Aamt m a mm .pywro?<br />

nmma, no~o twynmeclmsa, zoTopoC xmansere oc0~o axamo as auncntmeM 39N ac WIM XrozPAxepa.<br />

OT" HemJ6e3xiomo H UWI EonpamBOrO npxeHa ei cemat cnoco60o, € COpa.MCPHU. CT CeRe O11O100M,<br />

yrPnxaIonldIe STOMY .MI3 KJIl I PYrOMY 3aUXRWAC.oMy AnM HA meyeMey. To o6 oTeWWmcia, 'TO ameo<br />

yqacmaao a onepanum 1o 3aI ee, npoaw aHmcftc ct naMm, camo o cok He -iRcc OcH0eoaSe Au<br />

ocao6oxetnem or yrojioaHo OTmTBCHOCTM corlacuo STONy nojwyi iy;<br />

d)acmme, zotopoe npeRnonozwemno npeecraanxr co~ol npec-ynnaeioe, nonaajm~axiee no,


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

IopHRCAKW Cyia, gu "iica BmHyxAcHo Ho Tw IoA. peK=He Ha yrpo3y HeMmyeMOk cMep'm na6o<br />

HaMeIyeOrO npH'mmea TIrWXM ren caOl ne, Ixo nOeeH A n oaoojjoxeMu npwoMeuA TaMHX<br />

lopeJCzHA Au Hero ciMoro HfH An ,pyroro nmqa, m mW mmo npmumaCr HeO6Xo1HMdM H pa3ymmwe<br />

Mcpht Au ycTpaHH-IB 9To yrpo3, npH yCfloBHE 'rm 0 SI 1m111o mm C HeMCpcHO upWIHH1Im 6OJhIIHHk Rpefl,<br />

qeM TOT, KoTopUiA OHO cTpCmUmocb npeoTpanm. Tamu yrpo3a Moxer:<br />

i) m6o ncxo~M o'r sApynix RmR;<br />

ii) nH60 6nbm co3Aa1a Apynmdh O6c0romereamm, He 3BHCgJm 1 or o0o .lnua.<br />

2. CyA onpeAenmer npceHmocm ocoaHmA =m ocBo6oxAcmu o yronosHoA armler emocm,<br />

npejycuo pemma a HaCrOewM CaTyre, a oTxonaeHHH paccumrpmaemoro m Aena.<br />

3. B xoje cyj i6Horo pa36ipaTcwcrla CyA mo0ar paccMOmpm Kaoe-nmHo ocuoaaHme DDE<br />

OCBo6oXJreHHE 0" yIOjiOBHOII OTBrCTVBCHHOcTH, HHoe, '4M OCHOREHIM, YKa3aHHIC B UYH 1, WCH TaKe<br />

OCHOBEHIC BsrTCKafr H3 npHmcHBmor npEaE, KB. 370 ape.3ycm0peHo cTmaimi 21. Jlpoevpw.<br />

xacaommca pacm0TpcHmH Taxom ocHoBEIBI, Aomm 6am. npexicMorpelw rpasHnam npoieopa H<br />

,AOtra3blBsffu.<br />

Ommr 32<br />

OMH6wn B IbKTC 4(111 n!11HTC B iMW<br />

1. 6Ba B 4arrs Bens'C . ocnosaImeCM AoE ocno6oi¢CHm or yrmoolk OTCeB ocTH, TO nKO<br />

CWIN oa HCKmo'aUr HeO6XO.mYIO cy6rmCKTHByIm cTopoHy AamOO anpccVInaHI.<br />

2. 016xKa B npase OTHuOCETJ O 1o, i anCeig li OIpeiCfleaMum Ton1 11 IIO C DpecylmleCHM,<br />

uoajalUX M noA IOpHCXUaUM CyjA8a,HC EBJIECT OCHOBAIECK ACE OCB6oxACmg o yrjooo<br />

B m-TeHocm. O rB o m6Ka B npBsc moiE-r 6hm ocHoBaem4 AlE ocB6oxAcHm o YToooBl<br />

OTBCTCTBCHHOCrH, OC.IH oHa HcKJAo'qacT HCO6XOliHMytO eyfe BHymo cropoHy IBIoro lnPCcliHH 11,160 B<br />

nopexC, npecmoTpemOM B CraMr 33.<br />

Cnm 33<br />

nolojmm HaveSnr11112 H lo e 314mg<br />

1. ToT 4 wr apecrymnme, w,<br />

UOjAB0C BlOAi 1oPpcAMUM CYAB, 68ob0 COBIPUCHO AHHoa HO<br />

UpHKE3y npum mcrsa 3111m Hana mum, 6yj To soCHEoro Huo rpEaBHcor, He ocao6ozjaet sro mnmmo<br />

07 yro.noBHoAl mOmTB 0CmT, 3a HC MI e.H1CM CJIYBE, Ko"a:<br />

a)gm 0mo 6bmo impH'MCC 06E3aHo MmS3M AMM HpUMM Oro npBWMbCTB HR ASIHOrO<br />

Hana.EHHWK;<br />

b)g70 .11110 IIC H3Hao, m'lI tip~m,1 6 HC3aKOHiwM; H<br />

C)TlpHDS He 6ML1 181o HCM3EOHHL4M.<br />

2. Au lueRl Hacromme mvCer npxxaIW 0 oBoPmemm npeCUHnE rgowla Hm npcCryiHHf<br />

npoTIm qCIOEC't0OTI EmfEoTCB EEo HC3= Em0bMH .


CyA cocro m cjeYiuoM, oprMloB:<br />

a) flcIJ2HYN;<br />

<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

qAcrb 4. COCrM B H YrIPABJIEHHE AED" CYA<br />

Ciuhs 34<br />

b) Aouwomo oa ee, Cy, dnoe oTjenme OrcneA mo npemparvm~oro npom umn;<br />

c) Kamlepma Ilpoypopa;<br />

d) Cexpempea.<br />

Crans 35<br />

flungnweRHA gbyxni~ cvynanfj<br />

1. Bce CypA M6ipazo=s a nqecme "Caoa Cypa, r,,moMMnoUM cuoa 4yt u& ItOCOMoo<br />

oczoa, H USiaxoC B PaclnopIXtHm CYna AAR C.MMACM cROXX 4yuiaa RA a'o OCRODC C aqaa<br />

cpOa HI irOJIHOMOUAi.<br />

2. CymWz, xoAsz=e I cocma Jpe3Hmiyia, aBmomaDa an 4ym=u Ha nocromomA ocuoe c<br />

Move O€oCW v36parB.<br />

3. fileA.Wy ,oXzar, C yq''oM 05.Ma pa6oMr Cyla It sOncyOCMTa C WeHUMa, CyMA, spOut or<br />

speaem npmamn cmcpma o ToM, B KnZof mepe o? Apyfx cyAeCA po6yerca momhm cson byuxwm<br />

a nocromok oc ose. JAmo6of TucOA nopzojx He Hauocwr ynep6a nozomeuxat CrTsu 40.<br />

4. 4uaucose npaaus, npmlemome & cM", OT opux HO TP0Syerca nu IuOUM CWOH 4yu iM<br />

R& nocmoMioR oCHoIC, npMUiaOU a coo~enrcMm co crand 49.<br />

Cas36<br />

lTpe~oaa,~a zmemn~se41e K cvmamri. ainmuem~e U nuz~onu vr<br />

1. C y'ero nonoxemt nymura 2, CyA cocrouT K3 18 cyeA.<br />

2. a) Ipe= nAly, ,etIcmsyi oT or cm Cya, moiT aueczm npejoxmeuac o5 ysemacuu ucza cyei,<br />

IHpcMofel'CHOM B nyUxrc 1, yKaSaU npHM , B cM KOTOphI Br IIDpOACUSMTC HaJZclazIlM M<br />

aeoixojwm, . C.xpCTmpb HCnakeJmo pacopocrpancT moo<br />

rOCyApCr-y8crHmOB .<br />

mc upTa ejoxcuxe p Azu e xa<br />

b) .o0oc T.Koe opejwoz eim noypex 3a'M paoorpeumoo Ha t Acesaixca z'ocyusApcusy'wmmoB,<br />

co3M55¢oM e a smcmmuu co cmea 112. Taxm npeoxmet curare np Tmr a, ecmI<br />

ORO O O6peiO H& 3scepaHx DYME TPy, IWI rojiocos ,ueno AcCaMeR rOCYApCI-yumaCmhIoS, H sct'yaer<br />

a my B cpox, ycram aeuft pememem Accaufnem mcYAapcM-y'lacrmmra.<br />

c)i) Iloc.e npmru B COoTBevm c nwxymur (b) upeuoxemis o6 y'a euu. orcas cyje.S<br />

Ha cegzyioretl ceco i Accam6neH rocyapcm-ycr o a coomercau c ay/HrraIM 3-<br />

8 acrosmel crn a nymrou 2 crams 37 UpoAVMp UL60opU iso0<br />

CyACri.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

ii) flocae npmirrsi m ocyineremeio B coo ',rmH c now iYuaM (b) H<br />

(c) M npe~noxeHUL 06 YBCfH'CHIH Rmcfa cyneik fpe3IIJym no CAoemy ycMoTpeHmo<br />

MOXT B J11060C ApeM, eCOaH<br />

o6um padonm Cy~a onpaxiar smo, npeKjUo5Wnh<br />

YMCHhULHTb qHCnO CyAei1 npH TOM YC.'OIHH, RO fHClCO cy((el He yMaHLIla CIH MeHCC<br />

nwnca, yKaHaomro a nyx1 1. Taxoe nPeOXCHHC paCCurrpHBaCM a CooTraecraMa C<br />

npogenypoh, ycraHouc.mof B nojnyHKax (a) H (b). B cay'ae npHorm TaxorO<br />

npe.soxemla qHcao cyAAef noCrcneHHo ym¢LuiaeTCs no Mepe ncreCemIa CpOKa<br />

I1OJ1HOMOqHA<br />

)(eHcrytgoux cyAeA Ao goCTiKeHxz HCO6XO) MOro qcna.<br />

3. a) CyAH swdmHparcm H3 qHcna nmI BbICOKHX MopaHMIUX xaqeT, Aasmam xca 6ecnpHcTpaCTHiMH H<br />

HCMHCHaMMH, xOIopLIe yADICvoAopx0w Tpe6OAaHH im, fpCLAUCM6[M B HX COOTCTYIOUIHX r0CyTapcTBaX<br />

A Ha3HaMICHHE HA AucmHCe cyme eHe ,onHOCTm.<br />

b) Kaxjmjf KaHXWT HA 136paHme a cocras Cya Oaxe H o0amm:<br />

i) npmH8HHOR KOMneTCHOCT0io a o6zac yr0 0IHOYO H npOIeCCyambaoro npaaa m HeoxOxHMom<br />

ODhTOM p36OMi B KaqCCTBe CYabH, RpOXYpopa, AMOKaTa HAlN HHOM aaJ101HOwM KaqecTe B<br />

c4lepe yroioaaoro cyonpor39Ojwraa; n4<br />

ii) fpH3HaHHoR Ko nereHTHocrhio a cT hoeTCf yiO=X 06iiaCx Meixsapomioro npua, TaKHX,<br />

Kam MezjlHapo0Hoe ryMamH-ApHoe npaao H npaaa WeaoRaA, a TaKXm o6ImpHhM orWTOM<br />

npo4CCCHOHaJWoA tOPRHRCCKOR (eCRC OCTM, HMCiolX o IomCHHO K npCJAMdTY cyJ e6HO9<br />

errei HocrH Cyca.<br />

C)[KaXAM KHARHaT Ha 13p1Mae a cocmaa Cy.aa onxcH a coapmelcrc maTh no MeCLmeCA Mepe<br />

ojAi R3 pa6o'nx R aMo Cy.a H cso6oIo roaopm. Ha HCM.<br />

4. a) Kagwiayp,- HA H36pMC a COCMAS CYAa Moiyr WMnA KAMN rocyAapcruom - yqaCHHKOM<br />

Hacrm ero CTaTira m6o:<br />

i) a cooTvm"smr C cynmecrayto.€fi a woM roCYAapcs npoixeW.'pof atwH:m e aHAaJ.a7t p Aa<br />

Ha3HA'iCHH H 3 aUCIDiw cyA ,KHMC AzOCrH; IIH0<br />

ii) A COamm c npoUljIgpof, npenycMoTpeHHOR A Cmnrf' Mcjyjapoxom Cyca us<br />

abmmw eems Ka, mryp a com-aB Mezayiapowioro Cya.<br />

Bbwxxxeue K&H[mp conpoAoXzTAm amBne. eM, A KoTOpOM CO BCCM HeO6XOmMMH<br />

OnpO6HOCtmH coo6axaerca 0 TOM, KAIE<br />

npe ~cMm a nymire 3.<br />

O pa3OM KaHJMJIAT ycoADC fhOPSCT Tp060mmis,<br />

b) lp. npoAtHH Aw6opoa KammIO toqapmro-y'IacmHx MOXeT BhIAByI% oAworO KaHIJXHJTZ,<br />

KOTOPLIA He o6s3ATwbIHo floflXe 6Am rpaAaHmHom 9Tm I'OcyJhAm-y'(amflHK Ho A IIO60M CIz'ac<br />

J.oJIH 6brm rpaxAaHHHOM KaKOIO-zH60 rOCY.aPCBraa-yACTH4Ka.<br />

c) Accainex rocyAapcrA-yacHxoD MoXeT npmHTm pemeH e 06 yqpexzAcmm, ceca, ro<br />

elcoo6pa31O, KOHCyibTaThBHOTO KOMHTvTE no BMA uIneio KaAHAaTyp. CoTA H MaHaaT KOuwreTa<br />

ycmasmia m Accaa6nee rocyapc-yacnnm oa.<br />

5. A a ucnei npoaemm a, z6opoB coc2am smfmOC JsAa Ka BKA zA:<br />

crmcoK A, coepxanxH HNMHa KaH IArTOA, OTC'IamHX Pt,6OBaHMAm, YKa3aIHOHM B<br />

no w yrff 3(b)i); m<br />

cnxcox B, COACPlMpWIi HMeHA KaHAHAMTO,<br />

OTB9CIAOKX Tpe6Oaa &qM, YKa3aIOIHIM B<br />

no nyH=r 3(b) (ii).


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

KaNwJT, o6iaioniut AOCTBTO Or Kn4mm iKg ne o6o cncHoC , mozeT no CBocMy Bm6opy<br />

onpJcf'rb, B KBIOM CnICKC OH 6YA CT 3Ha'nMrrc. Ha nepmax ai15opax B Cocr Cyna H3 coucra A<br />

,3HPUMocS He MeNCC AmeITN cyei8, a H3 cnHcxa B - He MCHCC Ifm cyjeC. IloczeSutoIMe Bu6opha<br />

oprBH3yom Tam O6pa3oM, no6,i, coxpaH'm a coc'ae Cya 9KBHBanCimyuo nponoptno cyAze8,<br />

npoxoAumix no cnxcxaam A H B.<br />

6. a)CygmN WipamOMc Ha 3acejoamH Acc.m6J rOCyYnaPCM-y'acrn Oa, COMMaUMOA nA 9TO8 IXCA B<br />

coo1' TBmH' co craTbeif 112, nyTCm TjNoro roAocoBaHm. C co6moem M nozoxmnl nyumia 7,<br />

mP6paBHNML B cocra Cya g noCRyj 18 Ka304JroaB, nOflYWHflI &HftSOfleC MHCZO roDrOcOB H<br />

6o.'nmmcmo a ;me Tpem ronoroa oyJapcTm-y'nacHHIoa, nPHCTCTBYIO'cy)IX H I npHHI4BmawouX yacT'C v<br />

b) B cMayae, CCZH jLOCTrONOC ,CJIO CyACA NC H36paHo B xoJ)C nepaoro Typa roIocosumBJ, B<br />

coomrcTBnl C nponea'pamH, ycTBHosJCemam B no=YnCr (a), nposowcg nocae4pomu€ Typm<br />

IOflOCOBBHZ AO 3anomicHNs ocTBioIIINICS utcT.<br />

7. B COCBC CyAa He MOxCT 6im ,IByX rpazN OIHOKO H Tol1 XC rocy, apcra. 31mxo, KoTopoe<br />

MONWO pacuafrpIMrm npHMCNIICDHO K COCTBY Cyna KaK rpazjiamoa 6woee aem oAwor rocyJapcMa,<br />

C'lHTrC IpaZAHOM Toro locyJaplCBa, B KoTopom 9m JMo 06qHo non3ymrCB CBONMH rpaZ JICI I<br />

H noarmccVW npanamH.<br />

8. a) Focyjapcma-yacmItu np oriope cy eA y'r(nUm HcoSxoMoc'M o6eceneqCma a coCCMc Cy A:<br />

i) npCmBmchbr CTBr ocoHbiUx fpaBoaix Cucred mpa;<br />

ii) panA vno rtorpaiN'1ccoro npccraawrem a; m<br />

iii) WpBMeAJ.HAO c<br />

-pcJTBBWTCmCflB<br />

cyJCe XCHcKOrO H BmyxcKOID non.<br />

b)rocy~Apcma-yac'mxH Taxe npmnwaiTr Bo mwamd e noTpedHoch B eaIM CyAC1,<br />

ofna3JaOmnx OmatTOM IopKAHqJemcoR AJeCrCAHocrx no cneum.anm aOnpOCaM, B 7OM 'aCne, HO He<br />

orpaNHBB MUC 3oM, no BonIPOCaM, KacaIoMii,,cK HBCaCIUs B OTHOlHH N X CH lN JWT'C.<br />

9. a)C y'eio noy,Iymr (b) cywlh 3ammaloT cboio Aommocmh B Te'eHN JICBMUTH .ie? H, C y'roMM<br />

nojMU lM (c) CTBH 37, nyime 2, HC IbOT flpBa HB nepeO36paHm¢.<br />

b) [Ipu nepahix aa,opax oma TpCTh cyet8, oT6HpaeMlx no xpCSmo, ocracrCC B JaoJ cm B<br />

T'CNeC pe¢ l neT; OAR& TPCMh CyleC, o0INPCUME no xpedio, ocraTfmR B AonJ. ocrTH B T"IlCHHe mCece<br />

ACT, B OCTBJOhNLC CyWCR OCI'BOTU B IIOAROCYN B TOCCNN JICBM ACT.<br />

C)Cy jbX, BMOpaHHH Ha V=X 'HBXIN CPOK B coonerM C nOwyarnyrom (b), uaeer npaao 6rm<br />

nepezispamnm Ha nomulk cpox.<br />

10. Hecamtopq Ha nonoxemm uyHZBa 9, cyJWS, Ha3NasBul a CyReHMo mH AnAuNmmomym nuay a<br />

coommTCB co cmrae 39, ocTBrmsC 3 JXOmO C'r AO 3aBpmcie mo6oro cyedHoro HAN<br />

antu mlsotmoro paB36pftTcJi , CIyMaR no KOTOpOMY YXC SdbM HaaT h B aKumofl Haeam.<br />

CTamaM 37<br />

1. KnPH OTKPMTHH BBKRNCNN ahi6ophl AUn 3aMoBHCHNI npOBOAWr B COOUCTCHN CO Crtme8 36.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

2. Cy~AL, K36paHmblA AU 3anOJI CHIuI UKHCNM, OCMCI 8 AOJIXOCTH AO HMc'HHeJ CpoKa<br />

no.omodoqmK csoero npeW mCrsBCNMU H, eCCJI 3Mro cpoK COCraMIBrCT 1p roa Mnm MeHCe, xoxeT 6u'1<br />

nepCN36paH Ha nOnwHhIf CpOK B coorsBCT-mm co craTni 36.<br />

CTBT , 38<br />

1. Hpcea nepBblA N opotA BNI(C-nPCCCJTHlxN NIGpaxnrca at6comoTiM 6omAoNwN o2M<br />

roaOCOB CYACe - OHM BMUOfMUUOT COMH 4 YHKUH B TC9CMM<br />

T Tee MCe CPK WIN AtO 3aBpcPICB CPOKR<br />

MX nOJIHOMOqMHI B KxaeCTBe Cy((CI B 3aBHCHMOCTM O1 TOrO, KaOg m3 M=HZ CpoKoB HCTCK2CT PaHCC. 0M<br />

Moryr 6u-m ncpcM36paHi omm pa3.<br />

2. 1CPai BNue-np1ceaAJw 3aMcecT IlPeAC4TCI B CY'qae, CR lpCeACCrarena oT MCTyer MW<br />

o'reeH. Bropoft BNxe-npe c1 TC. 3ameMcr npTm Cnytae, MRe MR npelN CAJCTM , N nepmbAk MMe-<br />

npetCeaTeam OTCYTCT ByOT HM OTBCCNCHbl-<br />

3. Hlpeoceiaarne Bmcre c iepBm M N mIopum Bwe-npecepnzaT o6pa3yOr flpemNZnym, KoropuM<br />

HCCT OTBCTcTBeHHOCrI 3a:<br />

a)Ha ¢1,cxaee ynpaJeHNe CleaMN Cy11 , 3B CamwmeCNmBC Kaimenipma lipoKypopa; N<br />

b) apyrHe 4byKmixHH, Bo3naraeMUe Ha Nero B COOTBCTCM M C NaCfOJroA. CTBTYToM.<br />

4. fIpo BbI1OnCHM cBoHx o6Z3aHHocret, npeCAycMGorpCmWx B nyB xC 3(a), I'lp03IKWY KOOpNInmpyeT<br />

AerreJ HocTb c I~poKyWppOM N 3apyaeTca cornacueM nocaecro no BCM BonpocaM, UnpcJTBiw UaJ<br />

B3aMHuft NHTpec.<br />

CTabx 39<br />

flano<br />

1. flocze H36paH4Hz cyjeA Cy( Tax CKOpO, KaK TOnbKO 10 BO3MONEO, opraHR3YeT B CBOeM COCT€BC<br />

OTtcnemNi, YKa3aMHe B nly ie (b) crmH 34. Aneaomoe oTesenme cocroNr w [lpeACCATf N<br />

elte qermpex cyneA, CyJe6noe oTA¢jiCm~e - Ne HCNCC 'CM H3 wCC cy.efA H OTCeaeme npCJBapMTehNomo<br />

rapOR3BOAcTBa - He MCeHe ReM H3 WWCCM cyA.CA. Ha3mHimc cyAe A B ccOCaB or1eCm f ocynxecmrmCT c<br />

yne'rom xaparrepa cymKa, Koropue Bonarawr s Ha N xoC otrtCneMe, xsuaKbBI xaNZ mN N oIm, IT<br />

N36paHmwx cyJICH, C WUM q'1"O6N B KrXAOM oTJ.eneHJ J CYICCTBaBo e noxoAJee co.1C1Bme cyefA,<br />

su.ioulxcXC cneuauJc'raM B o6aCTN yronoaaoro IaIaa npouCcca N B o6acTH MCXJINapoJmoro upaBa.<br />

CY.e6Hoe o rAeneloe N OrAeretMe n aparnJzhmoro npoit3aomCrB covroIT npeNwMeUCreTMo n3 cy~cA,<br />

o6ia3aiouM OnWTO Be.CHK e cyAe6HOrO pa36HpaTCJem Ho yrojfoBm.hM ,A.,aM.<br />

2. a) Cy1e6mCe 41yNI1Hm Cy( ocyclMnM'wCB B Kaom mreMna ianraam;<br />

b) i) Aneua omtnas nanala cocrowr x3 Cex cyeA AnCanoHorNo oTretem;<br />

ii) 4iYHaxM CYJIe6HO nuami' ocyMecTmamT C pCBm CYLBI CYge6orO OrACiCMuN;<br />

iii) OyxilYH flanau npeIapNrcvfof npoNs3otC'aB ocyajCCmBnJrcs 1m6o Tpem cyJ"H<br />

OTAcJeIm npeCapwrmf.loro npON3o3C0ra, lN6o oJwM cyIOefi 3'ro OTreneHmA B<br />

COOTC1-MHH C HaCTOtRHM CTaT O N IIp namaMN ripo0iJlypht N AOKw3MuHM ;<br />

c) HHro Be CIBIM o fly HC HCXHJIOqaCT B03MOXHOCrH oWDOBPeMemoIo YqPCX CHB 6onee


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

'CM onoft CycCoft nanaTz iHm flamam rpemap ix om npomwaocmr, Korxa sworo Tpe6yor irrepecu<br />

sleKmIHoro peryjHpoBaHHji o6seMa pa6omi Cya.<br />

3. a) Cy,bH, Ha3HBmcHLeZ B CYAC06OC OTACHICC OTeCHCJ1,N1 HPCJCBBP1TeMJLorO Hp0oH3BOACTBB,<br />

BunomiHioT cBom 4IYHKIINN B 9THX OTJeJIeHHX B TC'qeHHe TpCX AiCT H nO HCTC'eCHN jaBmoro cpoKs - AO<br />

3aBCPWCHH paCCMOTp[HL mo6or JeCja, c y aCiyW no KOTOpOldy yzKC d uu HaaaTu B cOOThCTCTByIOnleM<br />

OTJ C.JCeNNN;<br />

b) CYJbH, HaBHaqeHHble B AneJXmAWmNoe OT 3eACNc, BbmoMi TlO' CBOIH 4IyHtnZU B 9rOM<br />

OTOeemN B TemCeHe B Cero cpoKa csoxU nofniomoit.<br />

4. CyjbH, HalHaqCHHEe B AICzIJIBONNOe o'rjies e, abmOMtlOT cBoH ty HKWM TOmKO B SCOM<br />

OreHeHmi. OCEO NrIMTO B HaCTO=Ik¢ CT bC H HcKmoqa T BpCMeICmo HaHamCNmC cyoeiA CyAC6HOrO<br />

oTJCme B OrgcjcNiec npcABapwcmAHoro NpoH3BJ ~crBa 01160 Hao6opOT, eCm.N rIpe3JAH CnlrTBCT, 'To<br />

mrO1O TpC6yloT NNTCpCcu 34)4cKTHBHoro pelyAHpozalHpO o61CMa pa6Om Cya, npl yCJIOB.HH, q'ro N npH<br />

KBK1x 06CTOTrJmCTBaX Cyli, y'IICTrOBaBwHA B npcJIBpNI OM HpoH3BOAcBC HTO Aei.ffy, H 6yoeT W4I<br />

npaa 3aCCIA Ha cjiyiuaHHX HO 9omy xC AeCfy B Cyne6HoA naRaTC.<br />

Ci..i~g 4 0<br />

HC3B,.NCIHqOCMhCfe<br />

1. CymbH H,3BBHCHaMJ~1M npH IHoJIHeCNm cB Ox 4)YHKWl.<br />

2. CYJHI He 3aHHaMIOTCB HHXaKOI ACB¢7JHOCThIO, KOTOpal MOXeT npCHfITCTrBKfh BhIojUeHIIO MIM<br />

CBOHX Cy e CKHX KHWM NAuN MOXCT 3aCTB B&B yCOMHWThcI B 1X HC3aBcBmocrh.<br />

3. CyMH, OT KOTOPUX TpC6ye'CT BSIHOMUrM CIOH 4)YHKM Ha nocroamof OCHOBA B MIcre npC&1Bamm<br />

CyaB, He Aomow notmBI Tce6s HHKaKOMY ApyrOMY 3BHwTrmo npo4mccohamoro xapKTpB.<br />

4. .bO6flf BOUPOC, KaCalOnN CI npHmeCHemi nyHm O 2 R 3, pCmamcT a6comaoTm 6onmHmHc'oM<br />

fOiOCOB cyAefl. EcJIH KaKoftJim6O H3 TaxHX BOnpOCOB CBS3BH C T7M Ha1 Hmm CyWbeff, TO 3T07 CyJb{A He<br />

6yBCT yacTBaOsa B npmHiMT pecII i. .<br />

OcBO6OWIXNNR mm11 OTWH sV1Ia<br />

1. lpC3NJINyM MoxeT oCwo600NrL cyJLo, no cro npoch6e, 07 BsmomiOemU 1ymufM, npeJyCMoTpemx<br />

NBCCOMHM CTBrfrom, B cooTUCTC=HN c flpasJImNm [1pouej~ypu H AoKB3 miLBIII<br />

2. a) CyAb He y'acByeT B p&CCMOTpCHi AwfalB, B CMrNI C KOTOpUM ero mH eC 6cnpmcTpBcocTh<br />

Morna 6 611rb pa3ymuo nocraBea noA COMNeHHC Ha TOM HER IOM OCHOBaH1. Cybg oTBOCfrcR OT<br />

PaccmOTpCHHI 1e.1a B COOTrCBHH C HBCT .mUIM nyHxTOM, ec.H, CPC,,N Hpollcro, mwO CYJg pBHee 6hLw<br />

npUmcTH K AN OMy ,jIly B CYIC B KBKOM 611 TO Ni 6wiO KBWc'Me, 0160 K oTNocimIeMYCA K ISaHHOMY<br />

Aeny ymnOBHOMy ACIy Ha HB c11NI1O OM ypoBHe, C yqCTCM NaU, NhXOAJI]UCOCB HoI COCCTANHCM 11<br />

noAIepraooacroca CyA 6HOMy npe ¢cAOBmNo. CyMuAi TAKxU o7moIICI 0r paCCMoTpCNHS is Ho TaK,<br />

oPyfhM OCHOBAIaCM, KBKH¢ MoryT 6Mbm npcIClMoTreVm B H'piwax npoCCOYpl H AoxB3.lBams.<br />

b) lpoKypop Him .ilMW, KOTOPOe NaxoJIIITCS noA ciiCeJIcTmeM 1I1 B OTHOIeNm KOTOpOro BeAVcT<br />

cyc6Noc pa36HpaTwrebcmo,<br />

HymTOM.<br />

mOXeT XOJaTaCAcTBOBaTh 06 OTBOJe CyJUH B COOTBCTIo1 C HaCTOBIIIM


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

C) J0oo* Bonpoc B o'Homefflffl OT'B cyTbH PCMar= a6coMOnMM 6onahlcMiH OM MOCOB<br />

cyjtfi. OomnmoMy cy w, rpe ocTa.=eTca npano npecrMB CROH 3aMenaHHa no A&-oMy Boapocy,<br />

o06a8 a npotecce npHmRTM peMeHeA OH HC YqaCByeT.<br />

C~amis 4 2<br />

Knannag flnoavna<br />

1. Kawnejspia IlpoKypopa Aeffcrsyer He3aucBmo uK oTemiama opran Cyjla. Ona omeqaeT 3a<br />

nouzy'eHme ncpeAaBaemux cwrya t x juo6oA o6ocxoaaHmoA BHlbopMaWm o npecrynetnm , nonaammnx<br />

noA IOmpHKCUZM1 Cy a, 3a HI HyRetHe H OCYU1eCThWeMC pacuco~ama H yroioaworo npecneAoaams B<br />

Cy~e. Corpyjumix Karqeuptm He 3alpamuBBaoT H me BwlOmIoT Yasawaf n3 o60ro aHemicro<br />

xCI'qHM]<br />

2. Kam1enapHs BO3r1auc'rCB lpoxypOpoM. Ilpoxypop o6aiaaer BCaMB n0.1RHOMO'UMM 110 PYKOBOCTBY B<br />

ynpau elmo Kaa.meipHoel, Bnxo9aa flCpCOHaJI, OMCICHHB H 11powHe Kweiozuneca y Hee pecypci.<br />

fipoxypopy oxa3zaroT nOmOmh OIB Hm HCCKOJIbKO 3BdCcf1eTjCif flpoKypopa, Korope upaBomoqHw<br />

coBepmaTr mo6ue Reicnxa, KOropme AorxeH coacpIa-S IIpoXypop B COOTBVf l1 sac ro m"<br />

CTalyrom. npoxypop it 3aMCCT1r4eJI Ipoxypopa AoJlK 6iim rpawa, aM Pa3HZM oCYyapcM. OHM<br />

pa6oaio Ha OCHO e nOfiI 3aRHBOCTH.<br />

3. IlpoaypopoM H 3amecnenm flpoxypopa sBflIocs amma, o6nafaiouzHe Bwcox m MopiJIiH<br />

KaqeclaMRH, BWCOKOff K8HJbHKwHBWaef H HMeIOIQHC o6aimpBHLif npa"KTHccK oMlT a o6faCTR<br />

apecfaeosaE xnH BCeHH pa36BpTe wT no yrojioBBHM Aezam. Om1 goJImB B coBeptcHCTRe 3Man<br />

xow 6bi o~n Hm pa6o'mx a3IOB CyAa x cao6o.Apo ronopxm H8 HeM.<br />

4. Ilpoxypop M36HpaeiT, nyTeM TafiHoro roitocoaam a60JIoumIm 6oJr'mmiLrHCIom rwoocoB 'ueHoB<br />

AccamUte6 rocylapC B-y CrTBoB. 3amcemrem fIpoxpopa H36HPa MrCB B TOIOM XC nopXMC 93 crICKa<br />

KaRJIryp, npJc'craJeHmoro flpoirypopoM. Ilpoxypop BbAHraer 1p Ka.RWTyPH Ann Ha3HaRCHuI Ha<br />

KIIO AOMMOM 3MCCTCZe flpotypopa. Ecam Bo Bpem mx H36pamms He npmmeaerct pemeBs.,<br />

npea nxpBBa~onero 6oiee Kop0TmNR cpox nmmoM0'UR, fpoxypop H 3amecrwmme1 ripo ypopa H36fpa1OT,<br />

Ha CpOK a 6a.BB Juer H He moIyr 61r nepcH36paBm .<br />

5. Ha flpoxypop, m 3axeCxreH llpoXYpopa He 3zaHKaoTC max o Ae et ocrbo, Ko Top Morea<br />

6w npenwrraoaamB ocymern eino i npoxypopcxr.x $4yu1w am n nocraaHm noA comiemme mx<br />

HeaHCHMOCrh. OBI He 3aJm.axoTCB HHmaKmUH Apywy BIUZaM npo4)eccxoHaabHo o 6MMocTH.<br />

6. rlpe3 ym moer ocao6ommrrh Ilpotypopa Him 3amecrmuI ilpoypopa no ero Hna ec npoc6e OT<br />

YUCTHS B 1DM HER 11o1 KOHKPVOM Je .<br />

7. Hx Ilpoxypop, Hu 3aueCTBneflu lIpoXYpopa He y4aCry3OT mH B iIOM AeCC, npHMeRMeJ o K<br />

KOrOpOMy JUX 6eC1pmCipacrHOcrh MOraa 6w, 6h1Th PB3YMHO IOCTrMMeB IoT CoNMHeC H8 JInOou OcHOBaHHx.<br />

B COOTaeTMHI C HBCTr0BM=M nYBKTOM OHH 01OTBOABTCS 0 yaCTHBU 8 AeC, eMJx O.H , s qaCToCTr, paHeC<br />

y'Irac mB a mO6m Kaqec'rc s paccuoarpcmma B Cyne avroro AMa HAH B paCCMOTPCHmH CZr3aBHOrO C 11<br />

yronoBHoro rea Ba HaEOHRJIbHOM ypOBHC, K KOTOPOMY np4laCfIHO 1H40, HXOIJEIUeCa 11o c11c6TeRemCM<br />

1111 nojeprasomee Cy=6OBMy npCCJleM oaMW o.<br />

8. Jbode Bonpocu, ucaCBHecsc oToB6a rIpoxypopa Ham 3aMecrt.r11 flpoxypopa, pemawor<br />

AJncaXBOO]i nnanrok:<br />

a) JIMo, KOopOC HaxOMnM no CJeC CMCM Mot1 B OM Coe KOTOPOro BCACTCB CY,H61OC<br />

pudmpawe o, moxeT a =o6oe apexm o6paTmuc c xo~a~crmwM o6 0Toe rlpoKypopa Hm<br />

38MCCrRC JIB lpotypopa no OCHOsBIIBN, H3'IOXelHH M B Hac'roBIIef crare;


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

b) lpoxypop MKH 3aMec'rm rlpoxypopa, cooreTe 8o, npaooqc Uxpaejcram clov<br />

3aMemagno no mroy nomo .<br />

9. [lpoLypop H83HalUCr KOHCYnbrmMoa C OIehfroM lopNJIHAIeCoA , rCEMUROC'M no cUH8,ZbmOI<br />

fOapOCaNM, aXn U BonpoC, aC._eM Cn CCKcyahOr, Ha H, rOM~pHoro uacum H HaaCI.IE 8<br />

0O7UIm luM ACMi, HO He OrpaHwmlHUCb 9nE BonpocamH.<br />

CT8Th 4 3<br />

1. CxpeapxaT omeqar 38 HecyAcOe6m, acnea m Yinpauems Aeasm u o5csyxxsam CyAa 6e ymep6a<br />

AIn 4tyHKVmoM R nomoMo'u nlporypopa a coomenTmma co cmm k 42.<br />

2. CeKpBIpUmf- aosrnannaercI Cezpmpew, KoTop mufeTC. a riaamHmm ammoprrama3<br />

A oMrMOmM jmWoM CyA-. CeKperspb ocyu~eMneT CBoE 4tyuA noA pYtlaoACoN flpeceTAW CYAa.<br />

3. CcxpOTapb R 3aMeC n'e. CeKPcmp- o6AaaWr SNCOMiDM MopaMMMm zaqec'aNaE, amcookl<br />

KaanHEmtel H 3 CocpCMeHcTe 38A10T xo'r 6U oM B3 pa6oqKX ESOKO CyAa H cMo6oAo roDoPIT Ha<br />

He.<br />

4. Cywi s36xpawr CxpeTap- a6cmomm 6oimm room ronocoa Tima ronocoaamem, npammua<br />

Bo matname nm6bi<br />

e pexo,€eaoaW AC-am~nce rocyAapcra-yqacroEs. Ecm Bomae= TaKaI<br />

Heo6zo mOCm H n1o pCKoMHmumHH Celperaps, cymm ESxpaOT rmo ze o~pa3om 3aMcrzI<br />

CCxporaps.<br />

5. Cexperapfi HS6pHeC Ha nrmeTECmM cpoz nojImomoMl, MOwer ntiepCE3EPbC& 0118 pa3 H<br />

p85018e0 He oCEow nozo0f 38H SoM . 3aMaocmmen., CeWprapz 3a.NUM C80o JIOJinOCi' 8 TC'OMCe<br />

1oO HeCO CpOK8 nOj18MO M mm Taxomo 6onee KOpOTXOrO cpoxa, Koropall MONT m onpe, cH<br />

a~comomm 6om, mUcrsoM roiocoD cyAc8, m o MOxer Ohm mpaH Ha ocHosC Toro, ,'ro 38a CCmrff l<br />

Cexpep, Mo eT 6,T. npH3BaH ILmIOmuHITb 4)yHK11 ITO Mope HCeOAXOjiMoc[H.<br />

6. Cexperapb yqpoor, a crpyxlrpc CcKperapHSmr Fpyrw no oa38 noomH anoTCpDneCEm H<br />

C8MlrTCU.M. 3, rpyima O ,lC'1E880l, a KoHcyjThauax C KmeIJIHt[ Ilpoxypopa, MCpU saawm n<br />

npoueopm 6mlnacEocru, KOHCYJMTaEOIOHHyM H 119Yr710 cocCOTSC IoYu0 nomoIZ canAeTenNmm<br />

noTepnemm i. , o'opule SiImOC8 B CYA, OpyrHM MMaM, KOTOPUM rp03Wr OUICHOCM 3 pMYJyflM<br />

1101838888, Aamm TLOX 181 mMe8ITeBmM. B cocra rpymmTh Ax1RT CorPYjool, KOTOPMe HMOT? ori<br />

paorT 11O DOnpocaM, ocoMaUca K TpaBMa, KJUOq1a TERpRMaa, C8838aHH c nipCrMCMIUOIM<br />

ceIcyaM.Horo HaB8.<br />

Crm, _44<br />

1. rIpoKypop H CexperPrb H83H1'18oT a HX cooT CT8 icm op113 Ora 8ot Iz aImBII1pO I8IIHM<br />

nelponan, Kaxlko MoeT nmOrpeo aa a. B c ,"ae [Ipoxypopa Sm axmqoaer" sa3 ma'eme cnoeomaret.<br />

2. flpE Hague nepconana flpoxypop i CcKperap, o6cmc'1maor amoozE ypoam, paSo'rococoftoc'm,<br />

KOMcIaTOOH3om H Ao pocozacmoc'm H npEiniMa so BHHMaHHo, mutatis mutandis, xpmepmu,<br />

muoxeme z syHrre 8 cranH 36.<br />

3. CexpcTapb c cornacms flpe3jumxyaa H IlpoKypopa npejuzaraer llonoxaml o nepcoHane, KoTopmIe<br />

BxJIJO'1Or YCJIOBH8, Ha KOTOpMX flepCOHaJi Cy1a Ha3Haqa0Cm, 1[Ofly'aCT B03H81PaINJOHHC HNH yB0M6.HSOCJ-


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

floz~oxema o ncpcoia.e o ophotz Accam6 eef rocy~apcrB-yqacnmxoi.<br />

4. CyA MOxeT npH HCa.IoturremHhiX O6CTOmulbCTBm HenoJib3oBaTh ycJsyIH CiIawHCTOB,<br />

OTKOMaH, npoa8a1WLX a W3BO3Me3JOI OCHOBC rOCyJ~ApCTaMHY aCHKIaMH, MexMpBUwReT'crMlMdEIaM<br />

oprH3aUXWUH HAM HelnpaBMrenWTB.HHhdMH oprIHH3alIMH, ARA OKa3aHm nOM01H B pa6m Jm6o0ro 3<br />

cro opraHoB. HpoKypop MOXeT nprmnrrb iao6o TaKo¢ flpeAjoxCHle or 0MCHH KamHeUizpHm fIpoxypopa.<br />

Taxoik nepCOHan, o OMaHApoBaHHIA H8 6e3BO3Me3AJHOA OCHOBp, nPHHMavc Ha pa6oiy B coomercaml c<br />

PYKOBOAgwItHMH nlpHHl.nfllabrH yCTaHaBJTHBueMbJMN AccaM61teeA rocyapcTB-y'acTImmoB.<br />

CTMXh 45<br />

.. ~ToDxec'memOe odsaeagr.~<br />

JAo sc'ynnem 8 oJIOIHOCTh B COOTBercTBHH C HacoZIIIHM CTayrom cyPbH, ,Ipoxypop, 3aMeCTTCrH<br />

tipoKypopa, CCKe'rapb i 3amecrwm'ei, CKpeTaps npmmMao'r Ha ce6g B VMopMTOM 3aCCPaHMI Cy~a<br />

ToPROCSeTHHoe O6d3aTe.UMrBu nozJIoMO h CBOr coo'rBvlr"Cyoutm.e 4byHKxJHN 6ecmpHcrpacTlO H ,O6pOCOBeCTHO.<br />

Crum 4 6<br />

OTRIIICH~e or nojwixMOel<br />

1. Cyp, flpoxypop, 3amemcTim Ilpocypopa, Cexpe'rapb RHu aaurHwm Cexperapz orpemaerc or<br />

3aHlmaeMofA oirocri, ecH pelnHme 06 gTOM OpHHmdOaCB B COOTBeCTBHH C uyHXTOM 2 B Ceny/a,<br />

Kor2Ia:<br />

a) ycamOBJmeHo, ITO &HHOe mu0o coBmpmiHo cCpwH3u t OpocrynoK HnJIm Cepbc3HOe HapymeHHe<br />

csoHx o613 4ocreft no HacToImcMy CaTy'ry, xa 37o npeCIICMOIpeCO B HpHaZBaX lip.i-,JUpu H<br />

JOK93BIILa ; Hll<br />

CTayra.<br />

b) A aHOC J1H4O HeCIIOCO6HO BbIIOUl.lBTh (by]=KIH, Bo3.iaI emme Ha Hero B CHIIY Hac'romIero<br />

2. PemeHme o6 orpeUeHl OT OJDIOCTH cy , lpoKypopa, 3aMecrrasw. [poxypopa coruacHo<br />

ny-ry I npHmHmaeTci Acca.ii6eefi rmcyapcrB-yacHHKoB TAIIIL1M rojiocoBalmepa:<br />

a) B OTHOmeHMH CYMJau - r.OOHM lcTrBoM B ABC TpeTM roJIocoB rocyapcTB-y aucT oB no<br />

pCKOMCeHfIIO4, IupmHrk 6oaJbnn!HCrBoM B BC irpTH rorOCOB Oc rm mnII Cy)eft;<br />

b) B o'HmomCHim lpoeypopa - a6comonwm 6onJRnHcBOm rocyapcB-yaCTHEIoKB;<br />

c) B ofoenHH 3aMeCTNCjIE IpoKypopa - a6cojnT[rAI 6oibuIIHCTmO rojiocoB rocyAapcm-<br />

y'acrlimoB no pexomeHJawm IpoKypopa.<br />

3. PeiueHHe 06 orpeUeHHH OT AOJIMKocr CeCpeTap H.lH 3aMCrT= CCxpeTap npHHmmafcT<br />

a~comTmum 6OoJImHcrom roJOCOB cymiI.<br />

4. Cyp,e, npoKypopy, 3aMecrHTIeio [IpoKypopa, CeKperapio TiM 3a&MecTrrelo CeKperapA, noaeHse<br />

Knm cnoco6Hocm Koroporo Bunomurr, A ocnu Cme byHla, rpe6yemie HacromWIM CTrfyrom,<br />

OCnaPHBOTCB Ha OCHOSaHEN HuCrOAMCI craThH, npeoOCTBo m CC so o3Mo ocM AUX Toro, Wr106M<br />

npe bBHwm 11111 co6pamr OVKa38TCTCBa H c~lenam npjcrAnelnua B cooah rcrmI c npa tamN npoale.iypu<br />

H4 AoKa3mBaHH. Huoro yqacr, B OB6CYXKACHHH naaHHorO Bonpoca 3m .urmo He npHomwaeT.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

Cm 4 7<br />

nmnH1ap1uie T<br />

Me u<br />

B oTmomemm cywbH, flpozypopa, 3aMCcm a flpoxypopa, Cexpcraps HAH 3AMCCIrHTe.n Cexperapa,<br />

coiepmnmemro npocrynot MeHee cepbC3Horo xaparrepa, qeM a1r npeycMOrpeiHo B nyHrre 1 c'rarb 46,<br />

npHMeH oTc KCncgnJMHaPMHC MepW B coorETecTBHm c lpaa MHia npottempa H Jzoa3mhBaHHiH.<br />

CrTha 4 8<br />

fI'naIIem'J H IEMMV ffeM!<br />

1. CyJI nOJl3yeTc Ha TCPPHTOPH KasAJoro rocyapcCTBa-yacmrHxa TaKHMH nPHBHI erMH H<br />

HMMyHHTCTaMH, KaKaC ZBJaTRirc HeO5XOft HMIH J a AoCrTmHxHHX er UCJICH.<br />

2. CyJAbH, flpoypop, 3aMeCrwTH fipoKypapa H CexpeTapb nofib3Ylorca, xora OHI y'acrTytoT B<br />

,ermMHocTH Cyja JM a oTHomeCHHH TaloR AeJICrenbHOCTH, TCMH Xe IIpHBKIuer.IIMU HH MYHRMraMa,<br />

xoropue npeilocaanmOTa rnaBam Amnoma ncCKm npeAcramwrCnbra; Cy e6HO-InpOiccyaJIbHuj HMMyHHTT<br />

nio6oro poa a OTHOueIHHH acero CKa3aHHOro, HaIIHCaHHorO HMH H Aeflcrfi, coBeptleHHwx HUH a<br />

o4)mwajmaHOM xa'ecrae, npoo1XfeT npeocmThaCZ HM H nOCJIC HcTr'qCHHZ cpoxa HX nOnJHOMOHA.<br />

3. 3amecrxrezn CeKpeTaps, coTpyAHm KameUCpJHH fpoKypopa H COTPYJ9HIM CeKperapHaTa nom3y OTi.<br />

[npHBaH eriiMdH, HtMyHH'TraM H JlbrOTaMi, HeeOGXoAHiMH IS BMaoJIHeHia HMH CBOHX tYHXZIIHA a<br />

COOTB"TBHH C CorlaJIRCHHem 0 npiaHJIeCrx H HMMyHHT'ax CyJa.<br />

4. 3amaw-mxy, xCncpraMM, csHJImTfl4 H flaO0Y JApyro?4y fmti, npHCyrTaSHe KOTOpIrx Tpe6yerC a<br />

MeCTe npe61amHx CyAa, o6ecnemaaercs Tao K craTyc, Kaxoi qBzjerc Heo6xoAR um Ajw aH eaMero<br />

cbyHxn0eeopoama Cyaa, a cooTercmHH C cornameHeM o npHBtCnrHIX H HMMyHHTCeaX CyJa.<br />

5. B UpHBHAen X H HMMyHHTMrax MOXCT 6bLrM oTKa3aHo:<br />

a) a oomeHHm cy~cL Hn rlpoxypopa - a6colnoHim 6oJbmmHcrMoM cyJciS;<br />

b) a oTmomerm Cexperapt - IIpe3LyUOM;<br />

C) a aTHOmeHEM 3aUeonnw i flpoxypopa H corpyJuffio KaueJlmptw Upoxypopa -<br />

IIPOKYpOpOM; H<br />

d) B oROMeIH 3aCCTTCrA CeKperapa H COTpyAHOB CeperapaarIa - CcKpe=apeM.<br />

Ciama 4 9<br />

Oxijuamj, flOCO6HEg H KOMITCHeaIIH paCKOB<br />

CY,bH, flpoKypop, 3aMecrnnH fIpoxypopa, Cexperapb H 3ameCTHTCen CeKperapI nojiyq oT TaKHe<br />

ovfai, noco6 H H KoMneHCaUo pacXoJoa, Kaxe moryr dbm onpeee Accam6neeli rocyjapcrynaCrHHKOB.<br />

Pa3Mep 9IHx OKnazoa H noco6HA He MOXeT 6rm yMenbmUe a nepHo, BufOJHeHH HmH caoHx<br />

OJiHOmOqmH. •


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

CaIr 50<br />

u itmAnge tm pfa6ome HmmxHl<br />

1. Ombmwwmwo asraMa Cya zUET alHrmcKma, apa6cXHA, HcnaHcXIa, K rl dCXA, pyccut<br />

H *pamY3CKIly 3 H. flocraHoRamu Cyna, a Tace Hme peLuems no ocHoaonoauamonmm sonpocaM,<br />

paccMaTpxacmm CyAM, ny6nHYrfla= Ha obmHHaama ashmax. B coorer m c ipLrepflM H,<br />

ycraHoaJeHHwmH B IpaeuHax npOUCe.ypb H AoKa3aBHM, IIpea3.HyM onpaeCUT, xaxCH peMCUHH Cya<br />

MOyr/, a a ACJ1¢ie HaCTOUICrO rlyKTa, c'4HT8abC2 pCnIeHHAMH 110 OCHOBOUOau ORUIo BOlpOCam.<br />

2. Pa6onHM AM 3a~ Cya gnaIoc aHrjHAcKHm H cbpam w lc BUXH. B flpasmiax npoueJ;Wpu H<br />

AOK 3IRa-HHlN OnpCJ C cJY'aH, B KMoopUX ApyrHe o4bHLman we RbMKH MOlry HcnoTb3oBaTCg B<br />

KaqecTe pa~o'mx g3aKoa.<br />

3. no npocb6C iJodofi H3 CTOPOH, Y'aCTBYIOIWX B pa3dHparbCJe~h , HJl KaXoro-nM~o rocyhapcTra,<br />

KOTOpOMy paWPCU1Ho ycr&TBOBMS' B pa36HpaTrelIm, CyA p&3pemaer HcnOiZeaHe TaBOi CTOpOHOR an<br />

1"a31 rocynapc M mo6oro Apyroro u3L1,a, nomioo allrnfcKoro HAH 4)paly3cxoro, ropH ycjloamg, ro,<br />

no MK¢HMO Cymja, Taxoc pavpememHa¢ nueia Aocram'qHo o6ocHOBaHHmL.<br />

Cra,b 51<br />

UhaaHna U/flVfM 1 flflKAhBBHM<br />

1. Ilpa HAa npoilexypu H AoKaLizaamax ac'ynaior a cny nocze npmirrI 6omHmmm B Acae TpeTm<br />

ronocos qneuoa Accam6Jale rOCYapCrB-YqaCM4XoB.<br />

2. TaKwe nOnpaMH K IpamnHam npouejDypm H Jola3Imam moryr npeJIrabmc:<br />

a) ino(Lba rocyAapcTBOM-y'Iac'rllmoM;<br />

b) a6c om iuZm 6oiAmamcraoM ronocoB cydst; mH<br />

C) IIpoKypOpOM.<br />

TaKae nonpaBKH BcrynaT a cmy nocza<br />

AccamneH rocyAapcTs-yacrHoB.<br />

npmura 6oabHcmoM a Ta p erD roAocoB qneHoB<br />

3. flocne npmimf flpaaan apogempm H Aoxa3lIBSHa a cyuse 6eouflarvl¢.mw o* HeOdXOAHMOCTI,<br />

Kora llpaBna He npe"cMaTPHaalo' &ZKOA-nA0o KoHKpe"Of" CWIaWM, C KoTopoi craAK/faaecs Cyz,<br />

cybMx Mory'r 6osmmHHcToBM a pe T Ce Monocoa npm-rM BpeMeHmC npUaHa, KOTOpC dIyT<br />

npmwerra, noia Accami6nea rocy apcrB-ygma oa He rYpTCPT, EHCnpas'UT HA omoHir Hx Ha cDofi<br />

cAejyo1ie oqepcjAo11 Hum cnelfaauoik ceccI.<br />

4. lpanuma lpOIXCepU H AOK&3b[8HHI, UOflpaK H K HHM H =dnoe BpemeMHoc upamaIO o Ium<br />

COOTBrCBOBam HaCTOaeMy C y. l~lm KnpaKD K paHaB1M nPOIlCe4yp H AOKa3lBMDal, a Taize<br />

BpeMCH. ¢e npaBH.a He npHMeHIOTCB pmTpoarr Ho B ymep6 My, KOTpOe HaxojimTC no, CA¢ACTBrIe, H<br />

a OTHOUeHHH KOToporo aeAercS cyAe6Hoe pa36HpmebTfcfW o DDm KoTopoC ripmtaHo BxHoBHEN.<br />

5. B cnyqae KOJIAIH3HH MC.Wy CTaTyTOM H flpaBammaH npouejUyPm H Aoxa3WzaHxm CTry'r meeT<br />

ripcHMytecremHHY, cHny.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

Cran, 52<br />

PerzaMwr Cyna<br />

1. B COOTBeTCTBHH C HaCTOAHIMM CTayTOM H IlpaBHaMH nPOUeP H AOKa3baBaHHA CyJbH npHfHMOT<br />

a6conmOrimM 60JblnHHC"BOM rOnocoB PCrJIBaMCHT Cyla, Heo6xomHMIu Anx o6ecnc4enHA erO nOBCemieBHOt<br />

143YHKIIHOHMPO~aH1<br />

2. flpH paapa6onKe PernaMewra H nlO6bX nonpaBoK K HCMy UPOSOAMRc KOHcylrbTaBUH C nPOKYpOPOM H<br />

CepeTapeM.<br />

3. PeriameHT H mo6ie nopaBKH K HCMy BcrynaloT B CHny no X npHHla H, ec= CygbH He npHMyr<br />

HHO peleHHsI. Henocpe crBeHHO floCne HX fpHHTHB OHH pacchmacOx rocylapcrBaM-yacrHKaM Ail<br />

npeAcraBn3eHHx 3aMeaHHA . OHM OcralOTCai B CHHCi, eCJiH B TeeCHHK iueCTH MNCCUCB rpOTmB HHX He yATr<br />

BbIBHHYTO Bo3paweHHiR CO CTOpOHJ 6oJhbIIHHcTsa rocyapcrB-yacrHHxoB.<br />

4ACTh 5. PACCJIEZOBAHHE H YrOnIOBHOE flPECJIEAOBAHHE<br />

CTaThm 53<br />

Hagoso oacC Jlenopaansr<br />

1. flpoxypop, OiCHHB 1npe~cJanCHHypo epy KHmOpMaIXHlo, HaRHHaer paccne3AoaaHHe, ecflH TOJbKO OH He<br />

onpeji evir, 'TO Her pa3yMHlX OCHOBaHH[I An npHHJ1THm ,CTBm B cooTBeTcrBHH C HaCTOB11IHM<br />

CTaTymrM. IlpH npH-urlH paemeHmA 0 Ha,'aJ1e paccneloBaH H rlpoxypop paccmaTpaeT CAe ly OnHe BOpOci:<br />

a) JIaeT ri HH1OpMawH, HMeIOUIac B pacnopjixeIH npoxypopa, payMKme OCHo am<br />

noniaram, 'To 6io COBCpICeHO HuH coaepuaercc npecrymneHe, noAna&mmee o IOPHCJKXWMOo Cyga;<br />

b) ABngeTCx jil gTO AenO Him 6yleT iK oHo gurreb otOOyCTMmum cormacHo cra-me 17; K<br />

c) c y'eTOM TaXCCm npeCIyMnHH H HMrepeCOB nOTCpeHeBJ, MXCXC M, Tel He MeHee,<br />

BeCKHC OCHOBaHH1 nOnaraTb, O IpOBe1HHe p3CCZCeJOB8HHX He Oy I" OTsw' iKTepecaM npaBocyAKs.<br />

Ecim rIpoKypop onpelenxeT, 'ro HCT pa3yBHwx ocKoaao io An3s npHHTHB ARcrCRA, H cro<br />

On[pCeleHHe OCHOBaHO HCKJIOR'HTeIbHO Ha COO6pa eHHzX, npHBecHHIx B fo3nyH'rc (C) BUIIIC, TO OH<br />

yBeomnizT o6 sTOM flaaaTy npeABapHmtnemoro npoH3aOH3cTaa.<br />

2. EcIm no npoBt¢CHIH paccneoBaHH Hpnpoypop npHxoAHT K BUBO3' 06 OTCYTcrBH nOCarOqHbX<br />

OCHOBaHHI 31)11 Hana1a yrO31OBHOrO npeCfeAOBaH., nOCKOfbKy:<br />

a) HCT AocTaTo'mbix npaSOBhlX nH 4jaKTH'WCKHX OCHOBaMiH Au1 3anlpaumHBaHH Opnlepa Hill<br />

npHxa3a coriacHo CmaThe 58;<br />

b) AeJIO RBJI1CTCR He3oIyCTlMlM Ha OCHoBaHuH cmanm 17; JmM<br />

c) yrOJIOBHOC npecIneoBaHHC He oTsemacT HrrpcaM npaBocyIHJ c y'TOM BCCX O6CTOsle~mucrB,<br />

BKmIIox'a.1 cTetuIn ImXccTH flpccyflhlHH1. HuTepecib flOTepRCBlIHX H Bo3paCT RH HCMOIUt lPIeolaraeMOro<br />

npecTyIHa, a TaBKe r0 H IN Ce pOjib B npeofilo.araeMOm npeCTylulnHHH,<br />

fipoKypop yaeOMReT IlanTy npelBap'erJHOrO IpOH3BOACTEIa H rOCYAlPCT O, KOTOpOe flCpeCacT cmyamao<br />

o COOTB"TCTBHH co cTancIR 14, 1H CoBer BeorracHocTH B ciy/a, nlOIYraJ[aLLECM 110 HO)OKCHHC<br />

nyHicTa (b) CTaTah 13, o CBOeM 861BOAlC H OCHOBaHHXX 1ji TaxKoo BiBO JI.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

3. a) fo npocb& rocyjapca, KOTOPOC oCyzlecmrxeT nepej a',Y c¢la9H B COOTBCTnTBHH CO<br />

crauwk 14, HLR COSeTa Be3onacKocm cornacHo nyi-ry (b) cTaTh 13 IlanaTa npeAapWrenbHoro<br />

npox3BomcTas MOXCT BHOab paccMorpem peleHHe flpogypopa coriiacHo nyHeraM 1 HH 2 Me npenpmHmam<br />

cficrmd H MOweT npocHwh flpoKypopa nepecM(yrpeT 97v peiueHe.<br />

b) KpoMe Toro, flaniara npeaapireim~oro nPOM3BOJCTra MOzeT no cBoeh gHHiataTHBc<br />

nepeCMoTpem peIcHe flpoKypopa He npexTpmMaTh aeklcTBHf, eCJTH I0 pewceme oCHoBbaaaOCb<br />

NCKUIO'ieI'fff HO Ha noJIoxeHNIX nyHKTOB I (C) HuIH 2 (C). B TaKOM ciy'ae pCIuCHHC fIpoXypopa 6YneT<br />

AekcmoB m rOJmKO TorAa, Kora Ono nomTsepKteHO flanaTot npeABapHTeJLHOro npON3BOACrMa.<br />

4. Hpoxypop MoxT B ino6oe apeM nepecMoTpe'm peweHme 0 Ha'ane¢ paccjiCpOBaHRM MH yronoauOro<br />

nlpeJleOgaH]. H8 OCHOB2HHN HOBWX taKTOB ItOH HH(D)OpMa1HH.<br />

1. fipoxypop:<br />

CTB'ThI 5 4<br />

OdzaHaotaru m flornrmomou floocyop nm paecenoiaami<br />

a) Aa ycamoBAelm HCTmNH nosoB9r paccie osaNHe c TM, 'rro6m oxaBTNrh bce 4)BC 1aM H<br />

AoKa3aMenbCa, oneocmEHecs K OIeHKC Toro, HaCynaCT A yrO.OaHa% OTBeTCTBCHHOCn, B COOTB-CTHH C<br />

HacrozUIM CTayroM, H npH 31DM B paBHok Mepe pacCneyeT o6croalmcraa, CBKHeTCJCTByioIe Kax 0<br />

BNHOBHOCTN, Ta H 0 HCBHHOBHOCTN;<br />

b) npHNmaer Ha.JnexagHe Mcphi Jis O6CCnC'{eHHNR 94x"eeK-r om pacC¢com m H yroAoBHoro<br />

npeCJO0CJzOaM 3! npcCcrUfeURA, nOJnaABIOIUJHe fol IOPHCJAHKWWo Cyjza, co6.joJ! lrpN 9roM wrpec H<br />

mpmze o6crmgTeimcrTa nOTeCpnemx H CBNehTCJIH, B ToM qHcne 8o3pacT, ICHJepHfiH cazuop, KaK TO<br />

onpeCeJHO B nyHmC 3 cTaThH 7, H COCrToHHC 3JOpOBM, a TagKxe y'qmwBaeT xaparTCp npecrylemHH, B<br />

RacroocTm npecrynljeHHA, CBB3aHHbIX C CCKCyBjfhblaM NaCHJIHeM, r H3,¢pHbM HacHJIHCM HAH HaCHIIKeM B<br />

oT1otueHH AcTeik; H<br />

c) B eio0log mepe co6mouaer npaaa nHu, abrrClKaiouje K3 Hacrow1c€o CTaTrfa.<br />

2. flpoKypop MOxeT IpoBoJNTh paccJiCXIoBaBH Ha TcppM-ropHH KKOI-JIH6o rocyOapcTBa:<br />

a) B COOOCTBHm C nOJIOXCHEMM qac'r 9; MH<br />

b)<br />

cramja 57.<br />

no pB3peaCHIo, BEIRHHOMY rfluaaTo npeAapTej Homo upoN3BOcTBa coruaco nymTy 3 (d)<br />

3. flpoxypop MoxeT:<br />

a) CO6HpaT H H3y'a~b JOa38TenJICT;<br />

b)<br />

caN4iere ne€l;<br />

TPe6sOBBr REBIH H onpafHoaTh JNit, HaXOIIAUJMXC, lIo C ACrCBeM, nOTCpnCBIIHX H<br />

c) 3apynaTc coAICCTBNeM nio6oro mocyapcrBa aH6o muxpaTenmeHHOR OPrBHH3a=H nal<br />

MCXaHH3MB CorlacHo Hx COOTeTcTEyioumM nOjiHOMOINM /HiM MBHAgTBM;<br />

d) 3axfoqanh Ta~e corfameH! MN AoroapBeHOCTM, He nPoTnuopenamtle HaCTOameCMy CarTyry,<br />

KaJee Moryr norpe6oa x An o6 qerqlHA COTpyHNIerCBaa CO cTopogm Kazoro-z]O rocyapCma,<br />

MCxnpaaBff MCeH.OA OpraHH3altH MNH AHU;


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

e) AaaaTh cOrF2acH Ha HePaCKgptTHC Ha mO6OM anr- opOH3Bo)cnTha AOKyMCflaB<br />

HuH HH4)OpMan4H, KoTopbie diJiH flOJlY'ICHE nPOKYpOPOM Ha YClOBHKX COXpaHeRH KOHlHMeMHu&AJHOCMT, H<br />

TOIlhKO 2 1U tLUea nOJIY'ICHMI HOBbIX AOKa3 aTalM, CCJIH TOJbXO jnto, npeloraaBHalee TzHae lOKYMCHITIh<br />

H HlbOPMpaglUO, He Aaer Ha T" CBOero cornlacHa;<br />

f) npHHxmaTh Heo6xoMmie Mcp HIH nipocwr 0 IIprHrTHIIHoXOAHmX MCp Au o6ecne4HHu1<br />

KOH4tHJeHUHM&HOCTM HH4WopMaHH, 3alIuTU mo6oro moma mirH coxpaHHocr'H ,oxa3acbT.<br />

Cmah 55<br />

11PAB8 I[Hll A XORC 29Q8C .J AT Ia<br />

I. B oThOmUeHH pacc.neaoaaHHa, flpOBOAMMOtoo B COOBCTMHraiI C C Ha<br />

CmiYraOM, rnMUo:<br />

a) He J eoNfO npHHY]KaTbCg CBHTCrnbCrOaT kpoTHa CaMOrO Ceft Hit lpH3HaaaTh CaOIO BHHY;<br />

b) He IOlMMO no~aepramTb npHHYXeHH1o, Jea.ieHKIO HAH yrpo3aM a mio6ofi 4mopme, rmmam<br />

HIH ,pyrH )KccroKaM, 6ecm'niOBeuo m HH yHHzaiOti HM uocmIHcro aH aM o6panmemm HZH HaXa3aHH;<br />

c) eciH ,Tonpoc npoBo/AmTCl Ha AlMUe, KOmpbull TO u141.O He nOItMaT B nOioHO MCpC H Ha<br />

KOTOpOM OHO He rBOpHT, ,UORLIO 6CClHIaTHO naouiloBashC flOMOulmO KaanHbHIXHpOaaHOrO nepeoT41HKa H<br />

TapHMH lCPeBOfaMH, KOTOphle HCO6XOAHMI AU C06o.0CHI Tpe6ouaHmA cnpa.aHIHBoCrHf H "<br />

d) He JAomo noanepra'ncx npoR3aohioMy apCTM HT, 3auepxaHmo, a Ta=€ He .O.xHeO<br />

flOaWCprIaTLC JImHIO Cao6Obi, HHaIC KaK Ha TaKHX OCHORaHHJX H B COOTBeTCTBHH C TaKHMH<br />

npOUeTypaMH, xoropze ycraRoBeHM a Craiyre.<br />

2. B rex cny'azx, xorua HMemOTC OCHOaaBIH nosaram, 'To TO HAH HHOC inmo coaepwmno<br />

npCCTynJe[He, noAnuaamnee no lopHcJeHKumo Cyua, H TaKoe ANUo aCKopC AIOXKHO 6irbM nonpOimeHo nM6o<br />

fpOXypOpOM, JMi60 HaLZHOHafIhHMMH anaCTlMH CorjaCHo npocb6e, HanpaeHot a coomwemm c<br />

qaemro 9, gm nuO HMCeT TaKIxC C.leDlyotueHe npaa, 0 KOTOpEiX OHO HH4HopMHpyCn Ao Hanaiaa ,npoca:<br />

a) 6 M yBCALIoMIe M AO Haqana IAonpoca 0 TOM, 'iTO C OCHOBaHHIl nilramis, 'io mm<br />

COaepmueHo npecryrneHHe, nonl'laUlAaotlee no, IOPHCJHKI gO Cyla;<br />

b) XpamTh MOJ9aHHC, nPH4CM Taoc MonA'aame He oTOJMO y' or hSaarC npH OnpeAeleMeas<br />

BHHOaHocrH HIM HeaHHOaHOCrH;<br />

c) noJlb3oaaTRc npaBosof nOMOwUMo no co6cTeHHoy ai6opy xzl, ,CTT! m m o He<br />

fojm,3yeTca npaBosAa nomObio, nDory'a-M H3HaqeHHylO eMy ypaaoayio noPonmBP a maOOM cnmae, xorna<br />

roro Tpe6ymor mHrepecbi npaaocyALa, H 6e3 xaxol-IH6o oruaTi TaKOft nOmOuitH 9"HK nmeizOM a mo6OM<br />

TaKOM cny'!ae, ecJm y oro IMH1a He Hmeeia Aocr'qmux cpecC 1Ax oDnwaT TazaoA riOMOuHi; H<br />

d) 6irum AIonpamHaaeMiI a npHcyTCTrmH aABoxaTa, ecm jIHo no cof6ctnH soie He<br />

olTa3awoch or caoero npaaa Ha YCIYrH aABOKaTa.<br />

CriMa 5 6<br />

POnn, flanging nMe=nin weHOnn ngaonemaB O<br />

OmomeHng<br />

vHHKHsOflt aO3Mo wHocTmi nrpa DR eioaaHwg<br />

1. a) Ecm IIpoKypop c'mracT, 'Tno npoaeCeeHe paccneoaa.HHz npencfraiuer yHmaMMHylo<br />

BO3MOXHOCT1,<br />

AK nonyiCHHX IOKa3aHHH HJIH 3aBneHmHi OT CBHTJlerfl lH6O l H3y'CHRa, c6opa Har


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

npOepKH AoJrasaTCen , KOTOplie BUOCBATCMHH Moryr OKa3MTWeS mO ClyrJmam js zIe HclOflL3OmamHi<br />

a xoAc cyAe56foro pa36pen h, npoxypop mm4opwpyeT O6 TOu flaay npepxtwmBmo<br />

npo033oAcrua<br />

b) B wrom cryaqae nlmana npejwapmewmore npomwojcm, no upocze lpoiypopa, moxar<br />

npuTr THuc MepL, taime uoiyr OKB3aras HCSCO6xOjUmMLMam ,gli o feuiemS soXjcKTmmocru m<br />

iioczejloaaTemmocTH cyAc6HOrO apecWo IBaH H, B ,.acocrH, An1I o6ocnemm IpaB 3ww .<br />

c) lcam fanara upumap're nHoro iipom~mojwcua tc upmadaeT pemmmA o mHON, m HpoKyip<br />

apecraaueT cooTBCTrc maopamso mybouIno niny, xopoe 6huro apecroaaHo Km smoCb Ha ocHOsam<br />

fpVKma3a o JnMKe 8 CBa39 C npoaBOA,6Ua pacneMloa.Me, ynoMIy[ B noMYssie (a), c TeM Wo6l aco<br />

zomo morno 6hm. DBuc.zyMlIaHo.<br />

2. Mepsm, yia3ammmLe a ny 1 (b), moryr zmOqam s coos:<br />

cne iBm; o<br />

a) Aaqy peoAem.m WIm pacUopImm omourumMo npousp, KoropMu ISnyexe<br />

b) Arty yxaaamh o BOACmm npo~Iooe npoHDo~Ba no )eny;<br />

c) sazaaemame s axepra Aum Ocuagm nomOmH;<br />

d) papeemrm 3au=Hm mmIa, icoopoc msO apecmaHo mHm LsImoCb Ha OcmouaHmm npma3a<br />

o mmze, nplmmmam yacrue e paxmvncm mmns, ecam apCC.r He isIe. MeCTS Ms iBL3BamHOO mEO He<br />

mnaMoCb mAH aMmNx He onpuene, , Ha3HaqCsHe ,pyloro 3anUlMUMa ,Ju yrmacT a pa3OpareMCe H<br />

UPejwreinoff" HmPecOB 3a&njs;<br />

e) mmqy nopyeamh oAomy ma caax RaeoB si so, a czyue meoCxoonoCT, ,Apyrw cy e,<br />

mmmeeMyca a Oruemm npeapfmnmoro nponsAciua sum a Cy',e6OM onwnemml, ocymecram,<br />

Ha6AoRcme H JABMRh pezoeHumlm HmH paC copme s oflnCWEM.MM copa s coxpaHemg Aoxasarenscyu 8<br />

jtonpoca ullxl<br />

f) Taime HHHO AeAcTM , KOToPIC Motyr oaisrcs meHxooxLm Aix c6opa um coxpa-eHs<br />

AoIMnM-<br />

3. a) Ecism rlpo opp He nperipmmma r mep cornawo mac omtse crane, a lIamla<br />

npe=apRTeCIro npo3o3cra cWraeT, 'TM Tme MepM neofOtomm c enM coxpanmaH DuMMacraM,<br />

KOTOpL, no ee M DIi, mMelar CyluzIee Oe 3HaCmme AD Oe enelemX Inrepe.a ammi S Is XO<br />

cy.e6oro pa3OHpaTerc~ma, osa npoaommr xoHcymTa~m c HpoKypopom a olmmemm "rorD, imei nm y<br />

Ilpoixy pa aecue ccoaamss ,Afs meo6pauem c npoc. Oo o npmmlrnmm Xa mep. EcnI s pe3yabTC<br />

KoHcy.ZTSik Hama npeapmwreloro npo3BoJCraa nPHXOA T K 3K.mocsmo, ,no mexe amc fIpoKypopa<br />

noTppe6oarm rnamx "pu mep uAeTC Haeonpa~aamM, Ilara peiwapmrenHor npoiBoca moeT<br />

npHmme raie mepm no CBodk coOcr OnI ImHrHIIHt -<br />

b) peimme Ilaam o apmerenimoro pomo~aACTu AXeJkmoaa'm no cooc co6cmemok<br />

HH sM a co'scraTemx C HaCTORIUM nyliro oxcr 6brL o~xauoaHo rlpoaypopoMs. Ow6Xaoame<br />

pacmarpmaerca a cpc'cmom noptme.<br />

4. fonycrmmocm Aoaremc, coxpameinema m copase An cyme.moro pa36mpaTwecrBa B<br />

COOTBCJf'TBm C HWMTlInefl CTaThefl, HH npOTOKOZOB, 8 KOTOpLIX OHH C0oAPX5TCS, OUPCAe CTe. 8 XOAe<br />

cyAcOro pa3ftparemcra B coOrerTCmm cc craTSeR 69, H osm imuOT IO Ao 0Ka3CJZb0 UemsOCTL,<br />

aE MOXCT Onr onpejeciHa Cye6HOA nazaod.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

Cmai,. 57<br />

1. H Hacroe0 M m CraTyYt Hen peyCMOTpCHO KHOe, 'lanaTa npeApwreiworo npoH3nOAcTBa<br />

ocyntez haur cmno 4rylm=H a coOaneTmrua c nonoxCmiRNm HacmelC crarma.<br />

2. a) flocanoanew Him pacnopgzei flaawru nPeMpHTtnoro npoaN3opCM, HA CaMbltze a<br />

coo 1e 'rBmi c no.ioxe morH craeR 15, 18, 19, 54, nymrr 2, 61, nyrrT 7, r 72, npasuaawc<br />

6on,,mmwracT ronocon ee cyoel.<br />

b) Bo Bcx ,pyrx cnyh cyjpj Ilamaw npegapren oro npoanocTaa moxeTr ocymecrInuu<br />

lyHmaam HlamaTu npcnupmemioro "npoHsoAcTea, nprCMOIPe€W HacoroiMs CraIyM, ecna a-oe He<br />

nlpc, cMoTpeHo a rlpagnax npo.€AYph H AoKa3muma MR He penleHO 6imcmmosT roocoB cyef<br />

Ilana nlpcapTelaHoro npoHx3Bocma.<br />

3. Hapsa co caolma pyrMmH ryrmwuosA no Hacrommemy Craiyry [laxam npe pmmaoro<br />

npOH3OfJCTfm MOXeT:<br />

a) no npocb6c flpo]ypopa, oiaasm aHe pacnopizeima H Bau M a e op~epa, iaa"e<br />

mory'r 6rm HCoftonwina Ann l ,e npoae~imz pacclOoaamza;<br />

b) no npocbde mma, Koropoe diuso apecromHo mam sumloc no npHKa3y B coomecrram co<br />

c .TaeA 58, oi=um 71ae pacnlopaxeHia, ajxoqaz MepM, nepe cniemm¢ a crame 56, HNH 3apyqrArb<br />

Tamm npe,,cmC emop m qacmO 9 CoTpy mleCrUOnm, KaioO MOX e OKa3a7u1 aeOOXOaMaM Jus OKa3aHHB<br />

JMUUI flOMOMiMl B ofOl roaineM 3a1i,1W;<br />

C) B Tex ca.y8Xa, zOl1 tO HCofXOA O0, o6e=cnqKUe Tl 38uM3y H HCUpHKOCIoICHOCrb nacraoft<br />

am3H nwrpnenmux H CaH€erAMfc*, coXpaHHocTh ,oKa3AaMn , 3a8013y rMU, KOTOpUe 6wm aIoOpe Baz<br />

am xvHj1mcb no npmia3y, H 3aUUMy un~opKaznxt, inC&aiOIef Al Ha11HOamOlk O3OnaCHoCra;<br />

d) A gab IpoKypopy pa3peiJCe HA apHHXme wemHJ x MCp, oHocariXtxca K NpoaAEBmO<br />

paccne.loaaa a npe~enax ,ppmopru rocYTalc-u-y -cnma, 6wm nonyqems co cropoim mror<br />

rocyvap&ra cornacma Ha wrTpyA1H tcrO B coormciam C q'crma 9, cmi, npamza ao alastamie,<br />

noCKojMay ato Bo3MoxHo, MHeCm cooTur cmylonlero rocYATpca, lalaTa flpeJAIwa hH Horo pox3BoAoc'lm<br />

lpMUCILHIUMH C O K AaHHOMy Cnya= ycMoaxna, rM 9O rocyAapcTaO XaHO He cnoco6Ho nMnoAnurm npoc-6y<br />

o corpyJwmcrme no npmm¢e oT'cymCm1 Kazoro-mi6o opiaaa H0TH anemra cro CyA9CHOf Ccreamm,<br />

HaAleseHoro noiHOmoomsmm,<br />

qacTro 9;<br />

neOXoflH l A BIOuHeH. npoah6u o CoTpym'emcaCe a CooT'rCTCTBH c<br />

e) B CnyMa, KOI na. ornaCHO CraTe 58, ,iaeTCU opAep Ha apCcr a n npl a3 0 RUine, H,<br />

J-oflnzimm o6pa3om y'nrrmlaai CHIy AOKa3ariM, a TaXKe npaaa s3TCpCCO~aHHlX CTropOH, Ka Wo<br />

npeycsawrpaaacrcia H HacroLareM CTaryre H B ripananax OpOMumpu R ,oxan3Mam, o~paxn.u',c K<br />

mcyapcat a c €merrms c nyHKToM 1 (k) crwam 93, Ann Tom Cr0o6 3apywnrbCZ lx coTpyAmH eCTsom<br />

a nppirmrnH step 3aux<br />

noTepnemum<br />

C LemmlO KoHcbxCKarimi, a 'acnroc H r rnaRwum opa3ot a aTpeCai<br />

emua~ 58<br />

Ruiuqa rlarmA nnenmnmr~anm o ownoarcru oenena<br />

ira gDon'T .in noainana o mar<br />

1. B mo6oe apem noce Haeana pacceAoaamm l'lanar npeoapHmr€lom npomocraa staer, no<br />

3uemm nipoKypopa, OpAep Ha 8PCCT Torn HAH aMo jiUa, cURa, pacCUOTpea TO 3UagCHHO H


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

AOKaUT a Hm Apyryio HH4OpMaUIHO, npem vaJHe e flpoxypopoM, oma ynomroBepjacb B TOm, 'no:<br />

a) HMCIOTCJI pa3ayMwe OCHOBBHUS nonarTm, '(To TO AHIO CoBCpimlo npeCeynieHd,<br />

nolnalaom,¢e noA IOPHcAHK1Mo Cy1a; H<br />

b) apecr AamHHoro nma npecrTanmseTca Heo6xoAHmbM:<br />

i) AMA O6ecnCqeHq erO XBKH Ha cy1e6Hoe pa36HpaTehrho,<br />

ii) =z o6ecnie'eHHz Toro, 'T06hU WO JI HO He C03AaBalo npenfrBKCr HAM yrpo3bi MA<br />

paCCelosaHmg xH cyjte6Horo pa36HpaTejicma, Ha<br />

iii) a cooTercayIu=H c ajtx, nL npc,ynpczeHI npoApiceRm cosepmemHs a OM Iroro<br />

UpecTyIUieHHg HaH cBg3aHHoro c Him flpeClyIleHH, KOTOpOC nO111912aA11 o IOPHCAM=MIHIO<br />

Cyna H KOTopoe conpIxeHO C TOMH ze o6cTroETCnbCmaMm.<br />

2. B 3aMeHK fipoKypopa yxa3hiB rTca:<br />

a)mg ,nm a H Jro6ua Apyrau coo'rsercrayoi as HHiopMagx, yCraHa fHBanouiaz w'mocrh;<br />

b)KoHxpeTrax cch a Ha npeC'yleHHm, noJonaaMWte no IOpHC9HXAMO Cya, KOTopuc, ax<br />

nPe=oJa-aeTC, COB:pUIHAO AaHHoe .. HlO;<br />

C)KpaTroe HufoxeNHe 4)axTos, KOTopa ¢, KaK npe=OfaraeTCi, o6pa3yroT nm npecrynieHxa;<br />

d)pemome 9OKa3aTefCnrB H nio6as Apyrag HH4opma= , Korophnm yc'ralsaBalar pa3ymfe<br />

OCHOBRIeA nouarah, -o Amioe hMWo CoaepWlHAO 3M npeC"yrMeHHi; H<br />

e) npM'Ima, no KoTopoii lpoxypop cqffmaur apecr AaH1OrO jAila HOeXOJIHMILM.<br />

3. B opepe Ha apecT yxa3BabOTCi:<br />

a)Mg 14 X& H =9169a1 Apyras coOTsercrByIohaz mH4'OpMa=, ycTaHanmzIOaioua iiwHocrb;<br />

b)KoHlpeTHax CCWIa Ha npecryrtfleHxm, noAnaAaiouoe 110 iopmcHII Cy~a, B CUA3H C KOTOPhMH<br />

eo6xoAwm apec'r .aLHHoro aH1a; H<br />

c) KpaTiloe HAoxeHHC iba'oB, xOTope, KaX npeonaraercM, O6Pa3YbOT 3M npecTynneHm.<br />

4. Opuep Ha ape=T ocTaeTcs B cHJe ,Ao Tex niop, noKa CyA He paCnOpI9tcR s o6 HOM.<br />

5. Ha OCHOuaHxn opepa Ha apecT CyA moxcr nanpe6oaim npeAaapHTCeJHoro apecra HA apecra jixa<br />

H ero npe,ocrasleNmg B pacnop1]eHme B cOOTSOrcrHH c qacio 9.<br />

6. rlpoiypop MozceT o6paTHTbCI K JIJiaTC npe1AapmTemoro npoH3socTBa c npocb6o BlecTH nonpaaKN<br />

B opnep Ha apeCT, H3mCHH3 CCK1 Ha fpecrynieHnx 11H6o AOnlOJIHHB HX CChmKamH Ha jpyI1He<br />

npecwynnc . Evm IlanaTa npew09apwrHmoro npo3Bo~craa y6eaiacb a cynevraoaamm pa3YMH'bX<br />

OCHo0aHKA nOJIaraTb, q'TO 9aHHOC J9M.o COBepIlIH, npeT1F¢HHA, CCLLIXM Ha KOTOpbie npeitnouaraerca<br />

r3MCHhM 1n4 J9OIIOJHWrh CCbL9KH Ha ipCTyflJIe HH, COACpXi9HecR B opePe Ha apecr, oa BHOCNT<br />

cooTserCryiomme nonpaBx B opcp Ha apecr.<br />

7. B Kaqecrae aubTepHaTmB 3anlpamHuaBHm o opcpa Ha apecr IlpoKypop Mowcr o6paimcs B flaiary<br />

lpeAapHTejmHoro rlpoH3Bqo Crna c npoc~o Bb,=9, 'lpHKa3 0 RIe ,aHMOTO lHIa. EcH rlaqaTa<br />

npeABapHTebHIoro IIpoH3OCTBa yAoCTOBCpH19aCb 8 Ha9HIHRH pa3yMuHuX OcHOBaHfI nOlna0ri# h ro aHHOC<br />

ww49o coepunJiO npe9 onaraemoe npecrylfettHe H 'ITo npma3 6yeT 1ocTao'romoi MepOfi Au o6ecne'eHHI


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

ABzH JAa1Horo amU a, oHa SBlaeT, Ha onpeeHa1X yCJOBfX }IH 6Ce3 KxX-H6o ycnOBuIg,<br />

orpaHwha mmaOxX cBOdoly (HHbIX, i eM 3aAep)KaHHe) , eciH aTO npeJycMcorpeHo H..tHOHaBIHMM<br />

3arOHO~flTentCOM, npHKa3 0 BBKe WaHOro nMua. B nIpHKa3e YKa3biBaiOTCji:<br />

a) w" i xua H ro6as Apyrai coTBrBcrTyIOlUa HH4)OpMaaHx, ycTaaBnHBaioua nmocrb;<br />

b)ToqHau AaTa RBKH iaiia;<br />

C) KOHxpeTha ccULKa Ha npeCYrleHH, nonanMaaUte noR E pmcAmo Cy~ta, KOTOpLI, KaX<br />

rlpeJoliarBOTCB, COBCPIUKRO AaHHOC fHiuO; H<br />

d) KpaTKoe H3JIOXCHHC IaKTOB, KOTOpme, KaK npenojiaraeTcji, o6pa3yioT mo npecryiCHHe.<br />

flpHxa3 o qBKe BpytacTca HeInocpecrBeHHO A.HHOMy JIHUkY.<br />

CiamaR 5 9<br />

fnoonenyva apecra B rocvylnpcTBe MeCTa conepxwa m non raxeft<br />

1. rOCy~apCTBo-yqamrmlX, KoTopoe folJyqHno npocb6y 0 npeAapwrJmIoM apecTe HnH 06 apecTe x<br />

nCpCewie Cyy KaKOrO-jiH6O AHi1a, HC3aMb HTeJlBHO InPCnPHHHMaeT Uars AU apeCCa COOThCTCTBY0 o ¢C<br />

JI0A B COOTB"TCaTBH CO CBOHM 3aKOHOlaTJlbMC"BOM H ROnOXeHIIHMH Ta'rC 9.<br />

2. I13m0, noOBeprtyroe apecry, HC3aMeAJimjHTho gocraT mCx B K0mrionrcHnmuft cyeHtbtim opraH B<br />

roCy~apCTme Mccra colleplaHHm no crpaxcft, KoTOpMfi B COOTBerCThmH C 3aXOHOA9aTcmcOM 3TOO<br />

roCyARPc'Ba onpCel¢lIeT, ,rro:<br />

a)op~cp awIaOH B OiHOI¢HHH aHHOrO nmua;<br />

b)T 10lO apccoBaHo c Co6.rICOHHCM HaB JIC eUt npOIXCeypH; H<br />

c) npaBa qroro fHIIa 6bumi cofnonemna.<br />

3. ApecroBaHnAi Hmeer npaao o6paTmcx B KOMnIeTcHTIIL opra B rocyJapcI1C Mecra COBCpXaRg nO<br />

CTpaxcfi c xO~aTafiCTBOM 0 BpeMCHHOM OCBOSOXO CHH 1o CA O c pnCpeA1 CyAy.<br />

4. flpH npHHiTHH pCUCHHI B OTHOICHwHH nlo6oro TaKOro xoJaaTaMcTBa KOdneTtHTHbib opraH s<br />

rocynapcse MwCra conepKaHHs noA crpa)Kefi pacCMaTpHBafr Bonpoc 0 TOM, CyI eCTBYlOT 4H, y'iHTM<br />

TBCCrb npeJOJaraMLIX flpeCryTnlCHHfi, '4pe3BhPaflHEJt H HCKJIO0'nTmHwc o6crorrnbcraa, KOTOpMC<br />

OnpaB IBaJIH 6SI BpeMeHHoe ocBo6o IJHlern, H CyIueCrByioT an Heo6xo eM1M rapaHTmi4 n o6ecneenOs<br />

mr-, qO6bi rocyAapcrmo mecra CoJIepKaHHS no cTpaef, mornO Bbinommmr CBOIo o613amocrb no nepe9,alc<br />

TrOo m na CyAy. KOMnCeTeWHTwf opraH B rocyAapcTBe Mecra coepzamH noA cTpaxAC HC Mox0 r<br />

paCC aIBpHBah BOnpOC 0 TOM, BhlJaH 11H opiep Ha apCCT H8W)IeOWHeM o~pa3oM B cooTBercTBmm C<br />

nonnynrraim (a) H (b) nyicra 1 cranH 58.<br />

5. flanaTa npe9BapHTCJibHro ip0OH3BO9CTBa yBe9OMLIeTCI 0 nIIOSOM xogaTacTBC 0 BpCMCHHOM<br />

OCBO6OE eHHH H BIHOCHT PeKOMeCuJI3aUH KOMneTemilOMy OPraHy B "OCy9BpC"BC MecTa coAcpxamui no<br />

cpaxef. KoxmerTHmfl OPiaH B rocy apcTe Mecra conepxamu non crpaxcef Ao BMHCHHAI M peUmJCM<br />

B nOJiHOH Mepe y4TlBaCT TaKHC pCKOMeHI aLHH, B TOM nitule nioOwe peKoMeHnAu4 oHocHTeJmao MOp no<br />

npCAoTBpameiHIo no6cra aroro anna.<br />

6. ECJI 31 ir10o BpCMCUHO ocBo6oxOzHo, flanara npeiCaapHreMHoro HtpOtOBOACrBa MO Xr 3anpaWHB8'M<br />

nepHo, qecKmie AnoLaxA o CTaTyce TaKOr BpeMeHHOr o0CBoSOXIHHA.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

7. IIoCIC Bhmcce~m pewemam o nepe¢ame amia Cyjy rmcyapcnroM Mutca cojiepxaui noA cmpaxe<br />

Aa-Hoe nHLtO KaK MO~o cxopee JiocTaBteTcB B CyA,<br />

CiamaA 60<br />

nfo l anafamne I11Da1m3soCT20 a Cyve<br />

1. Ilocne nopeMH JDHIAa CYAy HN 6POBOJ~hHOfl BBKH JIHBa B CyA HrH HB OCHOBBHHH olpia3a o BBKc<br />

Ina'a npeRaapmtenHoro nplOH3BOAc'rBa y6ocrOBCpaeTca B T0M, 'To Mto .110o 6hO HC pMHpoBaRo 0<br />

npecryn im , KOTOphIC OHO npC lOJIOXHTe.JHO cosepu.no, H 0 ero npanax rIo HaCTORII.CMy CTaTYTy,<br />

BKIOO'1oa opaao xoXaTafCTBOmBa o BpeMeCHHOM oCBO450o eH.H H3-OA cTpaz3H AO HB'ala cyleSHoro<br />

pa36HpaTebCBa •<br />

2. JRiixo, B oTHOeHHH KOTOpOrO BIJaH opjep Ha apecT, MOxcT XoAmTAICTOB3a, o apeMeHmOM<br />

OCBOSOXACHHH H3-1O vTpaXH a0 H'la.a CyAC6HOro pa3SHparfh a. Ecn flanama npeAapwebHorO<br />

flpoH3BOrABa y ocToBepHJnach B TOM, '110 yCnOBNB, YCTaHOBJIcHue IHXTe 1 craTbH 58, ablIlOHeHLI,<br />

31o imo nipoIoOWae coepxa7cs noji crpaxcH. ECI rlanaTa npenaapwremHoro nPOHU3B0o)Ca He<br />

y6ezXeHa B TOM, 'TO OHN BhMOIHeRm, ORa ocao6o Taer gm nRUo HB onpeeIeHHMbX YCJoWBHBX KJIH 6e3<br />

KBKH-IHSO YCflOBHfl.<br />

3. 'laara peaapmvTCjHoro IPOH3BOOC'Ba nepmotNIecKH paCCmarpmBaeT cBoe UocrBHoRBJe.He 06<br />

OBo6ozceHm 9TOro Jli1a Knit 0 cro COJ)pXaHHH fbo cTpazefl H MOeT c.ejlBTh 310 B J!Io6ojk MoMeHT no<br />

npocb6e fipoKypopa 1t311 qroro J mIa. Iocule Taxoro paccMoTpeinu oa MOe1r m3meHrb cBoe<br />

nOCTaHOB3ICHHO, KacaCoeeCl coiepxaHH' no) crpaxeft, ocBo6o1eHH a3-noA CTpax an' yc.ioBKik<br />

OCBOSOJ K)ICHH H3-OJ) Cl7pa,,, ecJIH ORa yaocroepmacB B TOM, ro 3roro Tpe6pyaor H3MCOBwMxec<br />

o~cTorrenwbma.-<br />

4. fara'a fnppABaprrr Horo npoH3BOJcrsa o6ecne'mBaer, o6EJ HMKo He co)epxajicz no Crpameft<br />

HeOnpaBsABHO AOro AO cyi.e6oro pa36HpBTepfb a H3-3a HeonpaAmmoHi 38a¢pIKKH pa36HpaenbCTB co<br />

cropoLi flpoaypopa. B cAryqac Bo3HHKHOBCHUA<br />

TaKOA 3aepaCKH CyA paccMBmpHBaeT BOnpoc o6<br />

ocBo6o)Ke)HHm JIHIOa H3f-no crpaXH Ha oripeJ.eHHhIx YCJIOBH.X HflH 603 KaHX-JH60 YCnOBHil.<br />

5. B c.iBe Heo6xoAHMocm flanaTa nipeABapmrehHoro npoH socTBa MOICT BmUwaBaTh opilep Ra apecT,<br />

'-ro~h, o6ecneq'rr, npHcycme Jima, KxoTopoe 6t1o OCBO601AHO H3-nO, CTPaoK.<br />

CTMA1. 61<br />

YTexriemne o6a eme0t no HaBaia evniiqHOa eVa6Hpaiein'n<br />

1. C ytteTOM nojioxeHef4 nyHrra 2 B TeqeHme pa3ymooro UepHoa BpeMeHI rtocne nepcijamH JHma CyjWy<br />

jiRSO nocne er0 Jro6pooubmHoh BKH B CyA IIamBa npe)BapHTCJebHOrO [lpOH3BocTBa npoBoi)T culyfaHme no<br />

Bonpocy o6 yTCpXAeHxm o6aHHeH , a ocHoBaHm KoTopbix Tipogypop Hamepesaerc Ao6HB ThCR<br />

npOBCeJeHB cyfle6Horo Pa36mpaTei~hcra. Cilymarne ripoBoJrcs B npmcyrcTsH IlpoKypopa H o6aHeMorO,<br />

a rTaKe ero 3aBiwrHHKa.<br />

2. nMimeB upeapOHT oro OpoH3Bo)Isa MoxeT, no npocbe flpoKypopa KnH no co6cme¢Hmoft<br />

HHIOIXlTiBe, npoBeCTH cilyTmamHe B OTcyrCTBHC OSBIBMCMOrO, 'OrOLI yrnepn im o6BIeRHB, Ha oCHOBoBaMI<br />

KOTOpMLX IlpogYpop HaMepeBaercs Ao6HaaiBwC npoBeeHA cyAe6Horo pa36HpaTeJ rbcmr, B cfy'lax, Kora:<br />

a)o6ammexufi oTan3acz o" caoero npasa npHcyc sBoB Ha cnymHH ero Aena; Ham1<br />

b)o6BHHImMLi CKpMBaCTC HJIH He npeAcaBr nqeTc BO3MOAMLIM yCTaHOBH'm ero MeCTOHaXO CJC HHe H<br />

6mnH npepnpmoizmi ace pa3ymu, ie warmi MAB o6eCIC4CHKR ero B" B CyII mto6m HH4)OpMHpOBaTb e"O o


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

aBuJoaraeMI1X nPOrTH Hero o0BtmCHHNX H o CROeM HsMepWHIH npoIerCH cflyMaH ug 10 px.UHI X<br />

o0aBHeHHA .<br />

B yKBa0HOM c.ny'a TaKOC .laO MOXCT 6bM npc~AiuncHo 3aMlHIMKOM, ecm flnaTza<br />

HpelaapHmebHOrO HpoH3BOlCTaa OnpeAUHT, TO M OCls'¢aeT HIrepeCaM npaaocyM .<br />

3. B pa3ysawR CpOK O HaaRna CJIy1aRUR 90 n1Ho:<br />

a) noyaeT xonm oxymeHTa, coJepmmcmro o6ameaa, Ha ocHoaamm KOTOpUX flpoKypOp HaMepeH<br />

Ao6 uamci npmae'ieaHn ,111a K cy11Y; H<br />

b) HH4iOpMHpyeTCz 0 TOM, KaKH6 AOKa38TefCS a HaM epe HCnOJl3OBr ilpoKypop BO Bpe Mi<br />

Coymlamul•<br />

flaTa upe SapHrTrHOro npoH3BoAlcra MoxeT n33 mn' pacnopsxeHH1 omocreJThao pacKpbiTs<br />

HH4IopMaiH An itene2 cymaHmi.<br />

4. JO Ha'ana cnyMaHan poKypop MOxer npoiomcana parc3oaamlxe K mOxeT H3HCHrn mm CHrm<br />

mOShe o6BHHeHar. 06amuacMoMy npeAo eraa rs payMHOe YEJOMeHHC AO Halala cymaHu 0 11060)M<br />

H3MeHCHHII Him cHmIm o6BmHeH . B cny'iae crm o6nmieiHma fpolypop yaejoxz~eT riamary<br />

npeAaPHTMVMHOO nPOH3BOACTB 0 npHHHaX TaKOrO CH9mr.<br />

5. B xone cyumamm fIpoKypop nojACtpama cr Kanimmi nynrr o6mmemu Aoxa3mian mm,<br />

AOcmaTO'IHMH An ycraoaneHma cyxuecTBHlux OCHOBaHHfi nO11mn, q'TO JraHHOe n1O COBepIHflO<br />

npecTynnLRHe, a KooPOM OHO o6BMCTCI. fpolypop MOXCT noaraTcSa HA AOXMCHTanBmHS<br />

JOKa3aT7.MCTRa HZ PC3IOMe OOKa3aTeCrC H MOXCT He aU3lBaTb CESHJrekC1, KOTpme, KaK oxHJ e=,<br />

6yir anaaT noxalaH zH B cyge.<br />

6. B xoge cnymameA xmHo MOxCT:<br />

a) pnfp~cJ Bar Bo3paxCHHI npoTHa o6saeHmg;<br />

b) ocnapHasr AoKa3aTetCI, npelCraBAiIC' MelS IlpOKypOpoM; H<br />

c) npeAmwra m 3oXaaTe ma.<br />

7. flazaTa npeAaapHTwmJHoro fOH3BOCTS8 Ha OCHOIC CJM*IaHEE OnpC4.C.IICT, HMU1T IB Ao Oc0'hTO'HLZm<br />

AlOKa3MeCM AuIS ycmao~aeHm cyecTseHmx ocHoaaHaA nonaram, T'r AaHHoe 31Wo coaepmYnO KaXJOC<br />

H3 npecrynneHxk, a KOTMpaX OH 0o6maircs. OCHOBiUaCh Ha CoSeM ofpC3eneHmH, flajiara<br />

npVeupmenoi npOHl3OACTaa:<br />

a)yTBCpxaCT o6smeHn, B oTlomeHHH KOTopbIx OHa onpeAeala Ha¢IHe 3OCTaToImx<br />

Aox3uwrm.CI, H riepeAieT 310 JI, o T0i Hill mmotR CyAC6HOA ilanae A1 npoSC.eHim cyJueGHoro<br />

pa36HpMC a a CURH C YMePXCIHHUMH OGBHHCHHH;<br />

Aoxa3aTCM. C;<br />

b)He yThepzacT OamuHHal, a omomeHnf KOTOpLX OIN onpeAeaaa OTCyTcrHe Aocrm'r x<br />

c)oTKfnla~BaeT clymaHe x npocT fpoxypopa pacCmOTPn BoutOm0oCTm:<br />

i) npeocrmaIeIHH AnOBHbH]HLX IOKa3aT7bCTB HIR nIpoCoCH AMdliHCflerO paCCJOaaHHl 8<br />

OTHoiCHuH 0oro Him moro KoHxpe-Horo oGammDM; HIM<br />

ii) H3MCHCHHA OGSHHeHMS, riOCKOJIbKy nIpeC;raalneHHMC AOKa3aTeCMlT3 Ka IX DpC 3 CaBJIICTC.=<br />

yCTaHaJINBIMT 4)axr cosep1eH A.pyromo np CCIYJH, nO OI )CIO 1101 IOpHC 10 HIMIMo


Cyja.<br />

<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

6. EJIH lanura npe~sapwmmaoro npowaonvaa He yrepsaeT O6smem, M He nponmByeT<br />

flpoxypopy RriocneBcTH BHOBh o6paTmmn c npocb6oi o ynrpxAeEmH Mmroro o6 BHe , Kora TaXBI<br />

npocb6a noA~epxlmaaerC Aonom3ebmmmH Ao mcO J a.MH.<br />

9. rlocne yracpHjeA o6H-eHMA H o Haana Cy, HO"o pa3OHpaTeJ*hra rlpoxypop moxeT, c<br />

pa3pemeHxa Hlaami npeeaapwehoro npo3OCTBa m nOciee ye jieHNIn o6BHmaeMoro, H3MeHmh<br />

o6ameHmu. EcaN Ipoxypop HaMCpCB~eTS n uzunqm orioluO. zrenue o6B.eHxh H.lH 3aMelumh OOBHHCHxI<br />

6On1cc CCph3HMMH OBHHCHHIMH, TO 8 COOTBeTTHH C HaCTOUMJA cTmf Ajit Onxo O6bm npoBeAe o<br />

cnyuam e yAu a epxneHxHz gm oORHCHHH. floc € Ha'aina cyJle6Horo pa36HpmrCJ~CTn a Ipoxypop MoeT,<br />

c pa3pelueHHI CyiAe6HOA rianami, cHan o6 eimsHcu.<br />

10. Jeficmata al6o0ro pac Bwiiaaoro opcpa apeKpamasCa a oB aomeH mo6wx odaHae1mi, KoTopmLe<br />

He O6iam yraepe-m fanaTOk npeAaapuwrioro npoi3Bo~cra Hm Kapmc 6b=I cmirh IpoxmpopOm.<br />

11. locuie yruepz emm O6SeHmk a cooTemrIHx c HacTomm¢fe crami flpe31WYM co3AaeT Cye6fyfo<br />

naaly, Koropas c y'wrom nyH'ra 9 H cTrb'H 64, ny gr 4, OT'aCaeT 3a npo.cCHHe nocae~poiieero<br />

pa36mpa .tenhma H MoxeT ocyuecnnrI mn oo (Dymu um luaam npeoapmmor ropOH3OCma, KOT0pu<br />

iWter oTmomemie K T KOMY pa36HPaeMCMy H Moxer ahnoimc s xo e Hero.<br />

qACTb 6. CYAEBHOE PA3BHPATEJIIhCBO<br />

Craina 62<br />

Metm cVDeB6Horo amOmpammcr<br />

1. EcITH He OyeT npmuro pemHCm o HHoM, MeCrOM cy~e6HOMO pa36uparemcrTa anmmencg MemrO<br />

npe6aumm Cyj a.<br />

CrAma 63<br />

Cvrne6Hoc Va36mOHffrOIIIeC'hco a flnHvTWCTB, O6aaIxeMOT'0<br />

1. Oi,msewah npcyrcayeT Ha cyjc6Hoa pa36HpaTemme.<br />

2. EcIm o0mBHemaiA, npHcyrcTBy1OHLHx a CyAe, rpo oa zxer HapYnifr xoji CyAc6HOM pa360paTCmCa,<br />

CyAeOHal nanara MoxcT yA amrm o6oBHHzmom H flpegocnfwfucT emy BO3MOXHOCTh C . fm0b 3a XOAOM<br />

pa36HpaTemcirna H jiaTb yKa3am 3amnm'XY, HaXOAHCb 3a upeeamm Mana 3acewmi, C<br />

Hcnojm3oBaHme,, xora TM HC06XoJHMo, cpec CelasH. Ya3amwae meph npnlmmai Tore6 o a<br />

Hc AzIoRmTeomamou o6crornwbmax nocce Toro, KM HHWC pa3yMHeU MepU 6W11H r[pH3HOKI [ ReIIpHI OHLIMH<br />

H TOMKO B T'MeHHC Taxoro nepIHOxa spOMCHH, KoTophin flfliCS Crpo HCO6XOAHMl[M.<br />

Cryra 6 4<br />

OYHKumN H nnioMo'loIg Cyvfdnn O flniAnTU<br />

1. 0ymum H nojmoMoqm CyefHto nanaTi, npezycuorpemue B Hacmzaei crae, ocymnecrwnoTr<br />

B CowrBCTCTBaH c HaCTOd Cra'yro H [IparndzaaH npop €Rpa H Annumim.<br />

2. CyAcHau nanara o6ecne'msacr, ,cro6ba pa36sparnwram 6wio cnpaBCiAaMMx H OlImpm H<br />

np0Bo,[HJ0Q, TIpH nojIom co6rnoteHmH npa ofawmemoro H c onmKLm yqC1Vm Heofto.moCTI 3aufrlM


nOThpnCmnHx H CBMaureeA .<br />

<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

3. ocac TOMm, KAX JeIAO Ha3H8'CHO K CJIYIIaHHIO B COOTBMMHH C HaCTouIHM CT3IyOM, CYI e6Hag<br />

aam, H93HM8'CHHU A PaCCMOTPCHRR AeJa:<br />

a)COB1a1BCTC1O CTOpOHaMH K npHHMaeT TaKHe npOUC.ypM, KOTOphfe HeO6XOA1mbj Au1 coAeAcTB<br />

cnpaBcj8oHSOaY H 6icrpoMy npoBeCHeio pa36HPaTUCTBa;<br />

H<br />

b)onpeA eascr i3tnK HJH 23b.r, xoTopue 6yjiyr HcUom oL3oBBC B xotc cyAe6oro pawdpawrn.cr-ra;<br />

C)c c06moAc eM m06EJx HHWX COOTBVeTCYIOUJI nOAOCHHIA HaCLoxO~ero CTaMya, npeXycMaTpHBacT<br />

paCKpMTHe, 3a6JIarOBpCMeHHO 0 Haqajia CY¢e6Horo pa36HpanTebcraa, AOKyMeHTroB HAm HH4wOPMaHlIH,<br />

KOTOp.le AO 9TOoM He 6hlJIH pacKpUM, C TCM RTm06 MO)KHO 61.110 Hafllesautjm o6pa3oM no0J1OTOBH1C1 x<br />

CYJAC6HOMY pa36HpareTMCy.<br />

4. CYAe6HU naanTa MOxeT, CaH 3m Tpe6y¢TA Ana 34)KTnHoro n cHpaa3HBoro sIhI0JIHeHHL eo<br />

cBoHx (byHKI2Hf, nepellaT npeABapwmrebAue sonpocbi a Iannay npeABaparrenoro IPO3BOJICTh& Him, npH<br />

HtO6XOImdOCT, MHoMy cynbc OTreAaeHM1 npcuBapHTebHOO fpOH3BO, CTMa, KMCICOuICWCeHC B PaCIIop xCH Hl.<br />

5. HanpasuH yBCAOM eHHe cTopoHam, CyAe6Has naJI aa MOXKC, B COOTBCTCTBYIOUIH CWjy'481,<br />

pacnopBAH'mca o6 O6abejxeHmH HJIH pa3IweCeh-H O6BHHcHME npoTa 6oace qeM oIoo o6BHHeMoro.<br />

6. 1pM OcymcTaBnCHHM CBOMX (byHKIfi A1O Haa1a cyc6Horo pam6MpalumcTm HiH B xOl¢ cyACe6Horo<br />

paa6Hrreicma Cy1e6a naJiaa, nPH HCOXOAKHMOCTH:<br />

cram1 61;<br />

a) ocyiuecnnser mo6bie 4iyMHKumH fla3Mar npeJAapm'eHoro npo M olI'raa, ynoMmHyrue IyHKTc1<br />

b)Tpe6yer 1Kx cBHAeTeze H A'aRH HmH noKa3aHH, a TaKxC npeg1zueHRO AOKyIeIHTA1.M1x H<br />

mlUX joKa3aTWMCTB, npM6eras, eCCiH TM HeO6XOJMMO, K nOMOUIH rocy~apcrB, KaX 3O npejyCMOTpeHo 8<br />

Hacroxmem Crayre;<br />

c)o6ccnenxaaer Hepa3rnameHxe KoH p4HJeH)IJIabHoi HH4bopmMaKH;<br />

d)A PA pactopzxeHHe o npeAcmuJICHH loflOnHTCJlgHM1X AOKa38Ta1b K .IOKa3aTeJA1CTBaM, KOTOplie<br />

yxe co6pamw Ao cype6Horo P36HpaTeAl.CTa HIA npecRTaBneRH CTOpOHaMH B Xo. cyl.e6Horo<br />

pa36HpaTClrMo€a;<br />

e)o6eCneqaeT 3atHMTy 06BHHMeMoro, cBHJJeuie H noTepnesBmI ; H<br />

f)B1smocwr pemetme no jm6E.M HHMM HmeHIoWMM oTHOXeme K Aefy Bonpocam.<br />

7. CyA96HsO pa36HpamenlcrBo unierc oTpuTIM. O aKO CyJIeOHa a iauaTa mOxeT ycraTHOaHT1, 'ro<br />

oco6Me o6croTremchnCra Tpe6yoT TOo, '1ro6 HeKOTOpme 3aCeAwaHH 'ipoB oAlKJaC B 3aXpbITOM 3aCeHHH jAnn<br />

LlezeAi, npeJWcMOTC-HHLX B craThe 68, Hmm B MIIrpeCaX 3auvmr KOHII.CHM&afbHOA HJ.H 4TyCPMHTAHOA<br />

HMibOpMaaBm, Koropas AoJImHa 6hrll rpCIACM eH& B KB eCr1 AOKa3aTeA.c<br />

8. a)B Hanaie paB3fpamxCTna Cype6naq HJIaTi 3q'HThiBaeT o6BmhseMOMy o6BmHCIem, paHee<br />

yurpzteioe lanaoft npC. apwreaIHoro npoH3BOACTBa. CyAeOsa H aIaM yAOCTOBepieTC1 B TOM, 'ro<br />

o6smacMug no HHMae'T coJIepxaHHe o6BHHCH Hj. OHa Aaer 06BHHIeMOMY B03MO)KHOCrb nlpH3HaT. CIOIo BtMuy<br />

B COOTBCTTHH CO CTamCM 65 HAM 3aiBBrrb o CB0Ce HeBaHOBHOCFH.<br />

b) B xoAe cyAe6Horo pa36Hpareimca rnpCACeAaTenCTmyio1uxxA cyPAb MOxeT ABaTh yKB3amM<br />

OfIOCHTC HO npoBeemHi pa3mpa1.C-ba, B TOM nHCAC Aa o6ccnecHm1 Toro, qo6j OHO npoBoPMtoCh


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

cnpaaezmio m 6cnpHcpacmo. C co6moAeHmeM Mo6Mx yKaaHfA npWWM MyIOMCM cyjAb c€oposar<br />

Mor n MpecyUA joKa3aTeMCM 9 COCOTyaeeVy C nonoXeMM NarMCTzero CM"yrt.<br />

9. Cyje6Hu aa, a qacnmocnM, KUec npaao no xoj-ankcrgy oHo§ H3 cropoH Kan no caoel<br />

a)aEaocrm pememig o Aonycr2Wocim mm orocnuoc-u j~ra3apmcm;H<br />

b) npmmmace aHeo6xo, mwrme Mepw Ana noqepxamH nopajua a xoue caymamnn.<br />

10. Cy~e6er nanaTa o6ccneqmerT coc'raaneeme nojmoro npoooxa cye6Horo pa36Hprmcm, To'lo0<br />

oTpaaM ero xoA npottecca, SenCHr€ R coxpancmne KOmoporo aosaem<br />

rc ha CXPeUpE.<br />

C ama65<br />

ncuans A, fleik Vynag a 'vae InpnH3H ua NmH<br />

1. Korea oamesemmiaka upn3ac camo aEmy coruaco nymry 8(a) Mea'n'H 64, Cyne6nam naama<br />

O(peC.jN"T:<br />

a)oco3aae'r an o6amuemuft xapamrrp m nocneAcmraa npH3HBmmH ceda asmoataxl;<br />

b)c je.ano n ro npitmarme oaaeemm Ao~poaomnmo nocne ,ocTroqHux KoHcyjmTauimf c<br />

3RaXwMnOM; H<br />

c)nojMsep~acrcs a npemanne atmu o6romme aa Aewa, auoxemumw:<br />

i) a Aoxy/emx, coepmaumix o6axmeHz, peamaem e [poKyppou u npmaxame<br />

o6ammnemua;<br />

ii) a mo6wx maTepHiiax, npenAcTameHHux 17poKypopoM, KOTopme nonlpennmOr o6BmlHHx H<br />

KoTOpue npHHHdaeT 063mxmze; H<br />

iii) a oio6bix Apyrx Aoxa3aremcmax, Tamn ax nomasaua canAeTne6,, npe-aneCMefnx<br />

Ilpoxypopom Ran o6am ma .<br />

2. Ecin Cyie6naz iaa y.ocroaempca a rom, 'rro ycaosm, yxamnme a nynmr 1, co6mormi,<br />

oaa pacMaa naaCr InpB3MannC an.a, HaplUy C M06, An oDOmm M sw OVUCa3an , KoTophle<br />

6 wm npcraacmt, raK yc'raHaasamme ace qcymcrmaeHo aa,,ae o6MO MUCM, Heo6xoAmme An<br />

Roa3aremM cosepmem npeCTYeMa, B oTHomeHH Koropolo C.eao np2HaeMC, H MOURT OcyjM'<br />

odmamaemoro 3a CORepmeHNC 3roo pC PCTMeH.<br />

3. Eczx Cynefan naam He ynocoepmcz a ToM, 'rO ycnoIa., yKa3aHHmC B nyrore 1, coftmnwe ,<br />

OHa CIOJ Rr R3 TOFO 'TO tpHSHMe r<br />

BEH He meO me='a, s a sTOM cnyrae ola pa pamOpaxenne<br />

npo O ,zm cync5Hoc pa36npaTemcmo a coorsercran c o6amnen npolemnamu paccorpeHa Rena,<br />

npenyc~orpenmNu Hacromniwm Craiyrom, H MozeT nepeamr wro Aeo ,pyrolk Cy~e6HoAi niare.<br />

4. EcanH CyAe6Has nanara nonRaer, q'3 a HmHpecax npaaocynna, a acnToc'o mrepecax<br />

norepieamx, Tpe6yeTca 6once nonoe rmnoxHae o6cOmre ,cra aea, Cye6Hu naarm moxeT:<br />

a)o6pamumc x fpoKypopy c npoca6oA upencraamM ,lOnOAMlnbMCUe AOxa3aaTtenCTa, B oqa<br />

IIOxa38lHlx cBm4,cIk; Him<br />

b)Ara pacnopxeoem npoAonm' cyeooe pa36npvmem B ooonmm c o6wunaum


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

npoUtyaMH paccMUmPcma Aena, nfp OrpHmHam naCvoiu Crarymm, m 3 mou cnyae ona HcxOAHT<br />

10 TOO, 'n UP H3MC IHM He RaMUO MCMre , H M0XeT BtpeaM Mr0 ACO jPyrOR CyAOHoik nUaTt.<br />

5. J11o0o o6cyXjeme MeNy I'POKypopoM H 3aWWoA ionpoca 0d 2Mmcmm odameHmA, npumamam<br />

BEE HMm Haa EH, nojAXeMane HaaaqCHMO, He JISCCI o613ATJM AU CyAa.<br />

CyTamg 66<br />

1. IaXj Af CqaTn HCBHHOBHIH, noLKa eo 1HH8 He dyjICr ,Aman38H B Cyc B coOTB-mmhBH c<br />

npKMeHHMlM 3alfo0oM.<br />

2. BPepA AoUaamax alflMW os6BMcoro nen Ha IIPOKYPOPC.<br />

3. ARK ocyzj em 06HHCMOO Cyji ,IOJXeH y6ej A'nc 3 TOM, 'TM o6BHESOMMN RHOBH H qTo HO<br />

nOJZBeXH cOMCHMo Ha pa3YMHX OCHOUaB.<br />

Ciaila 67<br />

1. lpa onpencnomm io6oro odsBmemH o6smizeuml Hmeer npaao Ha nydHmoe coymame, c yqm'a m<br />

noBoxeHfMl HacoSMer Crayra, Ha Cnpa ncB niot cJymame, npoaojomoe 6ecnpmcrpacmum o6pa3om, H<br />

KaX MHHEMyM Ha CJIeC,,OULtHC rapaHTlH Ha OCHOBe nOJiHOrO pazeHcros:<br />

a)GWM B cpoRHom nopme m noolpo6Ho YB=C4oMNCRJM Ha anMse, KoRapul odinmnuwft noHmmaCT<br />

B nOJfIHOik MCpe H Ha xOapOM OH roaOpwrr, 0 Xaparrpe, OCHOBAHE H coCpXam FlpCAbMJzcmEoro Cy<br />

o~smiem;<br />

b)xmvm AOCvr o'OC BPOMS H B03MO L =HOClh nul r HO* CBoO* aoMMoJroTnH<br />

a I, a TUXz Ca060AHO<br />

cHocHm R c aM dpamaMM 3awAImHHOM a ycJaORiua KOH4H e HanJofoH;<br />

C)6WaM CYIIOGM 6e HeonpasjaR~l 3a lepZ K;<br />

d)c yqerom nymri 2 craTm 63 5sum cyjuw a s cro npxcyrcmTHH H samumam ce6s nwmo az~o<br />

,icpe3 focpejcTsO Ha3macOHHO H 3a1wzIHHma, Shm yEa,,MlIOO. IHbM, =CJ.I OH He HMOCT 3awA ,m, o6<br />

WrON npaBc, KMeM Ha3HaqeHHoro eM Cy CL" M 3auwTHHKa 3 maOM cma, ]or7ja Tom" Tpe76ywr mrrepocm<br />

npaBocyJIHI, H 6ow3mewO L u 11010 a 1 0om cn yqa, Kora OH He pacoZaraeTr oCIT UMN<br />

CPrCAACaBME An Oflla7I ycnyr 3alUUnHUMa;<br />

e)AorpanLumaih noKS3bIISomux npormB Hero CBIentCr Hm eri R IpBO P Ha TO, q'aO6M a<br />

caajoren S6hm Anpomem, a Taze HueTe apao Ha m3oB H RAonpoc cmAaerenk, IRno(a maauon(Hx a er<br />

IMa.3y, Ha TeX XC yCJIOBHX, KaXHe cyteCT15yiOT An1 CSaHJTea, nlOurBia&nLwIHX upol Heo.<br />

063OSeMUR Taae KMecT UpaBo naUwrTM apryMCHemU B ciol 3a=r n npeJCmUm HnHo<br />

ALOKa3&TOICTU, ZBaIUQHeCR AOInYC n MlMH cornacHo HacroaeMy C raryry;<br />

l)cnawno nomQfoMaNrWZ noMonlDa Vaau4bHlXpoaamaaro nepeRoimxa x nojyqaBrh HePCBOAW,<br />

HoooAHmwoe AnA Toro, 'ro6u cyAe6Hoc pa36upwwhmo o rlecano rpe06oaInM cnpaejimmocnM, B<br />

CJIY'aRX, KolrA& libm, HCfnOJIb3yewwR Aill paccmopeHHR ACJa B CyC nH6o npH cOclBJIcHR oJymemOB,<br />

3pejrcTaBae_,owx CyJy, He XBIRARl TeM E3btKOM, KoTophif o amaieam f nOHHMM a noJfol Mepe H Ha<br />

KOTOpOM OH rOBOPHT;


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

g) He 6u1, UpHHyxJaeMimM x ja' floKa3alHmk JIH6o K npH3HaHHO ce6m BHHOwINIM H HMCT lpaO<br />

xpamrm MioPiaHe, npH'eM TaKOc MOn'aiMe He ,AO.1XHO npHHxmaTzCI so BHxMme npH onpeueneHKH<br />

BEHOBHOCTH HAH HCBHHOBHOCTH;<br />

h)de3 IpxHaTHn nplcsrH ehicrynaTh c ycrmuxH mm IIHMMCMHMH 3BanIACeHMm B cRo1 3amNTy; H<br />

i) 6am cso6omm or 6pemenN Aoxa3jIa BN o~paTmoro Htc oftamocn onpoacpxetm .<br />

2. B J.onoiHeime K mo~omy ApyroMy pacepmwmo mbopmawim, npexncmoTpeHoMy B HacrmgeM<br />

CUaTyrc, flpoxYpop Tax CKOPO, HaCKOA KO 9TO Io3MoXHo, npeAhIBaBeT 3altrre IweIolgec 8 ero<br />

pacnopgxeHH HaH noA ero KOHTpOACM OKa3aTCArbCrsa, KOT0phlC, nO Cr0 MHeHHI0, CBHACTCJI CTBYlIOT HIH<br />

AO811111 CBH JIr eIBOBaTh 0 HCSHHOBHOCN OOBHH eMOO, HNH 0 HaaNHxN O uTmT0 ALTI CMmuoqajotmx<br />

HHY, HaH CnOCO6Hft fo o BN Ha AocroBepRocrb AOKa3aTeAbCT o6snHCHN. ho6bIe CoMHeHNi B<br />

OTHoieHE ripNMwHeiHm aToro [yHKTa papemaioTCa Cy, oa.<br />

CTaTb 68<br />

3amw-a noTrel[em1UlU H C Kefere 14 uz "RClCe R Pa.HaeaThCTSe<br />

1. CyA npHNmaeT Ha JIC]1He MCpM iiAN 3aUnUrr 6e3naCHoc'rH, 4)H3HeCKOIO H nCxXHqecKoro<br />

6uaronoa y'uL, ,oCrOmHCTBa H HCIpHXOCHo~eCHOCTr n mof = a3H nOTCpHBeiiHX H CB3~tCJene. RfpH 9TOM<br />

Cy, yqHEiaaer Bce OOOTaCCYsPOyl HC [laKTOp, B TOM 'Hcle 03paCr, rKHACPHNI 4Parop, Ka arO<br />

omp¢eACeeHO B nylxTe 3 craThH 7, H COCTOAHHe 3AOpOBbg, a TazXe xapaCK7p npeCrynCHNM, H, B<br />

qaCTHOCTr, HO He orpaawHRaaaCb 3T1M, To o~croIJIbcrhO, 'TO npecryne¢HHe IXJflO'aJIO CeKcya.UbHoe<br />

HacHmImC, reHJCBpHoe HacHeeH¢ HH HKCHaHC B OTHOUCHHH Avretl. flpoKypop [pHHmHlaI TaxHe Mephi, B<br />

oco6eHHocTx npH npOBe eHHH pacc¢jinO~aHN H ocyaeurmecHm yrwoIoHoro rnpeczeARIam sa gm<br />

npecrynnem . TaKH¢ MCphl He AOIGKAI HaHOCNrb yi.tep6 npaBaM oBNNIIMOrO HAH 6hrln HCOBMecmMMMN<br />

C HHMH, a mKae HaocH7-h yT1ep6 upoB=JHemo cnpaeAnm3oro H 6ecnpmcapacrHoro cy88HOrO<br />

pa36patmcrsa.<br />

2. Kax HCKAIOq¢HHC H3 npHNiU3ma npose1emwx oTxp1ThX c"JMumiB , npeAIyCMOTpCHHOrO craThe 67,<br />

najimf Cya Mory'r Au 3au11Hm uoTepnea Hx H CBH~erTeJCk Hrs o6BNmHEomo nposCm mo6yo [acr<br />

pa36apatmca in camera jum pa3pemN npecraruwm oxaOaaTC, cra C fOMOlb[D S.UCKWrOHHMX HAN<br />

bomix cnewHamawx cpec m. B qaC-iOCTH, TaKH¢ mepu npHHaiOrCi B Cliyae, KOFa pC'(b [,ACT 0<br />

XKfrBme CKCyabLHOrO HaCHIHS HAH p 6 HKC, KOTOpWM INABJC TH OTCPCpemHM KiN CBHJI CTCM, eCi CyAOM<br />

He pCIn HCaHO IOoe, C yqeTmM BOcX o6CTOmTCLOT1, B OCO6CHHOCTH MHCHHX TaKoro nOTepneBiaero Hin<br />

CBNMACTC •<br />

3. Ha crum cye6Horo pa36HpaTeimca, xompue CyA cower Au -roro no[xo Amwo , CyA<br />

pa3PelaCT npCACT8aUa H pacCMaTpNBaTh MHC[CI H onaceHm noeCpniCIMHX, KOra Rx AnK~e HHrepecu<br />

OKa3bUaOTCA 3BTpoHyrbhMN, HO 1"aHM o6pa3OM, Tff6Mb W7O He HaHOCHO yinep6a N He npoTNBopeqmo<br />

npaaM O6BmcMoro H npoBeAcHm cnpaBeAHBoro H 6eCnpcrpacmoro cynefHoro pa35NpaTeAbCTaa. B<br />

COIyqaJX, KOrea CyA CRJMCT 3T7 OnpaSAaHH61M, TRae MHHRX H oaaCeNHH Moryr H.naraTCR 3aOHHIUMH<br />

npJcruBr-eCaIM noTpnemnHx B cooT THm c IpuHaImH npoileCWpu H AoKa3hi13HI.<br />

4. rpynna no oxa3aHl0m nOMO(nw nOTepneamHM H cmNeTCaM MOme? pCKOMeHBalTb fpoKypopy H Cyj<br />

COOTBCrTEYIOIUHe MCpLI 3BalHMTI, InpoIjeyphi o6CncCeHHI 6C3onacHocTH, npeAoc7ARneHxs KOHcyflbTqI HOHHOA<br />

H HHOt [TOMOWN, YyIOMZHyTOI( B nyHInT 6 C1rThH 43.<br />

5. Korea pacpurme foa3ore.au Cr HAmN N4toPM1I2l B COOTBTCrMH C HaCRA0HM CTTyroM MOECT<br />

flOwlC' 3a ooft cpbepylO yrpo3y AU 63onacHocm Jo6oro CsHAvTCAs KA % AHOB er CCMLH,<br />

fipoxypop MOzeT Aux tteCH ocyuxecrCBeHHI o06hx npo~iecyaALMmx ACeC'HA, HMeiOUlHX meCTO AO HanaA<br />

CJyiUHr no AWCy He pacapuaBM TaKle AOKa3CaTC1B HAnH HKHOPMatiio, H BMCTo groro npecT" fTb<br />

Hx pemoMC. Yia3aHeae Meph OCynxeCrBruAIOTCs TaxHm oGpa3OM, 'rrodI, 3r0 He HaHOCHO yuiep6a m He


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

abo ecoemmum c npaMu oOe m o H fnpoeimfcM cnpaeUn30ro N 6ecnpHCrpaC77forO cy~e6nowo<br />

pa36lPareMca.<br />

6. rocyAapcmo NoxCT o6paTreca r npoch6oik o npHmfrIN Heo6xoWOu x Mep, o6eCUeqHBaiOuxHX 3aEWlri<br />

cM cJXaMUx HAn npCACTa3Hre*.ea, a Taie MCP no 3aWIrrM KOH4)5eHlXW IJ oA H qyBcMMe.HOR<br />

Cum~h 69<br />

1. flpezie qeCM ripHc~ymrb r Aaqe nioKa3aSmA, uzwajdi cBaieTreM a cooM'ercraM c flpaBHnuaMH<br />

npogeUCpj H AOK3hiUNMU npNNMaCT Ha ce~m oOz3aTeWJT1CWo Aaea npaMHnUe inOKaHalS.<br />

2. rloxumu Aamw cBAmmamU~ B cyJW5Hom laCAUe MMNO, flOCKOJUhKy HHQC He<br />

nPeRC&MHzaaeTca MepaMM, H3flOXCHMMH a cmrim 68 mNA a rlpaBnax npoZfypm H jOxa3omhNms. Cyn<br />

MOzeT Taixe pa3pemirm j tay viva voce (ycriwi) HN 3anucamHRX c noMoXMeto e€o- HAN<br />

ayIoToxmNK nora3aNi cBmACmu, a Taxxe npencTaJue AOKYMCNTO HM 3amnCel rpH yCROaHN<br />

co,6OoeHw no o eMd HacMieSM C r'a H 5 coocT'mHN c llpawmaaem npoitcJypu m jioxasb3euSlm.<br />

3m MepU He AORIHM HaHocHrh ymep6 nAN npomuop'uem npaaw o6smaemoro.<br />

3. Cropom moryr npecaarBm AoxawAr a, OTHCmo cWc X Aeny, a COOTmeCmm Co Cramte 64.<br />

CyA npaoMogea Tpc6oBamm npecraueNm acex Aoxa~aTCAr, KOTOphc oH czNraeCT HWeo6xoAJmW N AN<br />

yCIaNHOAnNe HC?'HHN.<br />

4. CyA Moxer a cooTerICI Hn C fI&pBH. aMH npouitp R J toK83Ita8N- DUCTh pC MeHe o6<br />

OTHOCHMOCTH HMANJOInYCYMO~M =l1bh J1Oi*3STCJMhCI, hPHHMB 13PN M1OM 80 SHaHRO , aay c<br />

IpWo'M, Nx cHAy, a 'axe BpeJ, KoIopbtl Taxec ,0oKa3aTcm Moryr nptmi1rm"b UipoBCAeHNJO<br />

cnpauI RBoro cyJe6Horo pa36HpaTef lbV'a HN cnpaC utob ogeHIc noamii cMaemrTa.<br />

5. CyA yu er m co6mo aer npHBHAMeHlt Ha KoHa tAHeMDMaMOCT, npeX'cmorpeHHMe a flpaam.ax<br />

nPOuleJA'PhU H AOMU3MWH.<br />

6. CyA He Tpe6yeT Aomm3mmHS, m o6he1mseH mun-x 4lios, Ho mOxeT npmHmux caejeHnno a<br />

Cyc6eHom nopOP .•<br />

7. goKa3aTJxb-ma, XoMpbie UOfM]'eHbl a pCym.Ttre HapyMeHR2 flOJItONN Hacoaguero CTayTa HmA<br />

MeX.apOAHO flPH3HaNHMX Upan qeJoaeaa, He EUR1OM AOITyCTIII, CjiH:<br />

a) HapyuetH~e nopozaeT cepbel1e comdeNN a AocOepHocm Aox&UTULCM; H<br />

b) AonycK AomaATejmcm 68W 6w1 HeCOsMCcrtm c Ao6pocoaemC"hm npoa.CJHaCM pa36HpaTejibcha H<br />

HaHOCHA dt 'y eCpbe.3Hnff YnePI.<br />

8. Pemaz nonpoc 0 AonycrHMocrT H oIH OCKMOCr OX8sgncti, Co6pamlwx rocyapclrao, Cyn He<br />

AOneH RiMOCH7% pemeH, oTocHrrTMHO npH?4eeHH HBJNONaMHNOo 3aBoHoJasMrsCMa aroro roCyapCma.<br />

Cmiihg 7 0<br />

fleervrTuema nort omnmeleg nnaotn'Vfn<br />

1. CyA o6fAKteA iopHcJW~m=Mea a orTomeHH cAjeIYIOmI npecrynnemi nparmN o'mpafl . mmNS<br />

npauocyA", coaepumem npewamepealo:


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

a)A j O immx ioma3BHI nocne npLTH oOB3aTCubCI B coomerVmm c nytwom I -ranTb 69<br />

,uanr nPRaAMMe noxaaasmH;<br />

b)npeAcrasmme saaeomo noxmHx Hm 481mw J.OIBSATCI; cawMmao3WWX<br />

C)nporUofpaIlOe oUa3aiHe 5o3Amcma Ha CBUVere, conmae nomex Him npe1lcfmltm<br />

npHcyrcmmo canCTteJ. Hnm Aa'le Sm noaafi, Bo3Atocrmse Ha cusareja B XaqeaCa B3M'aeerac 3la An Jly<br />

HI noxaasmit Hi yHH'rOxeHHC AOKa3BT.J1CT, Hx 4sancmDHKnua Hm ne flp e HI c6opy;<br />

d)co3Aame I ,pefETBHAk 3anymsaIHe mm npHS!IoripaBBoe Bo3AcfcTRHC Ha ,oJ)m omoc nmao Cyja<br />

C 50M,10 npMI y)WM Him YkMM y ,Mooc IAO, OMCT, . HC BbsmomWr K Him BhUIOJMWn HeHJIeSeCxBmm<br />

o~p3om em o6ssasmocrm;<br />

e)oK&3ase BmseftcrBms Ha JIOJIXBOCTmOe 1mmo Cya a KIecrae RO3We3iW 3a TO, 'TO 9To FM<br />

30500 JIOIHOCTU OO ISU IO HII~O CBOJS OcEi3BHHOCTliH<br />

f)ammorBrCJumo umx nonluy e w3311 B Ka'erae Aonmzocmoro nmza Cysa B CMR co cBoMiM<br />

o4iKwmm m o63aHHocrImm •<br />

2. IlpmIHmI' H pofll.opU, prympy'Iee ocymmeCC e Cy-oM jo3pC am B ooMCHH<br />

npecrymewmi Ha ocoaB&Htm HacTomAe* craSH, JIoam Z 6surm imrma xe, 'ro MAOXeCM B ipana..ax<br />

upoglpu H Aoxaumxa. YcnoaH oa.3mm5 ,,ew,,YHapoJ)Horo coecWCmHx Cyxw e omoema em1<br />

pa35HpaTmn-rB no HacToImme crae peyzmpywma B' arpnm sBAfloO n BTso 3anpamnaeaom<br />

rocysalPca •<br />

3. B czyw umecezow pememlBHi o IpmHumlHH maxoro-m6o mw am osm CyA Moxer Haumauam<br />

HaK aH)!e 8 MW nmmem CB0oAM Ha CPoK HO OenCC 1T mC Hm mTpasa B cooraec-mn c<br />

IlpB1maH npOiejIypM H JAoK,3hlBaHxx, ii,)! Toro H JIpyroro oWOopeemo.<br />

4. a)Kaj oe rocyAapcino-yuc'rm= pacnpocrpaager cmoe yronomsoe 3UaooH1AraWWM, ycrBasnmBaionqee<br />

MCpl HaXB3aHU 3a ipCclynCH!, R anpaRCHRe rUPUMa npOBCISWHX paccA e, Hloalm H OcTmeBaO<br />

CyAOlIpO83BOjZCsa, HS npCCrYnfeHl ispo MafliB np cyBIACH, yiI mY -le a IacICt0I1C CTBe,<br />

coBCpmmume cro rpa 0moM =16o HO 0ro TeppHTopHR.<br />

b) lio UpObc Cyia roCY1PCT-yIaCTEHK, KOra OHO CU'CT 9meCrmL,<br />

To ymcpejaer O eao caomK<br />

KomnmRTHum opraas us cyje~soro ripecnCoBaaM. 3Tm opraHmH Tt m0a,.bHo paccma1mT TKMC ej0a5<br />

H ImNJ.CJKT Ao€rammo'SnI€ peCypcw An, Toro, ,nodw Hx paccmo~Rpame Morao 6brm npoaC.o 0145c1Bmmun1<br />

CTBSYE 71<br />

CMMsrHII 3 Heg oRSCI3wrCMMMHOC ilOCRCM B C'yM<br />

1. CYA MoXC? HaBSURLIEB M, npHCY'VMYPM onIx B CyAC, 3a Heno3O b no e e , B TOM<br />

4HcHse 3a cpwLB pa36HpaTC Tar Rm npSaMepemAM = mrKaS m ioBmm er pacuopIaxam, IOCpGACTBOM<br />

BApUMCTpaTMhHMSX uep, IpOMe JmncsmC CBo6OJWh, T2KHX, KaK pe eeCMOe 14 ItOcM Oe YAaJI He H3<br />

Saua cya, muTpa4) Him mae noo6Tume mepbi, npwlycNowrpeme B rlpaBanax apouecJapN H 1oa3mnamu.<br />

2. ripoulewpm, peryimpyonme npHmeCHme mep, yKa3aH S nyH 1, yc'rmnBB1 B lnpammax<br />

WlpoS1,yp U H , orU3Ha".


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

Cmiag 7 2<br />

3ainjm omdiuhManum, iffmarjuammeff Hanman.Hrm 6eoinacpePr'<br />

1. Hacroanaa CraTh npMeTRcM a JO60M CfyRae, Korea pacipunme mcpopMan;HH M AoKyMeHwM<br />

rocygapcTa HaHCeJno 6i, ro MHCHHIO STOr rOCYA&pCrBa, yMCp6 KHTepecaM erm HaWOHaJIhHOA<br />

6e3onacHocrH. TaKHe ciypaH axAO'lalOT a ce6z cfyqaH, Ha KOTOpme pacnpocrpansvoca nozoxcHKa<br />

nyeHroa 2 H 3 cTaTh 56, nyHnra 3 cramm 61, nyiHra 3 CTtTIH 64, nYHore 2 cra-mI 67, nynrra 6<br />

cram"H 68, nyHrra 6 craM 87 m cramI. 93, a Taxxe cny'an, 5O3HmxatorHC Ha zInoTof0 )pyruft cra nH<br />

cyAe6Horo pa36npaTbmca, Ha KOTOpOi MO)KeT Bcrasa sonnpoc o TaKoM pacKpbrrxw.<br />

2. Havromnaa craTa npHMHlenrCs Taile a c'asx, Borla annO, K NOTOpONy 6uaa o6pazMena<br />

npOcb6a npeACraaWrM HH40opMaLUDo HaH )AOKa3arealcMa, orKa3aoC-, cAena'f 9To KJH nepeWano AaothL<br />

sonpoc rocyJapcrBy Ha TOM OcHO~aHHH, '41 pacKpLrI¢ HaHCcaO 6b] ymep6 HHrepecam HalmoHaabHofl<br />

6e3onaCHocTm rocy9apcraa, H 3anMlnpCcoaaliMo mcyJapcmo noA7MhpXJIAeT, '4M0, no em MeHHO, TaKoC<br />

pacXpElTHC HaHeC.aO 6u ywep6 HmTCpecam ero Ha uOHOJNabHO 6e3onaclHocTm.<br />

3. HHrm a HVacWAu ¢d crambe He HaHocHr yxuep6a Tpe6oannM KOH4)HAJgHEuIbocrnc, npHMCeRM L Ha<br />

OCHOEaHHH nynrra 3(e) H (f) CraThH 54, 1160 npHMCHeHmO craba 73.<br />

4. ECA KaEoMy-JIH6o rocynapcray craHowrc H3BCCTHO 0 TOM, TFO I 4)OpMannI R AN JOZyMeHlT<br />

rocyJIapcrBa pacXpUaalOrci HAM, aepor'mo, 6yjiyr pacKpbrm. Ha XaxoYf-jH6o cramml CyAC6HOro<br />

pa36HpaTenbcrma, H, no cro mHemO, Hx pacupumireM 6w 6u HaHeceH ytDep6 norepecam cro<br />

HaiwoHaanbHOft 6e3onacHocTH, TaKOC rocyjapcrao Bpaae ocyLneCraNM aMeaRehjmco, C TeM rro6<br />

Ao6mrcz peueu AaHoro aonpoca a CoorTBecr"HH c Hacroahme crameft.<br />

5. EcnH, no mHeHlO KaRoro-aH6o rocyapClaa, pacKpb'mHe mH4)OpMawlHm HaHecno 6I yutep6 HrecpecaM<br />

ero HaIAHOHEarnboi 6eaonacHocrH, gm0 rocynapcrao ao B3aMoAefcTBHH C l1poRypopoM, 3MMA MM<br />

rlanaTof npcAaapwremhoro npon3soCraa .,16o Cy, e6Hoff naJaTok, a 3naHCMOCTH or o6cro'reM,<br />

npmmHnaer ace pa3ynmne Mephi An pa3pCUCHHA AaHHoo BOr aOCa Ha Halanax coryAHH'ecrma. TaXHe Mepil<br />

MOryr aKJOqaTh a ce6a:<br />

alMoAH HKRKaIuO HAfm yroqll eIe 3anpoca;<br />

b) a,-eceHme Cy~om onpeAenenH. no noaojy OTmocamocm 3anpainmnaemok KH.4opmau. na<br />

Aoga3aTnbCa ji06o iO nO0 y O'TOM, MOrYTr BIR A0a3a1tftbCTBa, XOTS OH H O 1OCSTCE K AeIiy, 6bM<br />

nOJIy{eHbl H3 HCrO'4E11a, HHOrO qeM 3alIpaIfHBaMoe rocyapc"BO, HflH He flOHay'eHM Al OII H3 MaxOO<br />

HcTORqHna;<br />

c)nonyqeHHe HH5OpMaWfM HRH AoKa3BaebMCT H3 Apyror0 HCTO0HKa HRH a ApYTo 4)opMe; HR<br />

d),AOrOBOp CHHOCL o6 yCAOHBiRqX, Ha KOTOpiX MOXreT OMaaMBaTbCR DiOMOlib, MOIlUa, c<br />

npowero, npe.c raE..eHNe o6okaeHnof snH nepepa6ormio HHwbopMaUH, yCTaHO3ueHme orpaHa'velnI Ha<br />

pacKpbrrHe, HCnoaL3oBaaHe pa36BpalTemLcT in camera HnH ex parte nan ioe 3 anXrrEze MCpbl,<br />

AOnyC'nfQwe B COOTBeTCTBHH C HaCTOKAlM CTaryrOM H flpawJwamH nponeypu H AOK3aBaHNa.<br />

6. ECAH 6bL2H UpHnmM ace pa3ymaue mepM lau yperyampoBama Aanuoro Boupoca Ha HnaganX<br />

corTpyAHnnecraa H rocyjapcrao c'4raeT, WO He cyuxeC-ryeT Tair CoO6OB Hm Tax yc.oBaf, KOTOpme<br />

no3BOnqllH 6bL tnpeAcraBub Ham pacKpbrm HHclopMauiO HI AoymeH- m 6e3 yncepda Anz Hs'repecos cro<br />

Ha1IHOHaJbHOI 6e3onacnocTH, O14O yBcaaoxnr 0d TOM flpotypopa HAN Cyn c yKa3aHHeM KoHxpelLx<br />

OTHBOB CaoeM pLneHn, eCJH TOJhO TOtHOe OrIHcaHme TaKHX MoTmaoB camo no cede He noReer 3a<br />

co6o HaHecemm TaKoro ymep6a.<br />

7. 3aTeM, eCinH CyA onpeeawr, 'r1o AaHm € AoKa3aelTcT83a flAMOTC onlocRUIPODcS K AeAY H<br />

HCodXoAHMbiMH Aux yCrmHOuCHH. BlM H1H HeBHHOHOcn odaHHeMoo, Hm moryr 6Lm ipnhm


CHIAnIOMHx MCpW:<br />

<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

a) ccj pacphrme Hmwopmawm Him Aoxymema Hcfpammcwrcx a coOfTferHH c npocolk o<br />

cwrpymHqccTme cornacHo qacm 9 HM a c3MH C 06CTOrThCIl8ME, yTaaiMnMH any u re 2, n<br />

rocqapcmo npHaco npmam U onama3a cooem~erH C nyimioM 4 cram' 93:<br />

i CYA MOxeT, fptXAC qeM RMHeCTH KaiOe-AH60 3umo'(eim o KoTapo rOaopi1c a<br />

nojwyurte (a) (ii) lYNXr 7, HanpaH1M 3anpoC 0 1poeAeHH AabHe memx KOHCYJ TauH a<br />

lengx sacyuwaaaHu apryMe-roB rocyA8pCTma, 7O MoKer BaxMOM, B COOTaerCreylO=X<br />

Cay'u, cnymaNH in camera H ex parte;<br />

ii) ecJiH CyA upHXOxHT K 3aKmoqemHMI, qTO, CChmalCb Ha OCHoNHENs An OTK3a Ho nyuM 4<br />

cmmaT 93 B o6crorrenmc Aammom Acaa, uanpatlnaaemoe rocyjaapcrBo Atgl'fyeT sonpeKa<br />

o6maTcJcrm no CTB'y'Y, CyA Moxer nepeAnan AaHU soupoc a cooTsex-mmu c<br />

nym M 7 crama 87 C yu2aaeM ocnosaHA Au cBoero 3aRmO'(eHM; H<br />

iii) CyA MOXCT CAUM TaZOR BUSOA 3 XOae cyAc6Horo pa36HpM'rcjMc-a no Aeny oammeuoro no<br />

noeOJy Haaqmu Hm o ms Tom wn Hm oro 4mKa, toopMu MOxeT 6hrr onpauAwnm<br />

a AamHwx o6crorreawrax; m<br />

b) so B=eAcunx o6croze nw:<br />

i) x3mAb pacnopm¢eae 0 pacxpwlaH; u<br />

ii) nocxonKoy pacnopmxeHse 0 pacXpWTH He npnhum Cymo, "CeAan TaKOff Bah=A XOa ,<br />

CyJedHOro pa36HparenbCm no AeY o61mcuom no noaoy aanma Hua oTrrcTsml<br />

aIM HEoro 4qara KoTopLzf MoICT 6bm onpa~aammw a WOWmX oGComncra.<br />

TOT<br />

tHHd Onatm Sm nnOKWeCMuT ThflrMX CTOlmOm<br />

EcmI CyA o6pauxaeTCt K rocyppaperay-yacruaKy c npocboff npeAcm m Aoxymeu Tmum<br />

HH1padtMHo, MAorrcza o,X sc0 ae Hc , paCnopxenm N noj Cr KOITPOIM H XoropaR 6uMa<br />

paCKpMTa eMy Ha yc noaa.a KOH4a OjcCmana" c KaKHM-11m6o rocyAapc'OM, meiUpaButC eHolkI<br />

opram~au€efi H.IH mCxm yaapoAoA opnm3aae*, TO ro cyapc-yqacn-ri 3apy'crca coriacHem<br />

CTOp0HU, pacipLaMel AOKYMeHT KRa Hl4opMauno, sa pacmp rae raxoro AgOymera au aHlDopmuaa.<br />

Ecna TaKOfi cTopoHo0 aanuae rocyiapc=o-y'aCvra, TO 0HO a6o Aae cornaac Ha paCapuLle TB1OR<br />

HH4IOUMl W IM iAlyMe "a, at6o O623YCMrz papem-,rb c CyAaM aonpoc a pacp'mm A0KYM. C m a<br />

HM(4OpMatlZH c coa6moAeHaeM noOXCHmA cTa'nH 72. Ecnm a Ka'qecle T oi cropoae suclynac?<br />

racyApcrao, He nusuroeec y'MacM oM aac'roamnero CTZrayT, H ORO T1a3UMaaer Am Cor.ace He<br />

pacmpurme AoKymcHTa waI HEijIopMah , TO 3anpamiHnae, moCyApCMTo yIeC4OMMXCT CYA 0 TOM, 'T OO<br />

He B COc CDhMHH flpeCocraBBTb TaKoft AKyMer Ham m19opMautIIO aCvielcre paHee B30rmro Ha cefa<br />

o6Xaa~eff mCa a omroWeaia ca6 Jm sCHM KOH4IHACmuManHCTH nepeA 1-1o0 CT0POHO.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

Cram, 74<br />

Tpe6ogpamt K flDaHUO PaimISHHII<br />

I. Bce cy u Cye6HoA nafm Ir npHcyrcTAyTO Ha axAoft crAm cyJe6Horo pa6HpM CM X B xo9c<br />

BcCx cocmiaH H. Hpm3HJyM MOXeCT B oTrreahux cJI,2x Ha3UTh C Y'oU HMCI OmHXCI BO3MOXHOcMfi<br />

olHOro HiM 6on0e 3anaCHLIX cyneA, KOTOphie 6yyT IlpHCYTCToIn Ha Ka..of cT&AHH cy, e6Horo<br />

pa36HpalthCT H 3aMelaTh 'LHeHa CyA¢6Hoi nazaTu, CcWH SoT RnCH Ihnamz HC MOxeT 6onee<br />

npHcyTcToBa -h.<br />

2. PCmeHHe Cyo.dHOk nlaulaTmi npHHmmacC Ha OCHOBC OilemH elO AOXK3MTUJMhCM H Bce npo3BOf-rla<br />

no Atay. PCIHCHHe HC 1OJ O BLUXOAWM 3a pamKH 4barrob H O6CTOleflr.T, WHoxeHIM s Aoxyieirm,<br />

cooep=aeme O6BHHCML, HM B mOab6x rionpamal x ,oKym Cry, cocpxacm y odBH~m=. Cy, mo2KeT<br />

OCHOBblBaTh CBOC PCUICHHC TOJIbXO Ha AoKa3aTebCTBaX, npeAcraaJIeeH~x CII H PaCCMOTpCHIhIX HM B XOAC<br />

cy1e6Horo pa36Hpa'TeCJTwa•<br />

3. Cy,H crpersca woctH eAHouymHI B CBOeM pexIneHH, B oTVcYrMC KOTpOrO pCmCHHc<br />

pHHHMPvmP 6ojiW1mHcrmoM cyAe,€.<br />

4. COBeuRaEM CyAe6H01 nanaM CoxpaHWorCa s Tafte.<br />

5. Pemeime muiocm B s nHcbM HIHOM BHJI H COtpWiHT nOintOC H MOThimHpoPP-HOe NuHoimen[ BUBOOB<br />

Cyge6HoA nanaT'iP Ha OcIOC AOKa3aTCejnIM H 3aKmO'IeHmiT. Bueocxwoc pemeuefle sM cr ¢AMMCMaHHwi.<br />

flpH orcyrcTBHH CJIJUO'OAyiIH pcmHHe Cy.C6HOA ilaarb .ojCepwT ECHle 6OIyLmHCTsa H MeH.uHHcru.<br />

PemeHHe Him ero pe3oMe ornalaercs a oTKphrroM 3aBcCWH.<br />

Ciana 7 5<br />

BoiMeznewue vylepf nTelnepmxm<br />

1. CyZ yc'mrHauHBacT npmHwmw, KacaoiuHec BO3MeIIZCHxz yAup6a noTepnem I M B oflowCmH<br />

noTepneBuHX, Ba.,aoaa pc'rHTynm, KOM'elHC8U)o H pea6HAHmUran o. Ha w'or ocHonC CyA MOXe'T B 01<br />

Ha nocrynimimyio npocb6y Hiu s Hcs o , aH l cnyasx, no caoef co6cmfrewoft mH aTm e onpe¢x'mr<br />

B CBOeM pUIeu MacutPaM H pa3Mcp llO Oro yiuep6a, ylrmKOB H ,p8a, npHlHHCHHU X noTCprcsMKM<br />

HrIM B XX OTmoMeHi, H 3a.geT 0 UPH WUP , Ha OCHOBaHMN KOTOpMx OH AeCCTByr.<br />

2. CyA MOxCT BXECCYH nOcrHOuJCHHe HCUOCpeACI'CHHO nO oMOmeH=o K OCYXAeCHOMY 0 B03MeIxeHxH<br />

ymep6a noTepneBmM H BH OTHOmeHHH noTepnramax s HaJexamefiZfC (bopme, eqiroqag pCCrHTyIwo,<br />

KOMnICHCaIIHO H pe6HJnHTanIo.<br />

B CooTrfCT ytIoIWX cnyqatx Cya MoXCr BMCTm noCaHOanUPHH o uBwflraTe cyjou B nopapce<br />

BO3MCICHHI yM. p6a B ICuecBoA 4o11, uIpejI3CMOTpCHHUR 8 CraW 79.<br />

3. fIpee gCM BIIocmrB nocraioiaeme a cooarwmBC HH c HacromUefl cra'meg, CyA Moxem<br />

3aIpamHBaT H npHHEmacT aO BHHmalHc npeAc'rPaBHIU Or OCyXNCHHOro, OT nOTCpnCHXW , RlPIHX<br />

3aHHIpTcosamHHix iml Am 3aXII'pecOBaHHLLX roCY oCapcB AR OT X RM¢HeH.<br />

4. OcyIgtecBI CEoH nIOJiOMOmIm s coOrBCTCTs H c Hacrosm,"C cTra-el, Cyji. nocje n meCem<br />

pCenii 0 npH3HaKHi HHUa PHHOHMW 5 coeCpmCeeHHH npeCrYnePH, !loJ BJ1o a, ro no io pHcJI.HAMIo<br />

Cy.a, Moxer OnpeAeJ'b, cylUec'ryer .IH HCO~xoAMOcr B TOM, 'rW6o1 1 p enax KcnomCHH. mo6oro<br />

OOCrhIOBIICHHE, KOTOpoc OH MOXeT BI IHCCTH cornaCHO HaCTOIeft crame, 6anH IwpH n TLI Mepbi B<br />

cooTE'rcrTmBH c nyHKToM 1 cTBmbm 93.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

5. FOCYAPCrW-yqacTMIX aCZonM~eT paenam, BaHeCMeM Ha oC~omaHU Hacome9 aTaLH, KU CUJR<br />

6W no, G eo s CM'mn 109 6.M npmaenuD K AHo& A CM .<br />

6. HRm is Hwumeu CraT a He no Aluoo TozfouETa h u ya nMw umce npua noTepneamux a<br />

Co0ITCIH C HMUMOHUW RUN Me1]UH.poWHbM Ap=oM.<br />

Cycmg 76<br />

1. B cayqau, am aom o6maeoro ycmuHoJa, CyJed6H nua~tra pacompmmeT sonpoc o<br />

Ha3=lUH CO m,¢Yro uaXaalfMi H npmHIaCr ao RU!MaHe npC-MUanCIMwnO a ZOAe<br />

pa3s6pamum wKsatnem m cjamiwe pamcmTaumm, KoTophi HmaJOT OmomHma K HKHB'CHH~e<br />

2. 3a mmmem cnaeaz, a Kmopmx upacunemaw nonozem crms 65, CyHeuaz nanm fo<br />

usepmumH cyn6uom psupaTmcmr Moxc no acoel amemrru - a oAUa no npoce fipoxypopa<br />

HeN oxaiearO - NPOWCCT' JAnaom oe cypA6Hoa caymanme, c Tm 'o6, 2acaymBT .o6bi<br />

0WoHMT, A K1a3&TJhAS Hn npeJ SrleHR, HmalhIeC OThOIUCHH K¢ HaaaqaIo HBKB3aHlI, a<br />

€ C npTC.M PAMaHDH m UPOAMpM H AIo1 U.<br />

3. B c.nyqamz, s rmopm nplUmmserc nym 2, ,,Eoie npeAcraaemy, caEasume na caonam<br />

cTan.A 75, acynmamec g xoWe jnomm oro cayma , ynoumaymro B nymre 2, -Hn, opa<br />

HoodroAomocw, a mm modorao HoDow cwymmH.<br />

4. flpumroop ornamm ny6Ho H, Korpi mro so3moXmo, a rpHcy"mCm odmumemoro.<br />

qACrb 7. MEPJ HAKA3AHHjI<br />

CTarha 71<br />

rfl-wmane uenu HltUaxna~e<br />

1. C yqwou cmw 110 CyA moxer HawmT om y m cacAvnewmx aeap Haa3aaHs mm,<br />

npmumaMoy amoa s a coaapmmm apecrynneim, npoJqycOmeMoro a crarbe 5 Hactoanero Craryra:<br />

a) AmCma C•o6 Ha OU(p=XUe, UMHl, CpOz, i -MICu CiMUA,~ 3 Ko5 XOCT3C BCT, KO'MPOe HC<br />

UpeaMaa~ aMKeLmanuom xonnqCCU a 30 nor, mmN<br />

b) nozmimne Amner-ee cao6m s Tax cuynm, Kor3am oUp ww NcnmnOTcmO gim<br />

xaparrmpo. npecyzm- a ma, olcrosmencraaa mia, npmumamoro almoIm B em<br />

mopmin.<br />

2. Ilommuo imem caw6ow, CyA mOzcT Haanma :<br />

a) u-a4 a cooaem c KpH'epHmm, npepc oa 3 Ipaaummx UpO-eaPU H<br />

, uAta=~m;<br />

b)XonHbNcZKMUo AXOOBO, u3.UMeCa<br />

H Wn M, nonYRm~Ux npMo RIM KOaiCHHO a p eyp tM<br />

nyC UHH, 6e yap6a jA apan bona fide TIpYer CTOpOH.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

Cramsa 7 8<br />

Onnenln enumm eMt HarftIuu<br />

1. 1'pi OnpCAeCJ1CHHe Mepbi HaK32am Cy, B cooTSrcrmIS c UIpaanAlm npoM .noamAmMM<br />

Nu<br />

opuHu Me? 30 Bgo BX-O Tame 4bTOpw, Kar T2CTh Ipcerj=UbE H ZNimHOC OCy qzh m .<br />

2. flpH Ha3HaqeHmI HCaK38HII 5 ,un. nUmCmH Cao60AW CyA $scqmmaur cpaz npCezwpmm oro<br />

cozepxammh noA cTpaxcf no nocmuomueim Cya npu BUUwm Tutoro cpog. CyA uaxcT -mrm<br />

ino6oa cpoz, mmam o6pa.u othm-, noA crpaxcd. a can c ACmme m ,, zOeuERN s o os<br />

3. EciB .Nmo ocyKCo 3a cosepmmme 6oace Rem oAro npecl'flyux, CyA nmm S ucr M.Kaxm sa<br />

taADe npaecrynmme a o6mee HBaK 3NC e YcaU ,,,, BCero cpoa CmneaS C2O60X. 9M cpMo HO<br />

JOnzXH dI1'b MoNme CpOxa, npoycmoTpm OO CIMM CYpOSMM OTJISMAM HSiS38HMM, KOmpoo Gaao<br />

Ia3HamCN, H Ec AoJSCH fpemmrmb 30 JIST JIUeHICB C3O 3Wm via MepM HufLIaE a mm<br />

nom3ZHCmIOrO cHn cs o6ojpa coo1'rculm c notnymrom (b) nymm 1 cim'rr 77.<br />

Orai,,. 79<br />

I. Pommem Acca.,6,ca rocyzzapc'm-yw 'mxos yqpeArz Ucaoa 40W1 s mETOPWCX uorOamu<br />

oT npecrynem o, uo w ounxo noA p10Hwjino Cya, x cmeft TialZ nOrepOCMIuI.<br />

2. CyA MOaeT pacuopsnmes napeJo ne a e~e C cpeJta m1 zpyme muulCcmo, lmae noC)IcAuo<br />

mrpa~boa mm11 xoH4BIcKBwII a Ucaneuol 4owC.<br />

3. IJeneot 40oH, ynpasmeTCE B cooTruermOT C KPNmPRM., onpUesomma Acca.6aee* rcynapm-<br />

C'm. 80<br />

MCD HflSANUE N annR sM miI<br />

lfrrro a nacTommakC lacum He 3aTpazrmaeT tnpxmemml~ recy~kpc1Iamf map H18B<br />

yCTSMBO]f C6M HX HaLIHOHaBUIbIM 3RKOHOASrCTIBoM, ]XII SAXOROD<br />

tVCynBpC, KOTPMC He<br />

UPWcMaBpHaIOT MCpW HKa3aHuI yc"RaomaeUme 9 BhacrOMW acM.<br />

qACTh 8. OE38CAJIOBAHHE H IIEPECMOTP<br />

Crams 8 1<br />

OUzrnmm nema 0m o npnagnam. nemN a nmauu m.mul<br />

1. Pemieae, npmurroe cornaco crazm 74, uozar 6rm o6zaaowa ooTBOTCIBN o<br />

C IpaiiZam<br />

KpoXpItYP R ADOzaaiM, Ka[ M npjoCI MycMo Eule:<br />

a) inpoxypop moxer no ,am anemijuo no momuu H3 ceaKmpa ocowst:<br />

i) npo1nccyammm onm16a,<br />

, ... . ......... .... ... ;, --- m 3


ii) oUnI6Ka B 4IBKTe HH<br />

iii) onni6za B npase;<br />

<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

b) mmo, npN3HaHHoe BsoBHm , mHu f'poypop oT x4eln 1ro0 amla mOzCT noJ1Jm anemmum no<br />

nIoOWM 3 CJIe WU OCHOBaHAN:<br />

i) fipoueccyawaA oiUH6Ka,<br />

ii) 2Ox16Ka B 4arre,<br />

iii) omH5xa B IpaC mm<br />

iv) 2M600 KlHOO OCHOBMBtC, KOTOPOC UNICT R cnpaBBfAmmcm CYje6HorO pB36NXpBTC JcBa MM<br />

pecmeNHi A10o AOBCpHe K TBrXOMY p36 pBR .aWChy MAN PeCMeHO.<br />

2. a) lpmoBop MOxer 6bm o6xaoBBII B COOTBmNmNm c lpaBHmUm pormpm x AK omBfia<br />

flpoKypOpOM HAH 1/OM, IpN3HaHNIM BNMOMiM, Ha OCNOBRBH HeaCKaMOCTH BlheceHHoro npHroBopa<br />

COBepimeNoMy npeclyrnemuo;<br />

b)ecme pH paccMoTpeHNN upoBopa a nop €e o6m IoBa0 CyA co'rCT, Tro NIoTcB OCHOBBaHN,<br />

110 KOTopUM pTCele 0 OnpNHBNaH BHHOBNUNM MOXT 6OLT qaCTWOCO HIZH HOJIHOChO OTOCHHO, Cy,<br />

MOXeT 11PC.OXfr flpoXypopy H AIM, IIPN3HaHHONY BoBMN, np,:rBzrw OCHOB2HH COrIlaCHO<br />

nyHKTy l(a)<br />

CTbTef 83;<br />

ln. (b) CTaThm 81 H MOxCT Bbrlemf pemeNe o npN3NBNNN BNoBmmm B COOCTCTBH Co<br />

c)Taas Xe npoxelypa UpHMcNeTvCB B cMyae, orJI npH paccOTpCM B nopB € o6XBIOBaH<br />

TORSO pCIUlHH 0 npI93NBNN BNMOBK61M CyA coTrc, WOr NMelorc oCaoBam JI AI C3UMCHU npMBOpa<br />

corAiaco nymKTy 2 (a).<br />

3. a) IoOeomxy Cye6Hasa naTa He paCopBmI'C. o6 Hmo, Ao paCCMOTpemIC anenIMII mio,<br />

IpN2NBaHOe BHNOBNIM,, HaXOANTCZ nOA CrpaxeH;<br />

b)=H NCPNOA BPCeCHN, B TCR'CHe KOrOMOrO 21100, UpN3UMBeoc BBOBNlwM, HaXOJI TCn 1O<br />

crpaxef, npeamyar cpox HaIae.,moro eMy Ha&3aHm B BweC JOImMelu c3o6ou, OH IIOAJlCxT<br />

OCB06OXACH,O 3a HCKJIo'icHmem CJIy'IBB, Kom~. flpoKypopomi Taxe no0ACTCB BO~aBIIna , B CBJ13H c '1Cm<br />

ocBo6oxJcNme MOXT 6uin OCyUiTCTBcuHO TOreO c co6moeNme ycnoBI, npeWcmorpcmNT' B<br />

nojumYuTe (C) Hmxe;<br />

c) B cJaie BbiHeC.NNI p~eame 06 onpaBmmN o6mmemuR noAffCxRT HeMCJIIICHOMY OCBo6OXACNNlO<br />

c co6imo1 eemeM HixecnemylOlIero:<br />

i) B Hcmo MHNwaT X o6CrTrBCJ CTraX, C y'eeVM, B Racmocm, KomprNoA onamocr no6era,<br />

cCpbc3HocTH npehm,,L HNomIo o6Bx~eNHN H Bepormocm ycnem~orm Ncxoa anelmm J,<br />

Cyc6Hau naam, no ipocb6e flpoXypopa, MOxeT lepoonfeM coAepxaH1e o68MCMOro 11o<br />

crpaxek An paCcarPCoHN anCflnHN;<br />

ii) pcmeme CyJe6Hog naiiai, BLMCCMMoe NB OCHOBaNN noxynle (c) (i), MOXCT 6bm<br />

o6 oBxIoBo B CooT N c flpa namH IPllCUP AoK 3uBnaHm.<br />

4. C co6mohcaeem noJIHmKoB 3 (a) N (b) NcaoiHeme pmlHeNNI npuloaopa MOxCr 6r m<br />

pOCBOBJIeHT He nBPHo BPgeoN, [POM.y TPcHMA ARM UOAM aN Bf N POB=CHJI<br />

pa36NprbmenIa B niopaje o6zanoma f


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>,1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

Cm21a 82<br />

O6xxnnRaaMq npO4HjX emema<br />

1. H3 x cropoH s comercm c flpazmmaam npoteeypm H AoKxa.mmmu mozer o6uoBam<br />

mo6oe H cJe~poux pmeHHA:<br />

a)pememe a omomcmiH iopmCJWK mm AonycrmiocrM;<br />

b)pemeime, pa3peualolwee m 3anpcua,-uece ocBo6oxJ,,em m, KoTopoe Haxomfrcs noA<br />

cJie¢ BHCM Hm 9 omomeHmH KOroPOMo BeOAe'r cye6Hoe pa. 6HpeJevncmO;<br />

c)pemeeme Ilanaam npe,aapmw,,maoro npomaao cra Aefcroamr no cumA cocme~eMof mmnuZmsC<br />

coroAc&a nymMy 3 craTms 56;<br />

d)pemCm, KacmomeecsR onp0ca, K plkB H8awTm, HO* MCpe BOxu 6bii Me aCpaefle H<br />

6mCTpoe BOCeHe cyAedHOrO pa36Mpac~hMtBB HAH Ha e C3ybT8T MER B CEIH C KO2pbM<br />

Hcu3aHTCJmeTMoe upHarme AneJmfuowmoA naaoh pCmeMB moXe, no mHcmH uma'ma<br />

npaapmT mHoro npoM3BoJcTm HAM CyAC6HoA nanamI, cnoco6cmam qyeCY mmTh OMy npoAnszemuo a<br />

pa30parmcm~e nea.<br />

2. PemHMe laoamz npeaapmmHoro npoHamocmsa, HadM~CMoe<br />

M octoaam uyHmIa 3)(d)<br />

cTrHz 57, mOXeT 6'hr o6xaOoBao 3amHrmpecoamum rocyApc"om RAH r1poKypopoM, c pa3pemim<br />

rlawami neJ6Bapmleuemoro npomaaoAc'ru. Tamu anea m noaaemaT pacxom a feOT-arnemmOM<br />

nopsa K.<br />

3. O6zuoaHHe cauo no Ce6e He BICqET npHocraozmm pa36Hputerea, ecirm Anwammomag<br />

nnaaEra He BumC'Tm nOCTaHOaueHHI o6 rOMa no wpOCh6c B COOTBTSM-m C Ilpauxamm nponeypM H<br />

,oKa3lammE<br />

4. 3axomn, npecramrre nomepneaanu, ocyxzeimaw mm bona fide co6craemnm, nocrpagamn B<br />

pe3y--TBmT peiwum , upHm roO cornamo ffm 75, Mo~eT o6x ao s penieHme 0 BO3MeIUH ymoepa,<br />

aK mo nper ycmoTpeo B rIpaBMHax npoUepu H Aomi mB.<br />

Crmm 83<br />

1. , iezet t npoM3aoccTa a coatemm o<br />

co crKhef 81 m Hac-ro~aMt cMIMAT AnteOMOHHB mara<br />

odnaaeT nCew noOmoMoq-.m Cyedoofi naoaru.<br />

2. Em AnenmXJUoMBns m np XOJfr O K 3aUKmoqeMlO, T'M o6xa.yeuoO CYJo~aHO pas6HpMM<br />

dbMo HCepauCAmum '81Mm odpa3om, T0 ITO CrMM 100 COMHCHIe ,OMpHC K pemi IOM<br />

npioBopy, mm 'cro npma BeceH H o6xanyemoro pemem m M pumBopa 6hm AonyeYH CYIeUcmCeuOMM<br />

omOKH 4 l'e M m npaA m npoileccyanmna HapymcHMc, oHa MOXeT:<br />

a)aomeiT MM H3MemIr pen Hl M m I pHO pmroBop; m<br />

b) pacuopsAMr1Cs o flpo¢CmH HoBoro cyOe,6Horo pB.dHpKTmxhu CT pyraoR CYJCe6HOk Ga.RCol.<br />

,An mm nueo AnexuO. omxU na0m MOxeT BcpHyM B0opoc, C393MH* c 61mqtcc=o0 CToPOROl<br />

Aena, a nepaoama Cy~e6Hyio nanay a aeosx ero srucHeHm H nomeslwcro upe.,Thm<br />

AoeonnOHHAa naaTt COTa1CTC"ByloInerO 3RKalOqCHMI, MO Xe OHa M01C1 CBM8 3WC6BTh


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

JLOKaale3aTeThca N BMLCHeHHA BOnpOCa. Eca pemeHe Hint apHrosop O5XayeTCS loMo ocyzemwd<br />

KuM IIpOKypOpOM OT HMCHH TaKOro HmHUa, TO Taloe pemeeme HIM npmmosop He MOXeT 6hm H3MeHCH C<br />

yzgep6om Au, qroro nmxa.<br />

3. ECx upH O6xajiOBaHzH apHroopa AieJIIIIIoHNqE najaTa IpNxoJirr K 3arjaOqeHO, T'ra<br />

auNccCmHLA npmronop HeanesaTex coaepmuxelomy npecrynnemno, oea MOeT HMCHNmb npmronop B<br />

COOIBCfTfHH C 'IacTiO 7.<br />

4. Paenme Anea.A oIHHofi nanam, npnHxaefcS 6oJ mNNcI2OM roilocoB cyelk H ornamarcC a<br />

OTMpUTOM 3aCe= . B pCeIeHHH yKa3uaal'ca OCHOaamea eria Bsaece m. B cny'ae orcyrCMh<br />

emornaces B pamelme Anea1uuoaoA naTa w xnaraOe MHeHHI 6OAmiUMcra H M NHbMKHcTha, OiaKO<br />

razjk cynAbs MoxcT abcryaiem C oco6um HH HeCornacu MHemem no Borpocy npa~aa.<br />

5. AnejuLuioHHau na.ala moxeT ornamam cwoH pemeHaf a oTCyTcraae intHla, Koopo¢ 6uaO onpalraHo<br />

Ki ampOe 65bJio npH3HaHo sHNOmBIH.<br />

CTZnh 84<br />

TlepecMuew o e r.wlelm lnRHH nn roor p.J] flaa]le no n1urnaaV<br />

1. Il0e npN3HHHO¢ BHHOBHbimM, Hin, nocae era HKIH ete cep', cynpyra RH Cynpyr, P npoJmreH HA<br />

KaKO-TO OAHO JI=O, NHBYlee 5 MOMCHT CMCPTH O6aNNueMoro, KOTOpOmy O 6BxNxHeMM dwaH A HU qelKue<br />

nHChMeel yKaaH B a OTHOMICHNH no~a T aKoro HlcKa, Nil fpoKypop or N¢eCH TaKoro np3HaHHoro<br />

womiOum jmLa MOryT xoIaTaNtBOBaTb nepe¢ Ane oxeaeoHaok nanarofl o nepecMOTpe oao'aTeMnoro<br />

pemealN o BHCCCmm o6BHerem.Horo nparosopa Nne HaKa3aNNZ no upHroaopy no cne J yoeau<br />

OCHOBaHRI M:<br />

a)o Hapyximab3 HOBIe RoKa3oT.CTDB, KOTO)pm<br />

i) orcyrcrBoaaarn so BpCMI CyAe6HorO pa36HpaTemc'ma, H amerc=eaocrb 3a aKoe HX<br />

OTCYTC Ce He MOXCT 6UM IO.lNOCThIO HAH eacqw O 03JIOKCHa Ha COp0ay, o6paTHamyeocn C<br />

xoAaTaAcrOM; H<br />

ii) AUo'cI jocTaro'eo IazHumm, TaK ero ec 6m oN 6u= npHme ll a xoAe cyAe6HOrO<br />

pa36HpaTem-.cnha, TO Hro, BO3mOiKHo, npHBeO 6bi x BNHeCeHmO EHoro sCpJrra;<br />

b)O6Hapyxalc<br />

-<br />

HOwlle darr, calcriypxHe o Tom, ra peMalIgee AOK&3aTelCrIo, KOTopoe<br />

6iao npMMTO 30 BHHMaHHC B KO Ae cyeHOro pa36HpaTefhcm H OT KoT0pOor 3aBNCHT a6BHHNrewnwA<br />

rperoaop, 6uno nozHum, c4I6NmxonI Emm 4IaacxibatpoaamlM;<br />

c)oA cyWa NIu HeKomKo cyIAc, yucisoBunix a emNeem odwNNrreOoro npHrosopa Him a<br />

yrep3Kz ,ea o6aBjeHxA, npa paccmopeHm AaHoro jea coapmm cepbem3hl* apocrynox Hn ceple.2Ho<br />

HapymcmNe cBoHx o6B3aHNocrCH, nOCrTTO4HO T =Ke, An Tom 'fro6, caym oclosaaem Aos -<br />

orpemeesm wroro cyara CbH Ni n cygnu C or naeocm coriiaco craT 46.<br />

2. Ann=oHaa nanaTa oaraoAer xoramAcro, =H careT ero aHeooceoamim. E=H oHa<br />

onpenefl"eT, 'ra XOaTafiCnO no cyecry eurT O6OcHoBaHHNNM,<br />

mO oHa MOxeT a cJy'eae<br />

HCO6XOAKHOCT:<br />

a)aHoab co6pam' nepsoHaq BHyM Cy gc6Hyo naMay;<br />

b)3HOBO .C4OpMpOaTh Cyne6YKyo na.laTy; mnH<br />

c)cOxpaHNM 3a coO0i IOPHCiNKEIU 8 O mHOCHHII a Oaloro lBOPOCa,


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

c Tem ,rrod, 3acyma cropomH TINm o6pasom, Zx vro yrmO3 9 flpaaax npoixctwpu n<br />

,Aoxa.bamIHU, npmHHrr PCMlCH¢ 0 TOM, nojAUXJfr nH pcweie nepecMorpy.<br />

Crmg~ 85<br />

KourneRtaxmg4 HDCt0HHHOMV NMIi IIV. a=Dornri nDh1(IHHIiV<br />

1. Kaz A, xTio cMraj xcprsoA He3HKOHHOrO<br />

M,cH Hpera conepzaHz non crpaxelH, HHeC npeBo Ha<br />

K.omnHcaim, o6na.ammyo HcXooR cHotlo.<br />

2. Ecni Kaoe-Jm6o JHImo oKoHqaremihm pemesmeM 6uzo np3Hao allIognHm 3a yroomoc<br />

npccry €mU H eCnJH B1HC2eHHi, emy npmoHp 6b1 -,nocnec1 nTHH OTMeHeH Ha TOM OCHOHamI, , O<br />

Kaxoe-M6O HOHOC M , H HOB l oTKpL, IIICCCz O6CTOrrenbcrBO HeOCflOplMO DoKH3aLIaeT Hawet CYnCdHOfl<br />

01H&KH, TO 4=0, IOHCCIeC HaKa3HHC B pe3ybThTH' THKOrO r1pH3HHHHH BKHOSHbIM, noniq [T 3aHOWIM'O<br />

KOMiICHCHIHo., C He 6yjieT AOKa3HHO, 4'To YK&3HHHOe HCHT3C-nMOe o6CTOffrehcto He 6wzo B cooe spei<br />

o6HHpyxeHo HCK..O'UrrJMhHO Ham oTqacTm no ero BHHe.<br />

3. B HcxmoqHmzLbHLx o6crox arn x, Kor~a CY9 o6fapyKHmaH HeocUopHmLe #ri11m,<br />

cRB.R"nbmcTyzoMHe o HwH rpy6o* H amof0 cyAeZ6Hof omH6KH, oH moxCT no csoemy ycmo'pemuo<br />

nPHCYI'r% KOMIICHCaH10O B COOTBeTC=HH C KpHTCpHRCMH, npecMopeHHmn a IIpNmax npotte.,C4"pm H<br />

A0KH,ImsHI, MlHIIY, KOTOpOC d1J2O OCaO)OxneHO H3-OA CrTa811 ocne OKOH'I1TCJWHOO PC e1iHu 06<br />

onpHaHJImmH H1Ha n pcKpawtCLa npoH3HocH no mO tlp imHc.<br />

qACTm 9. MEXWYHAPOHOE COTPYHH'8EC BO H CYESHAA fOMOmb<br />

Can 8 6<br />

061nee o61 aTUeln.CTwMi cMMvnH qar<br />

rocy9,apcTr-yacnHKH H co evrUcHi c no11oxcHmII Hacrosw¢ro CTaryTr scecToOHHe<br />

COy'miftfavH r c Cy9oM B npowAeeHm Hm paccfleaaEmE npwcl7meBlR, noarajommx noA IopHCC4UIIWI<br />

CY~A, H ocVIIZCCTIIH1I yozoBom NpCCAJOHHH 3H SM IpecCI7nCHH.<br />

Orawnm 87<br />

"lnoCbd o cm'vM fmleCTre: o6nme InoJIoveHmm<br />

1. a) CyAi o4er npao o6pautaTcs K rocy9ApcgaH-yttacTHMKam c rrpocb6am 0 colpy~mecrge. Tame<br />

rpio¢C61 HHtipamlTCH no mUOIn1omEIraccKM KaHuam mm no mo6him IlyrM cooTBvrcTsyioIHM KaHHfm,<br />

KoTopMe Moryr 6nm onpCeAUCHM KaZW IW rocytapcrsom-yHcnumoM npH paTH4C1lHK8WM, npHHIrH,<br />

TIBCPZJI1eM H4 nPRCOCAHHeifll.<br />

IlocCue.ywnme x3McHCHH T&Kro onpejienei CO CTOPOHM KOao rocyZApcTB-yqactmIHa<br />

npoHxsO9Cx a COOT¢'I"CTH c flpaumeamH[ waO mbipOYPl m AoKoa3bEaiHH.<br />

b) Kora mW ic11ecoodpa3HO, 63 ya ep6a Us nooxcZC nonyHm (a), poc-,61 M moryr ra0 me<br />

HMII9H1H , 'epe3 MexzyaponAIyl oprimfaWwo yronoEHmo nomjOHH Hum mo6 y lo coomCaTCTymmOyIm<br />

permoRM.UM1 opnuuuo-<br />

2. npoch6m o corpylmmecrae H mo6he ,oyMemu, nojixpenramnme gTm npoc,6,., 116o<br />

1Ipe C9 Ha OI-IOM K13 oM04)IHbIHX 93UKOI 3HripaOI]IHHMoro IocyJ 1A °Im Ham OJoIM H3 pa6omu<br />

s3biKoB CY9a, no sm6opy, 06",fl€emOMy ocyjapcmoM npM pmcbmrHaiHm, zpHimm, ytmCpr,,Ho am


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

IpHcoCeJIHeHHn, Jiu6o conposor,.awmr. flepezO)WM Ha OH 113 TWZXJ M3b111O.<br />

flociyeiomae m HCHI Taoro Bu6opa npow3oAwTCm s cooTmmrrmu c npaalmHaH npolxemypU H<br />

AOKa3 BaHUM •<br />

3. 3anpamuBaemoe rocyapcTBo coxpalieT a Talie npocb.y o coT'pyJWmcCrh H o6,e no, penmonwe<br />

MY npocby AOXyMCML, 3a HCXo'eIHHCM Cny'aga, xo1017 - H B npozeax, 9 KOTOphlX - HX PaCKpmlmc<br />

HeOdXOAmmO Au HcoJimem npocbh&1.<br />

4. B CB23H C .io6oi0 npocb6oA o oololmn, nlpeAlCnleloft B COOTICTMIU C Hac1O1fle* qacTmO, CYA<br />

MOXeT llpHHHMalda Tallne MepU, b .JIIOI.Na Mepm, C03am0 C 3auwmlTog HHlOpMawm, ioTrop1e mor1 r<br />

noTpe6oBaTbcs Azz o6ecnenleHmi 6e3oracnoC"l H m 4n3H'Iecoro nn ncmlmecKow ftarononyu9 fo6x<br />

rOTepflCBlInlX, IIOrCHUJHaJIhHLIX CaxlcTmeJe H Hx ceA. CyA Moxcr o6paTHlmus C apocb6l 0 ToM, eTo61<br />

o6as mHH4opmaao, KoTOpas npefocmneT a cooI Hm c Hac'OEweR 'qacrmio, npcpca~macb H<br />

HcnonL3OBaacb TaKHI o6pa3OM, qTO6i nlpH m7m o6=em e'bwaanc, 6emonacitocr H (HmccZ0C HiH<br />

ncH wemccoe 6aaeonoz'Me juo6ux noTepnc af , noTtHuEamim cBmadumi H Hx ceMC9.<br />

5. a) CyA aoxer ope JuOAmT nO6oMy rocyAapcuy., He sam oemycs yacBrHoKOM Hacmogmeo Ciray&,<br />

OKa3aTh flOMOM B COOTBCTCBHH C HacT oMe¢k 'faC %0t Ha OClIOUC cneW a Ho. Ot orosopHaHocm, cornamCHal<br />

c Taxx mcyapcTaoM HaH Ha mo6o jwyrofl CooTneTCTymmea OCHoie.<br />

b) B TCX Cfl'asx, Korla rocyAapcTBo, HC mJumOlgee1CC yUac1HHom HacmzomIero CTaTra, xoTopoe<br />

3aXIO'lMH cnelDCinaJlhHyO AoroBopeHHOcTh Him cornamem e C Cynoam, iora3x c U c€OpywRfm a<br />

BbiiOJIHCHam npOCbA B C0ooT crml c ,io6o8 TaK Ok Aoroaopamocrbo mm cor'namemiw, CyA molxr<br />

H)opeporm o6 3rom Acca6ne o rOCyapCTB-yRmCnIHKOB H~a, 8 TeX CnyRaM, Korna AaHeNTi BOUPOC<br />

nepejaH Cyy COBCTOM Be3onacjocm, - Coafer Baonac~ocm.<br />

6. Cyn Moxer HpocHfm mo6ym Meaxpantm ' mC m opm=3amo n Ao mp HHO~pmN o HflH<br />

AOKyNCHTL. CyI MOze7 Taixe IpocHm' o6 oxa3mm CoTpyJHzq1CTBa H nOmOOIH a Apyrlhx (lbopmaI,<br />

KOrOphi¢ MoryT 6trm cornacoaaHml c TaxOi opramm~aI €e H KOTOpmC oTrtalo e cooThTCymum.d<br />

IOnHOOMOHSM uRH MBHWU .<br />

7. B TeX CJr4UX, Kora rocyapCeo-yqUaCIH Hc BwnomiIT upocb6y Cya o compymwece Boopea<br />

fOJIoXeHNSM HaCTo02¢rO CTW a, Tem c8amNm He non31oU CyAy awnfl0UmoHTh cro 4)YHKWIH H nOJZHOoMo'I<br />

cornIaCiO HaCToallleMy CTalyiy, CyA Mozer BbEHCCTB 3aBK IIOnmne no mTy ao0BOW H nepe arb Opoc<br />

Accam6nee o apcm-yqacnnrxoa HaN, a TCx carran, Kora AaBHNL sonpoc nepeaH Cyxy Coamm<br />

Seaonacuocm, - CoBTy Beonacocm.<br />

CTMg~ 88<br />

Hgfawme niTM&WIvD, OD gldYCCHma H onLuLIM flOaM<br />

rOCYalcTra-yac1{HX o6ecne'waw HafNH npoLuyp, nlpCycJIY CeHaH x I Hn.Is<br />

apaBoM, Anx sCeX 41opM CoTpym'ecma, yKa3amx B HaCrO A, elq 'IeTH.<br />

Crana 89<br />

1. CyA moxeT npenpoMojm npocb6y o B9cre H nepeae JHW WeCT C nfoJPlnOINH ay<br />

npoch6y Manpmam, yKiaamum e cramTe 91, modomy rocyApapCy, a rCppmopm KOT KOW mOClT<br />

HaXOMlWhC MT h o, uH odpaaMc=CE K ToMy rOCyDApI C POCb6 0 WTpyiMMWMCTUC B npOUSoMcTrC<br />

apecra H ncpeane TaKoro nHna. roCyA)pcraa-Y'laCTHHiH B COOTB1TCJIvMK C UcnOCOeflmH Hacrom=laC t CTH


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

H lpOlXeypOR, npeJyCMHOTpeH-OIR HX HaIHOHBUMMHMM 3aKOHOAITtJMCMM, BJUoHmT nlpocd1 0<br />

UPOH3BOACT"B apecTa H nlelBC.tq¢.<br />

2. B Tex cnyqasx, Kor .a iHLo, pa3hlCKHBaCMOC AARa nepejaqm, o6pauaecs c npoTemCIrM a<br />

HaUHOHBajaHblk CyA Ha ocHOBe npmw.itna ne bis in idem, KaK SMTO ripCyCM0WCHO B CraT e 20,<br />

3anpamHuaCMoe rOcynapcTMo He3aMeIflHTeJlhHO KOHCYJIbTHpyTCN c CyRom zrn onpeAjCeHen Toro, cymecr1yeT<br />

JMB Co'rCyIORCC nOCTOBJIeHHe 0 npHeMReMOCTH. EcaH Jl0 o flpHSHaHo npHCMJICMm, TO<br />

3anpamHnaCMoC rocynapcTO npHcTynacT x HCnOJIHCHHO rpOcb6bl. ECITH nOCTaHOBSCHHC o npHeMaeMocTH atue<br />

He IIpHHO, TO 3anpaMHBaeMOe IOCYAAPCTBO MOXCr OTJIOXHrh HCnOJIHCHHO fpOCb6E1 0 fcpWlaqe<br />

cooTBercrryonero nsna JAo npmHzrHa Cy~oM pewemu o npHeMneMocTH.<br />

3. a) rocyapcTBo-y1acTHHK B COOTBCTCBIHH CO CBOHM nPOUCeCCYaL fHUd 3&KOHOMATCCrM ,ACT"<br />

paapelUCHHe Ha nepeB03Ky Repe,3 CBoO TeppHTpMHIO JHlt8I, nlepegajaeMoro Cyjzy WyfI'tm rocyJapcrBOM, 3a<br />

HCKmOqeHHCM Cny'laea, KO!"i, flepCBO3Ka q1cP3 sT' rocyjapcmo Moras8 6,i socnpenA'rCrBaTb nepejae . x6<br />

nPHBeVTM K ee 3aJ)CpXKe.<br />

b) lIpoci.6a Cyjia o rparwire HanpaJIecvrci a. cooaTerOTcTB co craTrTh 87. B npocb6 o TpBHM'e<br />

cojlepxa'rez:<br />

) ornicae nepeno3Hmoro rlnia;<br />

ii) KparKoe H3noxeH€ o6croreJmCri Acfa H HIx ripazBOu KnHtIaiXe ; H<br />

21) OPiCP Ha apCCT H nepCJaI'y.<br />

c) UpH nepeBoe TpaH3rmoM nCpC3o3HMOC JI O coep3rCB no cnpaxei.<br />

d) HnKaXoro papCIeHm He Tpe6yercX, Korea flepewouSa ocyuec'm.IerCE Bo3AuMiUUIzM TpaHcnOpTOM H<br />

He ape iOnaraeTz nf pH3emneHm Ha TeppHTOpHH [ocyapcaTB TpaH3ira.<br />

e) EC€H Ha TeppHrOpH rocyjapcraa TpaH3Hra UPOHCXONT He3anaIHPOBaMoe npHSM-cHe, ra<br />

rocyjiapcTao MOzCT o6paTHrbca K Cyjy c TpC6oBaICuM o TOM, 1TO6h1 CMY B COOlBC!TBHH c noJioxcuXeC<br />

no,=jymra (b) 6fna aHafPSfcHa npoch6a o Tpa3Te. rocyjapcro TpawH3S 3aepmmaeT nepeso3Hmoe<br />

nHIZO AO 1f"CHHN IlpOCIbM6b 0 TpB3HT H BO306HOBMeM TPBMH3H, HO nlpH BTOM 3a4iepXaSHe AMR HeCHe<br />

HaCToslero noAUyHrra He MOIeT npoJiOJzt 6oee 96 qacos c MoMeHTs Hc3ffrIaHMPB8oHHoro<br />

npH3eMIcHI.,E, CCeH B TeeHHe moo BpeMCHH He noJy)eHo T8a10i4 npoc06M.<br />

4. ECIH pa3acKHBaeMoc iHIIo zBjmvC O6,,cKTOM cyne6Hom flpecflejolaHmxI BB OT6wsaaT Haxa3aBHe B<br />

3anpaM 2BaCMOM rIcynapcrBe 3a rtpeCTynJICeHC, HHOe, ReM TO, B Cs23H C KaooPUIM 03y]XKCHO XO,,aTkACTBO<br />

o nepcaJe CyIy, 3anpaum aeMoC rocyJ.apcrBo nocde BaueceHms caoo pemeHH o6 y~oBeMopemH<br />

npoci6U KONCynMpyercs c CyAOM.<br />

CorM 90<br />

K]IrnigmnnmHCe naMOCwu<br />

1. rocyiapcrBo-yacTHBK, nojwqionte cC or Cya npoc6y o nopeane juma a coo'ercrBHH co craThefi<br />

89, B CfyMae, CCnH 0eo noJgy'aCr TaKxce npocy OT Kaxoro-JmIo gpyroro rocyjapcraa o BMtae TrOTo<br />

-ze lHa 3a TO e camoe noeneHHe, o6paomUee ocHoBy npeCTYfWCHHI, 3a KoTowpOe Cyn XOTamkcrYCT 0<br />

ncpe.am'ie roro zmHa, YB.W MECT CyA H 3anpaumoaloliee rocyjIpcBo o 6 mJrM 4arTe.<br />

2. B Tex cnyqazx, KO1i7a 3anpaoneaaloUle. rocyjapcMro SV€CrI rOCYAapC rOM-Y 'acHHXOM,<br />

3anpaumBuCMoc ncyiapCIBo oTAacT npe~inof'eHmle npocb6e Cyjoa:


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

a)cc m Cy a COOmemmDHH CO cTSThr5H 18 aum 19 sIHCC olpPeIJICm o TOM, 0 AroJeo, B CW93x<br />

c KOIOpMM OH xOATBaICmyer o nepe~aqe sIum., nnzUSV npicMfeMMU K npoR30oAcrBy, R B STOM<br />

onpe"teuH ywnfmlCTCs paccZcJoBaHH@ man cyBI6moe npecen1o1ame, pose0eHHoe 3anpamHlonum<br />

rocyapcTBoM 9 cas3H c cro npoco f o ahtiaqe; um<br />

b) eca CyA BmocH onpeAe cHRe, o KOTopoM roBopm B D fOjnyHKe (a), nHa OCOIanMM<br />

yBeJOMIHCR 3anpamRRBamorI' oCYABCCarZ B COOT'IrCTBNH C DHmITOM 1.<br />

3. B Tom cnyue, mm onpenmer 9 cooerTvmuiB c nojnynmrOM (a) nyHKar 2 He duiJIO BaueCelO,<br />

3gnpSm1BaCMOC rOCY UpCTBO MOXCT 11o CBOeMY yCMOTPCIUO A0 E9HCCeH CyAOM onpcleuxm Ha<br />

ocHosamml lto, yHKTa (b) nyHrr 2 npHCTuR K pacCMorpeHMO fpoCb6] 0 B =Re OT 3anpamxmmcro<br />

rmcy1apcTm, HO He LAUj jneO ,AO B]HweC Cy~om Onpe1eieinema o neenpiteMemocm 11ea. OnpeAeem<br />

Cyla aHocvrcz B ycKopeHHoM nopWKe.<br />

4. EcneH 3BlPAMHmaoxeC rocy1apcrmo He BnAerc mCyEAopcroM - yu'IcHmoM HwmoUmIro CTM'rar, -m<br />

3SUPaMEUCMoC roCYapCTBO, B TOM C.Y'EBC, CIN OHO He CBB3aHO M1 WNH8pOAHMM 06F32TenCTSOM 110<br />

BLUar e Jazz 3aUPamHBB oOY rCqAapcrBy, OTAaeT ftp1 noTeHMC npocm6e o nepemlC e, nocrynue¢I oT<br />

Cya, CCAH CyJ npa3Han m0 Ao pipHCM.eMaZM.<br />

5. EcRU no AMfly B COOTBCZCTSHX C ayfTioM 4 Cy om He 6wzo Rm eceno onpezaeHm o<br />

TlpHeMCMOClH, 3anpamRBaeMoe rocyAapcTBo MoXIT no cBoeMy yCMOpHim0 npu-RyT K paccMo'rpcHo<br />

npocb8m o sMmItae, nocriymmmet or 3aripalRBalonuero rocylApcTma.<br />

6. B 1x1 Cfy'a, Kora npBmeHse1cB nyNrr 4, 3a HCKUReHM CJy ae-, KorIa 3anpamm emoc<br />

rocyApCTo YXe CBBS3HO MIXX POJU 0623mbtcr0m no Ja'e aim 3pammm Ymomy ocApcTy,<br />

He gsflw0IeMyc ygacHmRxoM Hacrommero C'a1ry, 3anpannumaeMoe rocylapcTo pemaer Bonpoc o nepeame<br />

9o0 MR18 CyY 1My WBUO Wqe 11oro arpeA1011oemy l<br />

rcy1apcrmy. IIpHrHMaB caoC pememe,<br />

3anpamuReMoc rocyfapcmo paCcMapmItaeT BCe coomerc yeom e iauropa, 9 TOM wCJIc, HO He<br />

a) coamimywwc jAam gSnpB8ZCHRU rpocb5;<br />

b) HH1ipC.hI 3aflpaHB mloneO ro1y0AC1apc , BKtEqBS, KorAa 3 yMwClHO, TO o6mC1oixCTz ro, 6mAo<br />

iR npeCryr1zeH coepmeHo Ha em TCppHTopBHe, & TKe rpSIJ~aRCrO nOTtpneBMU H C8lorO 1M41a,<br />

KOTOPOe OHO IPOCIT aAam; H<br />

c) Bo3MOxBOCrh nocfle)omeA nepOAaU MeXN Cy0oM H 3pBaMIHBMB=xo rocyIapcroM.<br />

7. B TOM CZY"*, e1 roy~apcmo-yacmK, nDojIYmee or Cya upocb6y o nepaAant ma,<br />

11Jyioxi T TaKZC ripoab6y Or KaKr0-nmW6 rocyIAapcTsa 0 BM11B'I srOTO ze 9111 3a 14110 noBO11iUI, qeC<br />

nO~eBIHHe, npeAC B OItee co6ol cocMa pcynneHM, 3a XOTOPOC CyA Ao6HBacrMX nepeAgR 910O0<br />

a)3aI=paBmoe rocyJ1apCT1O, CCJI OH0 He CR1310 MC aPOWUdM 06 3.b3¢ ,BOM no Uaua'le<br />

mxa anpammiiomeIy rcyJapcrBy, a7m npe0novTme npocb& Cyza;<br />

b) upgnmRacMoe mcylapcmTo, CuJt oo yxc cmIa.Bo McJxlyHapoAHuml o638arenCTBoM no i abqe<br />

Mmls 38npaMKDlely mCYiApcMy, pemavr BlOpOc 0 n¢cJIe sm0O fro CYly wn BwMae mm0o0 Dma<br />

3anpUPmHBaioeI U y y y. UPHHIIMBB cR0e peimeme, 3anpa cMmIoc rocyuapcTo paccuMErP u"T ace<br />

COOTUBTCIByIRe IIbTOpLI, B TOM 'RCZC, HO He HCXMOqHTeAMO, 4)arropM, uaoxeumme I nyrre 6, HO<br />

oco6o y'qe mBseT oTHoarm XBpBKTCp e H p. 4010Amore noBCe.IHI.<br />

8. B TOM ciry18, CUR, COJ AaCHO yBC) OUMIHBIO 5 COOTWMC C HBCro eMCl CrTme, CyA aweocrr<br />

OniPCJ etHHE 0 HCnpHeMeneMomcriH .Da H a McDH¢AcTB1R 3&nPam]B1oRswM r0CY11RpCO 00o"fey'lae1 OMa3 B<br />

Sb,IA'I, 3anpamHBaeMoe rocyapcrmo yBe oMalBeT CYA 06 rom pemc1-1IR.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

CTHTY 91<br />

COneOIMaHH 9noeWi aOI Af=r' H nnpC.,ocUreHHH ft f IaTloflem1I<br />

1. lpoca od apccrc B npe~ocru n a B pCUOpmcl HanpaaneXa a m eMMaoU auIW. B<br />

HeosoYzAx cay'ux npochSa MoeT HmmpaJnwsC mdoum cpCJ1oN, cfl:o6mM O Cae3mI AOCTaMa<br />

imcMeimoro cooftacH, npH yclOumH noATscpXzcla o npocbSm no KaMj, npcj aCMOwpuaomy a<br />

nymi 1(a) CTWm 87.<br />

2. B cjamae npocm6w o6 apcue H npewocraaemw a pacnopaxcaMae mUa, D oTmomema KOTOpOrO<br />

Hauma npwsapmtar oro npoaaaoH ma iWfBM S OACP HI apeCT Ha ocnosaami crasm 58, upocbha<br />

CoAepIT Ham noJxpenmacTCa:<br />

a)HmaopmaweA c oncaimc pa3mcxHaaemoro ama, Awromo Anx ycrwaaoumua mamocrm mTro<br />

mUar, aH H4)OpMaUIe* OMOC1 WMO BOpOaraoI0 MOeTOH xOI HZTOXACH0I MM 9MM;<br />

b) Koflcd opicpa Ha apecT; H<br />

clTaumB Ao YMMamB, sazCawM us a H m4uopumetw %me moryTr 6h Ho6XDAM 3<br />

3anpaumuma oM roCynapC "e R BMnOnHeH IlpOUeblypM Inpqocauma B pacopeAxmac, 38 HCKolV' eM<br />

Tro, mm m TpC6o0umfa He Aoama 6uMn 60eo odpcmceHamdaLH, aexeH Mc, KOIOpEC llpaMCK DOTCa<br />

a omomcnHu upocb5 o aBusqe a coorc'wrsa c AoroSopaUa Hm ooraamcimenl emmy 3anpSmmmmm<br />

rOCYAaPCTSOM H lpyrlIM rocyaapcTmaaa. H ADI M 6M, eCaa SPO 9 1O3MORO, MCJee o06pCmeamrtebw<br />

c yerom oco~oro xaparrepa CyAa-<br />

3. B c.aye npocbwz o apece H upmao aa eaa a pacuopixcaa¢ mma, YX6 lpHRSELoro<br />

oaiommm, nlpoc6a coApxHr wre noAxpenaewca:<br />

a) eomeil mo5oro opAepa Ha ape=r oro mma;<br />

b)K noila cyAe6Horo pemmuts o npHaama mamown;<br />

c)HH4 )pMaleWk, yKana Cg HI TO, VTO Pa3MCHxaaaCM0 W ARA ISCMI NMCHHO TOM , 0<br />

KoTopom roaopmsC a cyJ.WHOM pcmemi o npmmmBm naumMU<br />

d) c,,€, pasaUczmaeoMy ay aM.eccH npUroBop, KOGECA npurouopa H - B CAYqa nB z ma<br />

ipmroDpa a BA. JlancBs caoEojtu, - 3a eameC o TOM, KaXori CpOK HaIUSmiH y=C oTE? H Kaxog<br />

cpoK ewe ocraeCT OT0M.<br />

4. H flnPocbe CyM CYapcrMo-yiacmHM KOHCyAbTBpyVCa C CyAoM - a6o a uCaoM, H5o a caamm C<br />

KaHm-HaEy KomxpermIm BonpOcoM - oTmocxmo .O x Tpe6oum no cro HatuomH OMy<br />

aZOOARTMaCTRY, ,oTop., moryr npimenarca corzacao nywa 2 (c). B xo c 'raxmx zocyT.ra&u<br />

rocy.apcrio-yqacrmm yaeJoMAO €r CyA 0 Ko-mpel Tp¢CoNHBAH M ro a aHaOM rO 3aKOHOAaMIlCrra.<br />

Crajia 92<br />

1. B HeoW=onxaii czylaax Cy moxer o6pa imrca c apoch6ola o uPaapmwa~hom apec.e<br />

pa:asucaaeuoro aa A npecrunaeml npocb6h o nlpeocraemoi a paCHOpR]rema H nolJEocwulum 91y<br />

npoc-6y AoKyMCWroa, npey-MoTp eH x a craB-e 91.<br />

2. fipocha o npcaeapmneaHom apecre uaPaacrc 6 m CP.AC M, cnocoOum o6egiem<br />

A*CTRKY roCbMeHHOM coo006 -HNS, it CG0pI9Tr:


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

a) HHiopMawwO c OIiHcamM pa3Uc ]zHaMoro JIma, AOCTTO9HylO AAR yCranOaneHRi Cr M OCTH,<br />

H Ha4oopMuno amocwOT mao BepoRTOO MecToHaoz]Imu qw aToro nma;<br />

b)KpaTHoe H3nofeXi tipec'ryrelnk, B cu3m C KoTopUMH HCpIUlae apecr jamoro SMlOf, H<br />

(4arro, npe'OlXoN4MTcJnbo o6pa3yloMnx SM PIeC'rynntHMS, BIOUB, 10 O3 ,IO t'XHO , SBpCM H MeCTO<br />

coaepmemu npecMynneH ;<br />

nIM ta; H<br />

C)3BaICHHC o HalHMHH opjcpa Ha apec nix cye00ioro pC -leNmI o ocyxnerm pa icKHaaeMoro<br />

d) 3azaeme o Tom, io npocaha o npecjirBaneimH a pacnopx seae pa3mcimamoro nma 5yzeT<br />

npcranCflHa no3mpee.<br />

3. T uo, ioTopoe Haxo, rcs no, nmpoapvrenmm apecwom, moza T 6urm ocw6ozwjo u2-not<br />

CMpaKH, eclz 3anpamMoaemoe rocyapcIo He nolqyHno npocadu 0 npCcncMaw a pacuopeme a<br />

nog0penxm=MUW Ml' HpocM6y ,oKyOMearBo, npeao'cuorpeHmElx a crvrre 91, B "rcque ompemoro cpoxa,<br />

yKa3aHHoro B rlpaainax lpotte.JPEI H WKoa3UBWMHH. OAHMio a la ,iio MOJc? AIB'm cornacae Ha<br />

npeAOCaReCHHe B pacnopIXelCHe Ao HCTMCHm. aoro CpOKa, CCX 3aXOOlbTCJThCO 3anpamllaaMoro<br />

ocy3Apcma o.nycuaeT T. B TaxoM cflyqae 3anpamH Moe rocy~apcino 3 Kpainagme cpo<br />

npCeocMaJser aHHOC iMMO B pacnOPEZeCHHC CyAa.<br />

4. To odcTormm rao, q'Io p83LICUIBaCMOC ,MUo 6iaio o OC8OgO CHO H3-nIo0 crpaZH 3 COoaCWTM'RM C<br />

nymzom 3, He wXICIC Ha nocJiCyOumA apelT H flptaocTButCm B pacnlopi0mcHM aTro am=, oCm<br />

no3J(Ce OyJIr npecram cHa npocbda o npCAocTHMCMM B pacnopxeHmHe H nojKpenMnMM HOw Sy npoca6y<br />

JrozyMCHhl.<br />

Ciaiaa 93<br />

flpvre dwomw u owmern<br />

1. rocyapcTsa-yacmm a cooaercrmr m c nofoxc!i¢ m iacrTmOet qacra H oornacHo npoutwyam,<br />

npeP. boOTp€eBM HX H u H0a4Hf tM 3&KoRoABTenaCTM, BLMrOflAHT UpochIm Cyra o6 oranimu nouonea<br />

B CR93H c ocymccTBJemene paCc4BeoBaId HmH yoiolHoI0 npeAfolipBS nyreM:<br />

a) HIemHBmrae H ycTaHOMMLd MCCe= HaXOEO H U H nRejoaeWCMn;<br />

b) noaly"aeH AoK3T cJrh, RKJIOIaI noUKaSBH noji npHCETiflo H c6op AO,1im3cM. , BUoqua<br />

MaeCmS 9KCIepTOB HEX 3aXmO'ICHES SKCUepTHW3, Heo6XOnWMZc Cyjey;<br />

C) Apopoca M6oro AHUB, HaSXojaMerOCR IO CI CACCHeM H" noMpraOtMCrOCS Cy,1c6HOKy<br />

npcMc.AoBaEHMo;<br />

d) BpyqCHE ,oIy] gECHTOBI, a O.loaS cyAc6'le ,oxyMciHr&;<br />

e) coAjcocrmx A06posonHof uxe fl B xaBB 'UcT e CHCJAR O acnlepTOB B CyA;<br />

f) BpeMCmaO nCpera9M Ox, I KU ai m UPCUyOopeo e3 ,<br />

B nyMao 7;<br />

9) npoaCe¢OAc ocOTpa MeT HiE OIclOB, XID'onu 9KCrY UIDO H OCMOTP BXopoiieCE*;<br />

h) poMH3Bo -ra od coB H HMaROCHRA apecra;<br />

i) npeocBeH E nporoXofOB H ARYMOTOB, XmO'la 4HWlmm1me npoToxozl R AoxygeRTM;


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

J)3amWm HoTcpneauNX H cmm ' nef H coxpaHM¢l AOK3M MCn ;<br />

k) a iueHim, OTcneDJAIIHE H 3amopaxzl~amI HJIH apecra Bbpy'qeHHhX epeAcrH, JI(eYaCTH I<br />

AOXOAOB, a "axze opyiA npec'ymeHeH<br />

fide TpcrbHX cropoH; H<br />

Au utct nocnenyoOMCA KOH(bHCac.M Oe3 yigep6a An HpaB bona<br />

1) nflClOCT'am¢Jemlm nc6wx AJpyrmx as0Ao noMo,H, He 3anPICeMCl- 3agOHOaTJIa CrOM<br />

3aInpaURIaeMOrO rocyapcTBA, c UCZI uO COAeJCrBaR ocyulgecat HmO pacvCCAOBaRMM H yMOnOBHOrV<br />

npecAetoaaHR 3a npecry'nJeHra, noiawaInIoxUM nAi IOPHCAUWmK o CyxA.<br />

2.. CyA ynoJMOMOGeH npeocraHmwh caE'mrcIIo hIM sxcnepTy, xam¢IMyCl B Cyri, raparTHo T0ro, TM<br />

mro cBgmeb H qxcriepT He 6yJCT nOAJeprY'r IpCAiOBawHO, 3aUAIORemO nOA crpaxy HJH mo6oMy<br />

JIpyrOMy orpawI-lCeMo lH'qHOff caomoJ co OpOHLL CyJ.a B OTHoWeHMH HO1OO AefCirI1 HAM YfyyIeHMm,<br />

KoTopue nMCaH M¢CTo Ao OTbMrm AaKHOro a.Hza H3 3anpamma¢MOmO rocyjxapcTma.<br />

3. EcJH npu m¢ xaxoft-M6o oHpemo8 Mepm a pamKax nOmOIIZ, yKa3amHoH a npocb ,<br />

Hanpasnemmoft cornacmo Iny ly 1, 3aWPeMCHO a 3anpawmaaMeoM rocy~aPc'T' Ha OCHOa, cyM Oxomem<br />

ocuosononaraourou npmmwa npaBa o6fteo npmCcHHa, 3anpaniga¢Moc rocyA pCTO HC3aMeHmeJHO<br />

flpoaoJlHT KOHCyflbTh1iMM C Cynom a noifl,.rTe pemmr ym BOpoc. B xoe TmXm KoHCynbTal.W cex yer<br />

pacCMOlp~m aOHpOC 0 TOM, MOCKT JIM TaKax OMOLIJb 6MmG npeAc'aaneHa 1)mM O6pa3OM 1411 Ha KaXMXaH6o<br />

ycxohaax. EcJIH nocne TaKmx KOHcymiTaIJ aTOT aonpoc pemmm He yAacrm, CyA asocrr a y<br />

nPOCb6Y HCOdxoAmme H3MeCHMH.<br />

4. B cooiaTmraxH Co crarbei 72 roOeATpOaho-yqacrHHi mosCT ouam B UpOCb6e 0 nOMOIH,<br />

GOmlcMzO HIM MacrqHO, TO1ThKO a TOM Cy'(ae, ¢caH npocb6a Kacaercz npe, eHHm aKmxaJCx-nH6o<br />

JORYMeffTOI M pacKpMM JoKa3aTtfbM , KoTOpL¢ HmeOT omomeIme K ero HaaHoHamuoA 6e3onacHocTH.<br />

5. flpexe 'em oTKa3am a npocbc o nOMOmDlI Ha ociiOBanH nyHmTa 1(1), 3anpanmnaaeMO¢<br />

rocyapc'MO paccMaTpHmaeT BODpOC 0 TOM, MOXeT AM nOMOu 6hm npeJocramheHa Ha KOHKPCTHO<br />

OnPl CJiACCMX yc.oanax ARM Xe OHa MoxecT 6Mm5 npC¢oca¢Ca B 6a oe Io3HCC BpM.A Hm KBxMM-A160<br />

1, 4MM opa3OM, npil STOM nopa3yMcaTCc, "roM, ec.H CYA HM IIpoKypOp npHMMeOT nOMO~hb Ha<br />

KaKmx-ro ycnoaxax, Cy HAn Ilpoxypop AmHM co6moAmAll Hx.<br />

6. Em a Hpocb.c o OMOWH OTea3aHo, 3anpa.elliBaMOe McyAaPcTBO HC3aMeA.JIIHTCJhHo mmOpMHpyeT<br />

CyI Hn lIpoxypopa o ffp'mmax Taxoro o'na3a.<br />

I. a)Cy MOaer o6pammca C npocb o apeMeHOA nepeaIe Ama, coCpxalemroca noi crpaxe¢,<br />

AR OO3HamHm, AaqH noxa3aHfl mJII o mA3lmma jipyrO,) IOMOUnm . Taxoc mmo MOwCT 6wMm nepeP.aHo Cyny<br />

npm co6rnoemm cneymuX ycaifi:<br />

-) juto cao 6oIo JAwT cioe oco'mmeO cornacHe Ha Taxyo n¢cpwy; H<br />

ii) 3alpamHBaCemoe rocyiapcrTo cornamaec Ha nepeJaqy c Co6moAeem TaillI yCAoaBH, Ha<br />

Kornphe am rocynApcMao R CyA Moryr coracmc ;<br />

b)IlepeAasaemoo nxeuo ocraeC r nOA crpaixe. [IoCRn BMblOJMCHHA [Eacki nepe, aqH CyA 6e3<br />

3aJePXKX Bo3apauaeT AaMHoe NO 3alpamHaaeMoMy rocyJapcTy.<br />

8. a)CyJI o6ccnemaaeT KOH411IeHJI LIWOIa b AOXYMCITOa H KHM4))OpaaMa , 3a MCXAq¢HHCM TOM, q'TO<br />

TpC6yCTCR AJU ge. ¢e pacC.JieOBaHa H pa36Hpa=bcMa, o xaxopbix HJcT peq 2 npocb6e.<br />

b)3anpaxmeaaemoe rocyAapc1O MoweT, Kora 9To HeO6XOJHMIO, npenpoaoxaM fiporypopy<br />

AoxymeTr Hmm HH4opmanaO Ha ycomu KoHd)HACHuaHM4ocrH. B qrox cn"y'ae flpoKypop MoXCT<br />

Hcfloa3Oazm Talle ,IOKYMChmu H TaXYO mMOopMaIIo u TO abKO AA gene¢t noa'y'eum HOBaMx ,oKa3aTcnhca;


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

C) 3anpaglmuaoe rOCYApKMC MOCoT no CBoM 6Cr1BMOfl HUDHTIJCmm t<br />

no npocie Ilporypopa<br />

snoCflcmAa AM cornacHe Ha pacxprme Tamx Aoxymcroo am HHO PUM8 . locne aroro oa Mory'r<br />

Hcfol3oBaM Ac B KaqecTIC AoXa3arThM coracaCo noJlOXClma 'Iacred 5 H 6 x B COrOTcmau c<br />

[Ipaxnua DpoILCJYpM H AD RNhiS.<br />

9. a) i) Korea Kaxoc-flH6o rocy~apcr-y'acm no.yaeT BcTprpm npoci6a, oyrnw ma or<br />

upocb6 0 nCpe~ane am ,zjuae, oT CyAa H lyro-o rocyapcm's B COOTBCTcTBm c<br />

aKWAl-nM6o UCZ aPOMM O6a3aXc WUlcM, rocy~apcMo-yqacnmax B KOHCyMTaWUH C<br />

CyAoM H pyn l ocy~apcroM f UpHIalier MCpm UO yAOBiAMopemao oO6Hx lPocb6, B<br />

c.yaC Hc06XOAMoCTH nyrM orcpou<br />

npocbh6l;<br />

aM conpoaozCHMa YCOBHMMN ToR HAH Apyrog<br />

) B oT eC aoro, BcrpC o ipom6w yIomCopiRucE B coo'C Hm c<br />

nPHM=8IaU, 3ptnjllCHMM B cram 90;<br />

b) ecm, oHaao, apoc6a Cyji ,acaeiu EaxopMafag, coOTCH ocm Iam MACl,<br />

noma) Uo, Koa'rpofb Tpevhero rocyAapc a JewapooAH oprama3amUH corZacHo Ka oiayi6o<br />

xexzyuaapoouy cornameamuo, 3anpamusaemoe rocyApCela HabopmapyeT o6 rOm CyA H CyA HanpasneT<br />

CDOMo UpOcb6y TPCnCMy roMCpY'PCny aUH MejiHrapOAo OpraHKH3= .<br />

10. a) CyI mOxeT, no rnio eaaa o6 wrom npoa6m, coyAmnsa c rocy~pCiaoM-y'iacrmxoOM,<br />

wcngynm. pacnieloaaae mmN cy~e6Hoe pa36HpaeMCl B oraomcam AC iu, o6pa3pyonero upccrytweae,<br />

noM&Aa aUec DOA ICaca iop i Cy~a, asm o6pa3yougtro ccpbe3Hoe apecTyfneame cormacao HBUMOHBJnbHOMY<br />

38OHKOOaTeJ~ y aanparMnBaoero rOCyJa8Pcrsa, H oKasbmaTh eMy nomoutl.<br />

b) i) !Iomo=i, oxummae a coome'wcia c noXyarromm (a), almoavr o ce6s, cpeA,<br />

apoqero:<br />

a. nepe.,qy snaaue~mm, AOXyM A MR lAynPYX BEOB a3arehCr, KoaropuC<br />

nO. y WW B XOAe pacc, e¢oaaUz, aWm cyAe6oro pa.apa mca, npoWeeHOro<br />

CyAOM; H<br />

b. AOOpOC .ri06OrO naHia, 3a.epxaMoro no pacnopmeaaHIO Cya;<br />

ii) B cnyae orauaa Cy~po u0ooig Ha ocaoaam noy wyara (b) (ila.:<br />

a. cum JLoKYmCem Him J1J17fl! sHIw JLoWBTCmhC nfldfy'cHL c lZomomll ]KaKoro-<br />

JM6o rocyapCTa,<br />

rocy~apcraa;<br />

An TaxOt nepeAsu Tpe6ymsC cormac€ co cropow aroro<br />

b. w." smmaean, Aoxym€mu Hmaymc BVAW wa3aTtm iTpeJcraue~m<br />

CBHAff'cT m H SIcrepToM, 72WlE nCpeAaa pzympye sc norrxemXiMH<br />

cvrra 68.<br />

C) CYA MOxCT H2 yCJI0BHX, U30CHx elx HACTO CM f7yff , YJOIAeBOpUMl B C0MSTBt C<br />

Hacromnwd syarrM npoca6y 06 OKa3aHHH IIoMOOLH co cropoM roCYJApCM, He SAURRnoUCcB yULTflKOM<br />

CTaryra.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

OraTbz 94<br />

rchooqKa KcrfoNHeUlm nnDO% R RgINf c = naeJRenlU "ae a emnvylniuea<br />

HJTH c11t06H1TEfn~~naM<br />

1. Ecm HCMwSIIItOC KCK RlICWIe npOc6 noMeMa a ueMyCg paccjaautKno HH Cy At6HoMy<br />

flpCcZ. o aW 10 ACfHY., oT. ,Hmom or"e Aca, K KoTOpoMy OTHOCHeTCI HlpOc)a, 3anpa=IMCaeoO rocynapcmBO<br />

M0oz orcpoqxm Hcuonm~cHe mo npocab Ha cpoK, cornacoaammA c Cy~ox. OjAazo orcpoza He<br />

Aol a nlPeaMNM CpOX, HCOEXOJMMB Age 3aaepmtHK CooTac1c0oueo pacAzeojaaMu HmN cyje6Horo<br />

npeciieoaHh B 3anpammeMoM rocy),apcTse. I'epeA aBuecmemac pememm o6 o'cpo m(e sanpamHaaeMoe<br />

roCyjapCr"O J0JMIO paccMoTrPeVb BonpoC 0 TOM, MOzer )IN 6brmb HcMjJieHo npCAocTa.neHa noMouib npm<br />

CO6moWACHIH Onpe)eACHR x yCJ1 OBR.<br />

2. B cyavy npimLhrnm pememu 06 tcpout s coomhenTcsHi c nyf M 1 Ifpoxypop, 1Cm He MCHeO,<br />

Mozer noipe6oah npNHB Mcp AJ coxpaemu ,m)Ioga3aa a coomemru c nyHmroM 1 () TanH<br />

93.<br />

Cranz 95<br />

O Ch0lTa H aHggH fn0CemI.'i a ComH c nnOwe maHeM<br />

B Tex cxyaz, xoria CyM pacca~pmaer npm'eC a oamomemH npMCMtmOCflI jAe.na a coorcITmxHB<br />

co cr&Tb 18 HA 19, 3anpamBmCuMoc roCyqapcrBo MOXT orcpo m mcnoi0meHC npoh6bm B GoOmBTlCIaHH<br />

c HacrogmeB sRacb j o aMneccaus CynoM OnpCUCHeN, ec1H ToMro Cyn He npmHm cncamaboHo<br />

pacnopzxemu o TOM, qo Ilpoxypop mozor npmclum K c6opy AoxamaeJmcr a cooTaercl co<br />

CrameA 18 KOH 19.<br />

Cuingm 96<br />

Coupeyamme npachu n rjpvnm( donMax nomomn cornamo c'rem 93<br />

1. fpocb6a o j, pyxl1 4opmax nMOmomm yaommymb a crae 93, a1npaMaJIC e u a mIcOMCmoM aiMne.<br />

B HoomoXm cn ymaz npocb6a MO3or 6bMm Hanpaanea mo6wbm cpe caOm, cnow6nHim o6ecnewmH<br />

ocrma]Ky nacIbmCMOIOO cOO6 CHHs, 1pM TOM yCJ.OBHH, 'O OMa nOATB PI t JCI 110 KaHaJIy,<br />

npejycmrpemomy a nymmrr (a) cram 87.<br />

2. Tazas apocb6a, a cooTarc''yiou)Jmx cly'laSx, OoJIepxHT PHaN noA penlazcm:<br />

a) xpVM3n H=aoxWeamM IZU, npocb6M H 3anpamnaeMok uOMxR, B TOM 9.CJe IOPHHReCCKOI<br />

ocRoau H oCRoDaan roB npoc,&z;<br />

b) ux Moxxo 6ozec nojpo6aoB mmdopauA o MeconaxosAam Hum zwIocTm mo6or mnma<br />

mm 0 McC, KOTOpme HCo6XoJMo ycfraom anH HTemT URPOasma % iJU rO, '1To6h OKa3aTb<br />

3arpaummaeMo noMomb;<br />

c) KparlKm ormHcmemcm cymecwcwI o6cro'reahcrB, Ha KOTOpMX oCKOHNMaerca npoc68;<br />

d) Mo~fams R AamaM NmoxcNmIe Jolor npotCjTYPL Him Tpe60oaHA, noi am<br />

e) raxoR HH4opManefi, Xaza9 Mo~r ? oTpeoSanc2 a COOTaCTMN C SaKOo ArC MCoM<br />

3anpanfumom rocyfancraa Js Bmoh0 mH npoci; H


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

f) mo ofl ApyroR oOTmocutefics x .uy IuIbopmaw4efl, HCO6xOImOfi An oKa3aH.<br />

3aflparnlmeMot nOMOm E,<br />

3. Ho apocb6e Cya rocynapCraO-yqacrHHx KoHcyrb'THpyeTca c Cy om - nH6o B ttwOM, JemO B Cum3 c<br />

Kaxmw-Ha6y~b KoHKpC'raMw nopOCoM - OTHoCwtmJxbHo Io6bix TpC6oaH-8, npCeyc oTpeHHx erO<br />

HaWMoHa.MMnI" 3aKOHOIaUMejMThOM, KOTOphC Morr npHMCIUIThbC cornlacHo nyHXTy 2 (e). B Xo~e TaKIx<br />

K0Mcy1nTaujtBI rocyJapcmB-ylBcmvx yBeflomARe'r CyA o KoHKpC'mwx TpeCoBBaHRX Mera MIHMOHMbIM<br />

3aKOHO aTIT Tr •<br />

4. looxeCHXA HaCTomC craBbM, B COOBT yI1y1OauMX cfluX, rIpHMeCHgO'Co Taxe B OTHOmICHN<br />

npocb6z o nOMOIUH, HanpaaflCmmOR Cyty.<br />

CTIIB 97<br />

Ecim, uoIyqB npocb6y B coo"c'rCsM c HacToKmeA qacmto, rocyapcTBO-yacnm yCraaBHMUBCa,<br />

,iTo B cB3x c a -HHOi npocb6oh Bo3mmKBIO npo6fleMbi, KoTophie Moryr npenrcmoab eMy Bbino.nmlm<br />

nAmXyz poch~y jpCY 6o HCVIO'iaIOT CC BIdlomHeHHe, TagOe rocyiapcTBo 6e3O"xaraTe ,Ho nposoArr<br />

KoHcyji.bTaimH C CygoM na peileHYx mTo Borpoca. TaxKze pO6JieME MOryT BKJnOqaTh, B 4acniocrH:<br />

a) HCOCTBTOK MH(bzOpMazU(H JA[I BhIflOJILeHIA npocb hi;<br />

b) B crp'ae lpocib6 o npeocJcHM s pacnop eH e - HeB31AO3MO rCTh YCTrHOBsflr, HecMorpi<br />

Ha Bce npxioxeHHe ycHzuns, MeeTOr neaxo MeHe Tpe6yeMoro jiuia mmH CCuJm pe3yJlbTa nPOBOAClHOo<br />

paCc.eJOBaMHH, floKa3Baiolie, TO IHH40, HaxoBUeeCC B 3anpaIIHBaCMOM rocygapcrBe, AMEo He IBUCIU<br />

JMWOM, YHOMAMYTIM B OptepC; Hjm<br />

c) To o6cToxTcmcrBo, '(To BbUIOAHHeme npocb6b B ee MNHCWHeM BHJL, NOTpeosa.Jo 6bi oT<br />

3anpanlMBaCMoro rocynapcrBa HapYUMeHMB cymeCCoBaamxx payce AoroBopMxx o5B3eTebmCTB no oromemao K<br />

ApyroMy rocyAapcy •<br />

Ctamaq 98<br />

C=opVrmnHeeCTO B OTMeFCHHM O 0Q ' MMVHTTeTM<br />

H CAncHgLmcnaJy<br />

I. CyA He moaLr o6pamaBmcs c npocb6ok o ipenocrBRCMHM B parnopgxernie HmJI c flpocb~of a<br />

floMow,, KOTOpal Tpe6Oaaa 6Ez OT 3aflpaJmaemoro rocyJ~BpcTBR AdCC'fHA, IIpoTIEopC'eIWIX er0<br />

o6f13mre m no MeXyHapO8HOMy npaay B OTHOUICHHH rocyapcTheHMHOo mH A I/IOMBTW1CxOro<br />

ammyfwmia alMa MH HMyIIeCh Apyoro focyJapcraa, AO TeX Hop, nOKa CyA He 3apyRImcS<br />

COTPYMMqeCCTOM rOro npyroo rOCYnaPCTBa B BOIPOCe OTKa3a OT MMMYMTeTa.<br />

2. CyA He moxmer o6pamac c upoci,6o o nepenAie, Koopax TpC6oBfa 6bi or 3afpaumemomo<br />

rocyapc'ma n eCTSH, He COMCCflehlOX c CD 6a3aTe ncramH no MCRJYHapoAMm cornamleHmlm, B<br />

COOTBMflHH C KoTOpMMH jU nepCuRa4 KaKOCO-JII60 HI2a Cyny Tpe6ymTca noy¢ege coracHi<br />

HarlpaDMIiUlero rOCyOapcTsa, ecJlH TO1bKO CyA caaima He 3apy"frr cOTpyAMM'ICTeoM HBXp JIROPCrO<br />

rocynapcaa B Rene nofl'ieHmi coFIacH Ha nepetaY.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

CTBThBg 99<br />

Hcnonmemie nioc,6, InI munc n nhe, coracHo craurm 93 H 96<br />

1. Tipocbdu 0 IOMOIH HCIIOflHIIoIC B coTBe TrTBHH C npe4,ycMaOpeHHoA Affs 3roro 11aJi upoinejypoiA,<br />

ycraaosaCHHOR 3aKOHOAaTJIbCTBOM 3anpamliaeMorO roDCyApCa, H, eCRH M1 He 3alnpeUIeHO TaK<br />

3aKoHO oaTexhbcOM, CflOC060M, yKa3aHHIM B flpOCb6C, BKJIIO'ag C0EllOfeHe rno6foi npoitc¢ypbl, yKa3a~loR<br />

B Hei, max1 pa3peC1CHHe J OOIM, YKa3aH.MM B npOCb6, npHCYTCEOBZTh H OXaMIBaM nOMOUb B nOOUCC.<br />

HCnOAHeHHX-<br />

2. B cflyqae npeAcrasnmm cpomoik npocb6u ,oxyMeJr, AOWB ubcTa, oro'roMCM.Me B (YTBCT<br />

no ipoc6c Cyja, HanpaBsnOTu B H.YrTnOMHOM nOplle.<br />

3. OrBemz 3BnpatfnaeMoro rocyDapcTBa nPenPOROXAMZOTCH H8 sIMKCe opmMaJIa H B Hx fol0JHHHoM<br />

Sm~ze.<br />

4. Bei yutepda ARM1 APyf.Hx crael HacTOaIIlefl qacrm, ec, 9to Heo6xoAHmo Aux1 ycneumuoro icnonuem<br />

npoc-.6E, KOTOpas moxe-r 6b.m HcnomteHa 6e3 KaxZx-nfl6o UpHfyAHTtfIh.I X Mep, Bmt.oqa KOHmpV-O<br />

J1onpoc imua HIH noxlyeHHe OT Hero aoKa3artmCrB Ha 9A.o6posoaJoR ocHoae, B oM RHCne 6e3<br />

npHcy'rc'roh BaacTek 3aBTpaflh4aeMOro roCy1pCTBBy'1a-CnH , eC."H 3S KPAHe 3a8Mo A HCnOJHeHm<br />

rlpOCb6E, H OCMOTP 6e3 HIMCHeHH Kaxoro0-jH6o o g.mCClHHoro o6uCKTa 1Im mo0 o-o0IUtBHHomo<br />

Mccra, inpoxypop MOXCT HCIO1HHTh TaxyI0 npOCb6y.HtnOCpeACTSCRHO H TCppHmopHH rocylapcTBa<br />

cJielzouwiM o6pa3oM:<br />

a) eCuI 3anpaMHBaeMOe rocylapcrho-yRaclMleK XBBJIC rOCYTaPCTBOM, Ha TeppHMpHH KoMpOrlo<br />

Kax npeuonaraerca, 6iuno coBepmeHo npeciynncnHe, H 6haa onpeneneia npHeacdoCr Aena D<br />

coosercrauMi co CraTmd 18 11A1 19, IlpoKypop MOweT HeToCpeACrm0o HCnOqiOHH TaKyo flpocb6y nocAe<br />

JpOBeAeHH BCCBO3MOXHLJX KOHCYfhTBI"LH C 3anpaIHsaemum rocy9apcTB oM- THKoM;<br />

b) a Apyrx cfaxx Ilpoxypop MowT HcnomHm TaKyo npocl6y nocne KOHCyabTaA c<br />

3anpamlHBamlmum rocy~apcToM- yaCTHHXOM H C y'IroM OhBlX pa3YMHMX yCAOBH& 114 o3a6oq~eHec'ref,<br />

uBcKa3aHHX AaHHmuM rocy,pcTrBOM-yqa8cTI4KOMC. EC 3apamaCMOe rMcyAapCTBO-yY:acH yKw3MaUcT Ha<br />

npo6neeMu, CB13aHHme c HCnOJIHCHHeM nocbd6a cornacHo 9TOMy no1fyHM, oHo 6C3OTviaras1eno nposoBAH<br />

KOHCYRbTaWi c CyfoM AmU pUceHIm 31TO0 Bonpoca.<br />

5. fozoxemia, pa3pematolmle sHUy, 3aCJIHBaCMoMy JI AOflpamu¢noml bOy CyfoM coraCHO cramTe<br />

72, cchiaiamCH Ha orpaHHseHHf., ipe HaaqeHmH An1 HCJOnTYCKI pa3rlaIeHR KOH4HRJCHEMAB¢a a o<br />

HH4IopMlIIUH, KaCaSO11,eR4CI HagtHOHaJnhHOR k3onaHocrm, 6yjzyr Tmxe npxmeHxTrcA K HCflOflHeHHiO npocb6<br />

o6 OKa3aHH IOMOHIH, npeCTaAlCHHMX B COOnTmBnrH C HaCT030I CrTabeii.<br />

CraaW 100<br />

1. O6 hime pacxoJW, CK3BaHHwe C HCUOAHCHHCM fpOCb6 HR TCPPHToPHH 3anpamHnaeMoro mocy11apcruBB<br />

nOKpblBaIOTCA 3THM rOCYAapCr&OM, 3a HCKARCHHeN HHXCCiCAYOAHX paCXO9,0B, KOTOphIC 11oepbIBlOTCa<br />

a) pacXw , cB3aHHhic c noe3AlaMH u o6ocnetCeCHHM 6e3onacHocT CBm11nCe.e H gecnepEon zen<br />

nepea~aeik, corflacHo craTe 93, 1114t, HaxOUIXnXCs rloA cTpa1Kef;<br />

b) pacxo9. Ha r hMemHuf H ycimri nepeaoRf H cocraneHme cremorpamm;<br />

C) .yIrTBbIC pacxom H cyronthe cyief, IIpoKypopa, 3aMecr1in e Ilpoxypopa, Cexperaps,


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

3smCCmax Cexpempi H c1pymo0 i6orm opau CyM;<br />

d) pSCXoJW Ha iInooToKy o6oiro SaKfl N Sr S'1 awepra RAH SgaepTh3M, anpomeax CyoDM;<br />

e) pa=xoU, ca3aHMe C nepCAo olA nla, ntp=UasoM a paxopxaszeO CyM roq,,apciro<br />

Mecm coAep nouu n0 cip xe; n<br />

f) oCne KolHcyJmhTawId - mo6hi 4pe3 Hbtahfll pacxojW, IoToPUO MOlY? 6hM DU3saam<br />

ucgommem nipoc6m .<br />

2. lioaox0a5 ay 1 B C TCy mOOI ,wHZ npmieammug B olomcm npOCM z Cyri co<br />

cropogm rocyApcm-yacrimos. B<br />

Kc8OJOIHNCM.<br />

oM czyae Cyt noKph15 o6mwwe pacxog,, craime c<br />

Cyanma 101<br />

1. Jluito, nepeaaemoe Cy~uy cornaco uacromzeuy Curnry, He no~aewT Upouoccyan.M uI AcRmOaa,<br />

H8Xa3aNOo mm CORCpxaHmO 110c Tpa, 3a ,Oe oioeceueuame, Aonyoue]oc Ao napemau, KpOMe Toro<br />

nOeCAUM H filum AI 0o5eJeCUS, odpa3ylolio[ ocnoay npecrynneull, 3a aoTOpble m zMo nepesaeca.<br />

2. Cy H.,er npocwm rocyapcro, nepeumee mwo Cyu', oxa3aM C o1 Tpe6oaam,<br />

ycraEOBeAu I 5 UYINyM 1, H, B Cayla HeoEoxomuocm, Cyt npeAvaaar AonommuyoM moopmmo<br />

s Cool 101 co c€"racJ 91. rocynap -yqacrimu npafouom yooameopflm npoc6y Cyia o6 OIa<br />

0? Tpeoaai AomcmI CIpeT z ,cJAr1 50.<br />

u xe el uacioumem CTyra:<br />

Crama 102<br />

a) .peJava' oM 0m auePOr A ocray mua mCApemo a CYp 5s e 1rM c macrOanzioX<br />

b) "maAma omame caT y A ojpwu royuipcrou a gyroe rocy~apcrBo a Coam nn C<br />

OODOXCIEZUE MezyanpOiHOrO A0OS0p8 KOH~aeJWIN HAMl HW11E0H511001 3SaxOAOJfMCLCB&.<br />

qACTb 10. HCHOIHEHIRE<br />

Camhg 103<br />

1. a) Haxa3alme a ane cumems Co6o,,, o eurca a rocyuapcae, Halla'leCom CyAom u3<br />

ncpIInOI roCy cpclr, y75.9MMM1 ( Cyui 0 COC lo105HOCc nPBUMh 1M, rXMOlPM mECO npHOOP.<br />

b) B To Cpem, oIA mcApcro 9CIaWT nc mueme 0 roomaocI np muoHMW fla, OmopUM<br />

aUIece npMorop, M10 rocyuapcino MOXCT yaa3WM ycnoaIuA Moro npMH'MZ no cornacoaum c Cyuom m<br />

a CDo rVnu c acioanui qacmio.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

C) r"OCyMBCpTBo, H9HsaqCHEM Ah oT~bM= HaxaaHa 3 sn Ce codoma 6mmemu 1 i m o<br />

Ajne, HelaMejIBm'ejmHo mztopmpyea CyA o TOM, cornama f nu oo c 1po3aB c1fHUM CYAOM<br />

Ha3H aq'eMM<br />

2. a) rocynipcrm xcnoimteaus iparomopa y ,ewuxer Cyx o mo6,- oacrogmacrmex, Bmunmoa<br />

aumomtemte mo6bix yciosM, cornacosammin coosrcrmm c nym mom 1, xoTopue Mory'r iW mtcx<br />

UOfBfMlr Ha YCORouM M nlpo, ojmwrrnocTM MzeHmm c3oo0,i. CyjA yacjwMwzHerc 1e e MCHCe U1.M 38<br />

45 AcRie o uamu mo6dux Tm o6croremcm, Koropbi moryr 6rn, mHc-rK Ru IOrOp,.e mozao<br />

6uio npe, Buue h. B m'nena swro nepnoa apcuemi rocyApcram scnomenm apmvocopa He<br />

npeutpmm ae'r Atc€c'rgm, ioropue xorjm 6U H&Hecra yMep6 nmwRmMMo Rm cSoHx ods3arencra<br />

corjicio c€are 110.<br />

b) EM CyA He moxer corzacwmcx c o6crormncmaa , o KOTOpmX roaopmr B noAayrre a),<br />

ON yac nMnCT pAmOC rocyAapcio MCflomlem npnroNopa B jteiyer s cooeTCrcan C UYmHrM 1<br />

CTMbiH 104.<br />

3. [IpH ocym ,cTJ Iw m caonx noio[omit[ no xHaaxaieiuo ocy)Japcraa B coor vercwc c nyiKmm 1<br />

Cyj npnmgmr no alnmtane czcnvmuee:<br />

a) nIpamM, Cornacao KoMopOUy rOCyAapCTBa-yR&Crdu3 p93JWr OTrCT OCTL 3<br />

Hcu omJeHoE HawaHRA fo aae ,imexiii cao6oh s coom'€'RaC IT1W c Cnpa, niau pfuPBBoF<br />

paCUpCe4IACe , Ka Mo npCJ CMVpnBUCT 8 'lpUHSax npoztepU H AoK&U.MM;<br />

b) npmmeum umpoxo npmsammx Me ,pomx Aoroopnmx c'raugMpron o6pamemm c<br />

3aKnamoqeHLM;<br />

C) Meo ie sana, KOTOPOMY a cH UpuroSop;<br />

d) rpazjwacno amla, KOTOPOMy umace npxioUop;<br />

e) Tau ,tpyre 4)aropu, ,oxopme xacaaOm 06croramcn peciyrneuus wrH nima, KOTOpOMy<br />

Bw(eceH ripmaop, mum oerrmmoio Hcnoiemu H.Kmmm B KopUC Mooyr oxa3ascJ yMecrCuMb ulps<br />

HBL3a1'CHx "cyAapcra HcOJ m pitronopa.<br />

4. Eczn Em oHo H3 rOcyAprB He H8a3iaqeo B COorzBcR"Cma nYIHrOM 1, H-1Ma3axe B BRIA<br />

nmeamix csooms o"6aacma B iiOpeiaom yqpezxm, npeocTauxemoM r0cyapcmm ipe uLBaHmU, x<br />

cooTCTmm c ycoBImmI, npWvmnpemwa s cornamemw o mn6-xupC, ynommwoM a nymr 2<br />

amu 3.<br />

HcCC? Cyxt.<br />

B TaKOM c.ymat pacxopo, cmaawe C xcnowmi ecM Halunw B sx .immemx cwioat,<br />

1. CyA MoXCT B Mo6oe Mpes UPMWrrM PCIUCHIt o U0CtPOtIC fMMl , KOTOPOMY UZeCC c IpHIOBOVp, B<br />

fr7phNY ,pyroro rocyjApCa.<br />

2. J'i~o, KOTOPOmy nWmec npmwoIp, mOXe B mDsoe ,peMI o6parc a CyA c oA&Taicrm 0<br />

ero zplOjte B rocyapcr'a dcno.SxeU npm-oMOpa.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

eThA 105<br />

14nomlrenge nommnaa<br />

I. C codmonamemi ycnoBRA, KOTOpze rocy~apcrao Morao oroaopim Ha ocHoBajxK nyHrTa 1 (b)<br />

cmms 103, RpHr0$Op 0 Ha3HaqCHHH HaKa3aHHB B BHJ. ImCHImI CBO6oA sI eT C oB3tmeJmaum AJx<br />

rypc rsn-ycMrmKOB, KoTophIe Ha npH KaKn o6cwzxenjbraax He MOryr H3maCr cro.<br />

2. Tomao CyA xewer npano npmHMwh peeHHe no mo6omy xo, .-ra my 06 OEXaJIOBaHH R<br />

nCpCCMOPe. rocyjapciio CMo AHH pHrOSOPa He UpePUTCBYeT IHUy, KOTOPOMY BlHCCeH nplrBOp,<br />

o6patumca c A106LM TaUMM XO aTaACTeOM.<br />

Ormm 106<br />

HAmop 3a oCgyneCemeHMeM npr"ooma H vurIoIngMR<br />

1. HcnonHeme HaKaaHM B BHJe amj elia cBo6ogm oc ecrugem :IOA HaSOPOM Cyja H AOJXHO<br />

COMM-MCroBBm IRHPOKO IIpH3HaHHW. MeyHapoHuM AoroBopHWm CTaHpTBM o6panleaH C<br />

3aKJ=qoC)EMa •<br />

2. YcnOams ammeH Bo6oa pcry iHpYoTC 3aKOHOaTChmc~OM rOcyjiapCTha HcIIOjiHeHRm apHmaoopa H<br />

JOMKHM COOTMMTOBMTh MKpOKO HpH3HBHHTInM M yj]yHapoomihM AOroBOpHm Ca~prBM o6pameiea C<br />

3aKJnOqeCMUhmH; MTH YCaOBHB HH B KaKOM C3"le He 6yiyT 6o0IcC JiKH MeHme 6aaronprHrHbJMH, ,abe TC, B<br />

KoTopuX COjiepXKCa 3aflnOqCHHWC, OCYIejCHHMC B rOCY~aPC HcIORItUlS PHMoBOpa 3a COBepmeHHC<br />

m'omLwx npeCeyrloemg •<br />

3. iepermcxa mexy .nHuOM, KoTopoMy BijHeCCH npHroBop, H CyoM euBI IiCC 6ecnpCewrreHHoi H<br />

KOH4bHAnCH1aHBUH0<br />

CTBMhJ 107<br />

llnenn'na nmna noCzne marru Harp2AMw<br />

1. nlo oT6um HaBKB3mB 1Halo, He eamomeICC rpaJnammBo1 rocyjiap'rna HcnomCmI nparmopa,<br />

MOmer B co0i1CnmBuH C 2KaoHOJATmC M mOcyapCTa HCUOJIHeHHI npHroBopa 6mrm nepeiano<br />

roCyJApCry, KoTopoC 0693a3HO IIpHHr JI HtO, HM Jpyroy rocyIpCTVy, KOTOpOC CorJlacKo OplU<br />

gm jHio, yqHTbiBa fpH TOM .Moil foxeiaHm JiHuaJ, nionnexaero nepejaqe TaXoMy rocyiapcmly, ecaH<br />

TOJlO rocyjapco HcnoAmeHHs nplroaopa He AaT<br />

Teppwropm.<br />

TOmy i " pa3pemeHme Ha npc6UbsaHHe Ha cBoeli<br />

2. EcKH E oAHo rocyjiapcBo He 6epeT Ha cC6g pacxojibl, Csa3aHHUe C OepWCjq aIHB B COOTBeCTHH<br />

C InYTOM 1, 6pCMA 9rmx paCXOoDB Hecer CyA .<br />

3. lipH ycnoum co6nmnem nonoxemu cemma 108, rocyapcro HCtIOJmiCHg npHrowopa MOxcT "axge<br />

B oTmffCTmhHH CO CBON 3axOHOrJIMTJohBOM BbuwJJ Jn mJOhlM o6pa3OM ripeocrBouTm COoThwrylOuiee<br />

.,fmo a pacnopzxeHe rocyjapcray, o6pa'raemycn c npoch6o o sua LHaH npeAn, ocfralO cCHH B<br />

pacnopNIeme roro mma An uel€ cyJe6Soro npecnejioaaas HZ HCIOJIHCHHiZ nparoBopa.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

CTam 108<br />

OrpHMeHHe B oTHrtneuHN vrnjlnaHom L CenOBBHKR<br />

1HH HaKRIWRJHA 3R nve npgoKBDnTTlIcmU<br />

1. fHl0, KOTOpOMy BIHeCCH npHroaop H XOTopOe naxorrca no1 cTpaxcfi B rocyJIaPCTBe acnojmemia<br />

npHroBopa, He no3JIcIHT yrOnOsHOMy npecA¢JtoBaHwo lRll Haxa3aHmo iiu6o Bbh0a'e TpvThMy roCy apCrBy 3a<br />

mo6te AeomqI, CoBeepllHHbe TIlHM JTHLOM 00 ero nepeOaql rocyoapcray HCnOJIIeHHi npIHroSopa, ecIm<br />

TOMAO RaKoC yrononaoe RlpecieooaalHHe, aKa3aHHe lou Bbaaqa He 6150H y'racpiKleo CyooM no npoch6e<br />

rOCyAapCM HCnOJIHCHmH llpHroopa.<br />

2. Cyt npjThmaeT PCICHHe no aHHOMY BOnpOCy flOCJlC TOrO, KaK HM 3aCJyMaIO MHcHe JnIWa,<br />

KOTOpOMY BrhMCCeH npKroop.<br />

3. flyfwr 1 nepecTeeT npHMCHI-bCo, tCI JlIHUO, KOTOPOMY BLIHC"H npHroaop, no co6ctemoA some<br />

HaxoOICst Ha TeppurOpmH rocyaapcrsa HcnojHcHHm nprosopa 6once 30 AHtA nocde oT6w mu w scero<br />

CpoRa Haza3aHHn no npmrobopy, BIIHCtCHHOMy Cy0oM, -1160 B03paUlaCTC Ha rppHTOpHO TOWO<br />

roCYJpCTBa DOCAC TOM, KaK nOKHHyJIO eC.<br />

CTaTbII 10 9<br />

IjC]OJn eHHe eIJICeHHf o mTMadlax I KOHjIbHCIJuIHoI.Ix MQDX!<br />

1. rocyJApcTma-yBacnamm o6ecnegalor acnoAwcme pemeHxg o nrpa4ax H xomHmiuOHmuX mcpax,<br />

wHcem wX Cy~om Ha oCHoaH4 qacTm 7, 6e3 ytLLep6a JII npaa bona fide TpeTi]X cmopoH H B<br />

cooBeTCrs C npoueoypoA, npecydMopeHMof HX HaUOHabHLIM 3aKOHORT¢aI.CTOM.<br />

2. Ecnm rocyjapcrso-y"acmHE He mower o6ecncqmrb pelemn o KOH4)Hcmatim, OHO npmHtMSaT MCpbi K<br />

B3lCaHMUo ,oxoooa, H~yuCCCTla Him auTIBOB, noJIJ0.xa~tHx KOHHCKbIatJHx no peueuHwo Cyoa, 6e ymuep6a<br />

Anupas bona fide TpmTHx cropoH.<br />

3. HmyqecnO HHu1 AOXOJw OT npO0aKH HeASHKHMOO mumecraa Hm, B COOmeTcreyBolauIX CwyIBRX0<br />

OT npoaza HHoro MyUtecrsa, KoTopot noilymeHo rocyapcTom-ylacrtmHoM a pe3yblTaTe HCnOAIeHRHNL<br />

pe-euum Cyoa, nepeoamcs Cyoy.<br />

Chrm 110 O<br />

paccaoreiwe Cynom RoflIOC! o6 ymcHJ.IJJHHI CIJOXB gaaHHJAImm<br />

1. rocy~apcTso HcnojmeHmA npumrOopa He MOKeT OCBO6o0HT7 110O AO HCTeCCHHI cpoKa Haza3anHu 11o<br />

nparoSopy, BIHCCeHHOMy CyAoM-<br />

2. ToflaKo CyA HMeeT npaBo npHHHMaTb pCeICHHC o KaxOM-H6o ymeIdmeHHHN cpoxa H Hm H<br />

BMHOCIwr nOCTBHOcm HIIC n 110 FOMy Bonpocy, 3acjiyuiaB 11muo.<br />

3. KorAa JmImIo OAlwo jABe TpemT CpoKa Haxa3aHvI mn1 25 ncT B cIYMat no -mHemiOro OmiIICHsm<br />

C5O6W, CyA ocylecmseT o63op npsmoaopa, c TeM iodo6U onpe cOa'Th, cneyeT 11 yMemCHSIU<br />

Ha3HaMHIOmft no wromly nplroaopy CpOK maxa3aHHm. Taxo 063op He 6YAer oCyU~teCTwnzh AO acrynHfMu<br />

yCTaHOnneImUoro Bumle fJI pHOR.<br />

4. lpH OCYI cTCeIeHHH o63opa Ha OCHOBaHHH nyH Ta 3 CyA moxer BIJH¢CTH pememue o6 yMeHLmCeHl<br />

cpoga HaKa3aHHI, CaiH OH yCrHaaBmHaeT HaJIHHHe OOm10 HRH HeCKOJIbKJIX U3 CJlC0IOIIHUX lbaTopOB:


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

.a) Bmpazcmtu Ha pame us1C He3mamax rom'm ocm mna corpy9rtm c Cyjo- B<br />

npoamojwxi xm paccnejoaamu v y oJTosloM nptc. enonazm;<br />

b) no6pobomuag nOMOh Co CTMPORM HM AB oOeOCeHJH HCuoJMeMn pMlOMHM n opmaaos<br />

Cy~A B pyMlI CnyM&am H, B %acHOCTM, O3wa noouMoW c g teCslwO Bm emmUfau mUCT mWXOZAcm<br />

a'rrmao, H8 goPuc PacuP0vCP 'IHC JAc'rH IIocIommIon M 0 unpI, KoH4cKbimaZn am<br />

so3MCmmH ymCp6a Ko'mpuc moryr Hisaom3saC s mrrmpHcBX noarepneom; m<br />

C) Jpyf"xe 4arropu, apej 0,uorpcupwe B Ipazaax opolUeWpu N AOKW3NBaHRZ, KOTOPMle<br />

cmm1mCJOCrBylr 0 HBHOM H mIweCTseHHOM H3MCHtmH O6crToIlfhcfl', Jor'rlaoNM Toro, RToE<br />

nOcYZxHM ocRonmem AMR yMeMainCHU RUAB3aHH.<br />

5. Ecnu npu nepaomaraimou o63ope crzmaine uyaxi 3 Cyn npxxojwrr I[ Uwel 0 aegeacoo6paaomm<br />

ymcaunemm clpoa Haxa3amtx, To sonpoc od ymCemIem cpois NKa ammI paccuaTlpaArci Hm<br />

MIOCflWMC qCpe ThE O POCZyMNKy RP HN C IpRMCHCHHWM TIWM Zpn Hpae , imp npe'cuoTpeSW<br />

B fIlpaimaX nPO ANPIep H JIOXa3MBBMH.<br />

CTOThz 11<br />

mi mmo, npaHaRaot UmoBS , cosepmacr no6er 3-noA crpaz a nomma rocymperso<br />

HMo~J1HeHM npnrouopa, To M rOCYaPCTDO MoXCT nOUC KO.CYJbT=M C CYACo 06PATBTW c npoa,6o1 0<br />

nepeRC JU IA K rOCyapcMly, B KOToPOM Wro MWliO HaXOlgf., B COOf nrCMsi C CAC1yIMouMdM<br />

jwycroposmooa as mHorocropommm Auomsopcsmocmi a6o noxfr o~pam&mcrs K Cyy c apoabok<br />

xoA'aficssoa-m o nepe.ae MW~a B coa sm c 'acma1o 9. OH noxer OrAm psopmeMe 0 Om,<br />

,ro6mt mno 6wio AocraucHo B OwpcO, s KOTOpOo o iiumo Smame, mnm a )Wyroe<br />

rocynAc, RaanHqe ot CyloM.<br />

qACMb 11. ACCAMMEIIR rMYAP -YqAcrHHKOB<br />

CTrT!,. 112<br />

Accaimnpa rnevnznem-yqtcnmn<br />

1. Hacrouxswaa yqPcznacr- AccauHea- rocyjapcra - yacn-utoa NacroMero Cmya. KaxMOC<br />

rocyapcrao-yacrm x 4eCr v Accaa6aee omoro npe c iemn , naTomposo ow oxvma<br />

3mecTCrCnn a coaemnm. jlpyre rocynapcrm, noxmcaine Hscroiad Cryr - 3ar--m<br />

arr, moryr 6rm namwsoA&Tasai B Accannee.<br />

2. Accauft xz:<br />

xoumcclin;<br />

a) paccM Wrp sT a 3 iOOT$VcnyOuax cfuiYq , npaam31e PexOMeRAa flolorOareMno<br />

b) nperAmc e fpeaarjyy, flporypopy H Cegpe"aplo ajMum pnlmHu[ o63op no fonpoca<br />

ynPUeaaz jAaa CyAa;<br />

C) paCMWBpMHeBr AOKRBa H o6cyxiw Aem m Eoipo, yqrpcICMo a comtC,'m H c<br />

nynmr 3, x npa]nnar 3 a CBE3H c 521W OOTICCTIY!0I)mH¢ MCpm;<br />

d) pacawaTpunaH& H npmmaeT diomeT Cy~a;


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

e) p c ,c'r cm Jileow6xomoCrl , MCHwm, B cooaTrai" co crbnfl 36 ,ocno cy~cjk;<br />

f) paccMaTpxtsacT wo HcnoiteHxc nyitrroa 5 it 7 craTbu 87 nio~oA Bonpoc, KacaOUBwcS<br />

OTCyrc ma corpyAHtitccTra;<br />

g) ocyL'tecTazeT ,o6iae Apyr te 4)ymw, coaMeCTrie c aacrozm' rK CTroi M M rpwanaMn<br />

npoixezlyp, H A OKBa3maM.<br />

3. a) Accam6nea mmeeT Biopo, 8 COCMB KOTOpoo IXOJI T YnpCA~eA~rW, Aia 3alUCCrUfeR<br />

npeiccna'rcna u 18 'UiCHOB, H36xpaeMlha Accvamncc* CpOKOM H a Tpi ro .a,<br />

b) Biopo itMeCT upcAcTU WMs xap&XTtp, y BmLsIUUML, B naCTROCTi, KpmpXK<br />

cnpaclBomO rcorpa(bnecxcoro pacnpe.Jcac mlmJi H HwJxcamrcro upecn<br />

CHCTeM MH pI.<br />

rmaTrc6iclta OCa oBHx npasauOnX<br />

C) 3aCC t 6Opo S Ipoaol.'rcs T2a qaCTo, Kag ReO6XO0oMO, HO He pc1e oAioro paa i roA.<br />

OHO oKabB=laCT noMout, AccaaMt.ce B BulfOHCiH ee o6zsaiioc1 ft.<br />

4. Accajmgez MOXCT yqPcXJXAr TBa€ B COMOr2TILMMC opnM, Krophic Moryr o0a3217-R<br />

HcO6XOAiitMLW H~, BUKfOqia co3laHfc MexaHw3Ni Haopa A npoxc~cwit. itacnc flu&, oieiox it<br />

PaCcz OBaM, j cTUMoc'ri CyjA aB IlenI nOiMUt er gd)4iwiocrH i IxoHomWHzoc T.<br />

5. rIpcAwCa&rce Cy~a, UpoKypop, CeKpepib HM Hx npCjc~rnamm noyr yqacaoiam, no MePC<br />

eo06XoAHMOCM , B 3accIaHmwZ Accamdaem m Biopo.<br />

6. CeccxH Accamtniem npooArc1 a MeCTC npe6maBH CyA mitIim B ltp mix ywcxpectitn<br />

Opram3anm 06uwmeHmzx HantH oAH pa a roAl; it x0rm 9OrO TpeGyIT ocrrTmocTia, apoaoxncs<br />

cneLtanm.ue cccrn Accaa6ntex. Ecim titto ie nPencMOwcg B iaC'roefM CmTYrM, Ce¢MAbMCu CeCCit<br />

co3,.lorci Bopo no ero co6c-moA itiTw m am no npocbO OAHO TpvM roCy pcis-Y aCn=uOB.<br />

7. KaXAoe rOc ,&pCiiO-y m KweeT o roioc. Ilpelnpinumj.Rcs VAc ycXMm lAA ,woc eHmH<br />

pemeRmi Ha octO KOHCciHCyc B Accatmtine i B fIopo. flpm HciOaMOAROCM JiOCIUxCHRS K010CCHCyC&,<br />

ccnI itoc He npeiycuorpeo B Craryre:<br />

a) pemcmtz no Bonpocam cyncecrim AoKnxu y'repzx~na 6ojznuncrmom a ,Ale rpcm<br />

npHcy'c'IyloUXHx H y'IcOhyiomM, B MoJIOCOBaaII rpt yCflOXHU, qTo a6cowwroroc 6om nmitcmo rocyLapCTfymamxon<br />

o6ecnemmaacr xiopyM Aim ronocom;<br />

b) pCM Tu no Ronpocam npoIlp, npiti csm upocr Oommmo npitcyrcuyuom R<br />

ytacmybonmx a ro.ocoaamit rOCYoAApcry'I-BCrTtZOi*<br />

8. rocynapcra-yqacrm , iMcloUine 3~oxctlO rh no Bb=rMIZ BIHOCOI AM 9IOKpwnmh paCXonAQ CyMa,<br />

He KmecT apaa rooca a Accam6,nce it B Eopo, cm cymm8 em ZAAoJIcmKocrh pjiBtcMX Ham<br />

npeBiumaCT cyMMy rlpHqraom C c Hcro B3HOCOB 3a npcjwujyule nia nOowx rOA. Accama6c Tem He<br />

MCHcc MOxeT paR3pcmIM TIKOMY rocynapcmy-yqacnmy npmmBT y'acre B rosocouHmm B Accamanee I<br />

B Blopo, ccli oHa y6eAJTCX B TOM, TMo HeyrlrBTa iiW3Ui O6MO CTMUf, H a3UNCXU Or<br />

mzyJAZpTU ytICTBMtxa<br />

9. Accam6nes npmmiame coccmeiue npaBHa npott4'pu -<br />

10. O4 RMH.UM, Ha p o60'Om<br />

"2SM.M ACCUMGicR IMOM RUM rWacP&iMpt'o AcCmamC-<br />

OpnmtWt 06- - x Huutft.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

'qACTh 12. 4>HHACHPOBAHHE<br />

CraihA 113<br />

t!HflaRHCORue nwOinxemug<br />

3a xcamHCM caiyaea, xor~a pej~cmaTpHavrc mHoe, mce 4)HmaHcoaue aonpocu, KacafomHwsc<br />

CyM, H c¢CC ACCaMuiez rocyAapcTB-yqacTHmKoz, ax qaa 3accgaMs CO EOpo H BCnoMoralebiJ<br />

opraHoB, peryjmpyorcx HacTromHM CTa~yrOM H 4Nmamcoainom nornoxtmH n H npaJmazm, npmTrmmn<br />

Accamd6nee rocyAapcTB-y acmHxofl.<br />

Cralm 114<br />

flnwnhume nrnmxnnp<br />

Pacxo;u Cyna H AccaM6neit rocyapcr-yamo, xmolqaz cc Biopo H BcnomomoraHme opram,<br />

noKplasalorcI 3a C'eT CpecACr Cyja.<br />

Cumab 115<br />

Cnencma Cyna H ApaM6ieH mcvuancTB-qarmnmo<br />

Pacxomu Cyna H Accam6neH ocyJapcr-ynacn BOa, ammonau ee Hmpo H acnouoraumH eC oprami,<br />

npecmoITpeHHIc a 6o=tfne, npHHImaCMom Accam6neei mcygapcm-yqcrHnOB, nOKpbzaaorc 3a CRWT<br />

ICJ7eOmImHX HCTO'mHmOB:<br />

a) Ha'C.cCHEMe B3HOCbI, fpOH3BOWMKHC rocyRpCeTa"M-yR8rHmam;<br />

b) cpeIcBra, npeo . Oacaewe OpraHm3aum4¢ Of"cmmemwx Hawif, notAn.exaHe yThCpEucHIO<br />

reHcpaubnoi Accam6ne i, B qwcmocmr a ca3H c pacxoflam, noHcccmum 5 em3H c nepCJaqe cw7a8u<br />

CocTOM Be3onacHoCm•<br />

Oraima 116<br />

Tlfladnamnige gwrom<br />

Bc3 yutep6a Au nonoxemui ccamrm 115, CyA MOxel noiryq'wt' H HmcoJsh3osam a xaqecTme<br />

AonolmHTemjix cpe~crs Ao6poo bue 3,moch npaamwrar', mcjcypoHx opraH &aIH, OT'rhhm<br />

1H1., Kopnopat H JpyrHx o6pa3oaaHHf cornacuo comeTcThylOH KpmTepHmIU, npKHuglM AccaMdnecLl<br />

rocyJapC'B-YqacTUoD.<br />

Cra %a 117<br />

BaHocM rcysapcm-yqacmrHKO ycraaazam1M B cooT-er'mm cc ornaOa8oHHo2 WK&Uaofi<br />

HaHCJIHHLX I3HOCOs, OHOaaHHOg Ha IX]aJIe, npwmHTof OpriuaMBa~c O6ummemmx Hamuid An ee<br />

PCryJRPHOro 60oxfea, H cKoppcKTHpOaHHOf B cooaeThUI C apHHIlIaMII, Ha KOTOpu 9Ta E IaI$a<br />

OCHO~biBaCeTx.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

Coama 118<br />

nerrmOamnun<br />

, o0KyAcH12, r a cic'ra i CyA, aUuMaoqa cro o 01lc 4)macoalut BeAomoc2, noj0epraiorcu<br />

exeroJ ol peBcH HO3BHcOMMM PCIH3OPOM.<br />

qACTh 13. 3AK]H10qHTEJ -LHE llOJIO)KEtHR<br />

CranM 119<br />

ypeaumouame GMDMc<br />

1. J'o6o chop oTmocHTfebHo CYA06hx 0yMAHR CYxA O JICrW yperymipoaanUo peCI1HCM Cya.<br />

2. M12OO Apyroi* cOop MeaXI Ay ms Ham 6oqe rocy, apcivam-yacuaxw oTmocm'ao TonmonauiH<br />

Kam upalaicmms Hacromugcro CraTyra, KoropLI H¢ yperyJrapoaa r eT nepcroaopo- B T'eH e Tpex<br />

MaCJaCE C MOMCEra HZ H Maqfla, nepejzacrca Acca 6a ee rocyOapcT-yqTvOra B. AccaK6ane Mom=e caMa<br />

UpCJUIPiUiET YCIHR ARK P93PCMUCHKX cnopa IUIH MOXCT BIZHe'h pILOKOMW0lM B OMTOMeHHH<br />

noc. o 'Onero npfmeHcHa cpeac'm pa3peumelma AaH0oro clopa, aRmoas fl¢pCal'y c¢iopa B<br />

MezMmaponmfi CyA a coaorcrmH c cro CTaywom.<br />

Orar,.a 120<br />

Huxaxae oroaoprzn K Hac'roaemy CTay7 He moryr A ITLCS.<br />

Cui&.a 121<br />

flanPARKH<br />

1. oacreRqmaN CemH AcT c Momaim sCryiieH B CKY HacHoanflero CTa-yr mo6oc rocyeapclao-<br />

yu'Icram mo1 T upejuroamm noipaumu K HeMy. TCKCT .oqoft npe zaraemofl nonpasK npejcramaerca<br />

reepanbHomy cexperaplo Opraeaaa Oftc xHemna HaWA, KoropwU* R.MeAfelo pacnpocrpaiuel cro<br />

CPerO DCC rBcMy Cl'nD-yaCnUhOB-<br />

2. He paaec qeu mepe3 Tpn mecsra c Am yaeoMicnix Accaw cua rocy .apca-y'macrmmo Ha cwocM<br />

cJ-e,.mIOejm COsamCmut 6o.bIHcHTshOM ronocoa IpHcyr'ylUl, X H YRBcaIyIOIIIX 5 rOJEocO,aHm pcUaCT,<br />

pac¢uamprm an Aamoe opeJoeiHe. Accaa6n s MOXaT paccuoWpCn npe4UoeHC HenocperHH Kme<br />

c03BDTh KOHpcJHmIHx no o63opy, ecBH vrOr noTpC6yCT 3a1"paYeHnU Donpoc.<br />

3. Ass apamomi nonpamo,no xoropoi He Mozar 6Lrl AocmrhYr KoKcecyc, coaeuxaM c Accam6eH<br />

rc y~pcTrs-yqcCxaoB wfl KoHimepe eflC no o63opy Tpe6yerci 6ojmmmco a eAe TpeTH rojiocoB<br />

r0CYJABPCTB-YKaCTraK0D<br />

4. 3a HCLumOme Cant upeycMelHoro a nyarmT 5, zionpaara acTacSr a cHty a OTHOmefHHE CceX<br />

rOCyJIapCT"yqaCnTHKo qepe3 rO.l nocRC CAMH Ha xpaHeNme reHepaahHomy ceKplrapso Opraax3aM<br />

O6sezwcmuwz Hauwif paTm11xaHommux rpamao Ham J.oKyemoa 0 nPHflflH CeMIO SOCMUHM H13 HXX.<br />

5. JIm6ax nonpaua K CaThlm 5, 6, 7 H 8 aacroanero CTaTyra aCyneT B CHacy AIR rocyapcMyqact'muas,<br />

nPIUBmUmAX M nolipaKY, nCpa ro noencCA a a XpaHeHMe mx parisKaguomux rpaMoT


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

mm AOpxyumoB o upxusm. B o'momemw rocyapcm-yqacrmma, He npmimmero nonpanxy, CYA He<br />

ocyinecrmmner cooet iopxCAcIwu a "oM, Tro xacaercs rperyrtneHm+, oxuMrBaCMoro Taioi nonpaBKoH,<br />

KOra ORO coacpmacrc rpaxnaMH aroro rocyapcsMa-y'iacnmma HIM H2 Co TCPPHpH.<br />

6. Ecim nonpaBxa npmHrm a w nmcumm Dc rocyJapcra-yqacmHfxon B coOmeicrmn c nymmrom 4,<br />

mo60t roCypcro-yqacrHx, KoYopoe He npHLmO ce, mox"r BuT"H R3 Hacromnierv o Cr c<br />

ne)mEUneHOA canof, ]He 3SBHCHMOCrH oT nonioxeHMl nylrra 1 ciamH 121, o gaKo c co6niogeHmeM<br />

nojioxeamn nymrra 2 crarH 127, Hanpnal yaeeomnceN He no3Aee qeM q'lpe3 roAl nocR BrYIeHH. B<br />

CmJ1y TBKORI nonpammK.<br />

7. re CPmuam cCKpCTBpb Oprameta 0i i4c exHjemu, HaHlA pacnpocrpazer cpcAH Dccx mcy~apcmy'acmmoD<br />

mo6yto nonpaixy,<br />

no o63opy.<br />

npHarryio coseamc Accam6aeA rocyiAapcra-y'acnm oB tHE K epemm¢et<br />

Cram 122<br />

flnnaua it i~nflei,. gewn ~ mmMo ~a~n<br />

1. IIonpaMM K nOROXHHIUM Hacim ero CTBayrB, KDopT a HmIwT Hcxmqo', Tenho HHncnTyw onam, mA<br />

xaparrep, a Hmeimo, K crame 35, nyitraM 8 H 9 cmani 36, craMe 37, cmmTbe 38, ngYHraM 1<br />

(naphe a npeAuioxesem), 2 H 4 crarTT 39, ny ma<br />

4<br />

-9 craTH 42, nyixrvm 2 x 3 cram 43 E K<br />

craTLM 44, 46, 47 H 49, Moryr 611r npwp..oxemla B mo6oe apems, Btee 3anmcxmocrm O" nojioxetixi<br />

nyarra 1 cramsi 121, o6mm rocyjapcrsom-yqacmlom. TeKcr mo6oA npenaraeMoff nonpaixH<br />

npecrAMMec reHCep&AU oMY OCKPCTpIO 0pra~mawea 06"eWamemniX HaWt l, im Homy m ',<br />

HBa3HcBe oMy Accaae6jeeA rocyApm-yqacHHmo, xoIoput HcmAiieHNo pacembacT ero sCeM rorylApcaMy'acrnmam<br />

H HMa y'acThyiomWiM s pa6oe Accam6aeH.<br />

2. ilionpaum K Ha&foMI=C CrTme, no KOTOPUM He MoxcT 6Mm ,ocfI"IxyT KOHCCHCyCy, npHmm Tr<br />

AccamfineeA rocy~lapcIB-y.cBTHHKoD mLn KoN4CepCmN eA no o63opy 6om, imHaOM B Pan TprHr roocoB<br />

rocypapcTB-yqacrmmoB. Taxae notpaBim BcTynaioT s cHAy B oTHoucmm acex rtocyapCr-yqacrmHZos Iep<br />

mecrh ucCzeB noce mx npmarmr Accem6eeii mm,, B 3UHcmmocr'H 0rr Cawax,<br />

o6lopy.<br />

KoH4)epemWela no<br />

Crams 123<br />

fleecrn Cram<br />

1. Ilo HcrTenmm cemm zer nocae BCDcmuDH B OH B omAero cy Cmaryra Feaepamaum cexperapb<br />

Opmmamm 06icMemnx HaamA coumaar KoHapepemwmo no o63opy iAn paccuoipcmz mo6bx nonpasox<br />

K tiacTo~lYmq Cralyy. Taxoe paccMOlpeHe MoxCT BImom[ 8B ce6a - HO He orpam'lHDACTCR ,, -<br />

nepeeam npecrynmemA, cojzepxnmcHa a c-rane 5. Kombepeama omphrra An, y-acnraoB Accamf5eH<br />

rocyjlapCT'(-yaCT'imKOB H Ha rex ze ycDoBaHX.<br />

2. B mo6oe spcm nocae ,roio no npocb6e oworO m3 rocyUapcm-y'acrm os m Ams ueaefi,<br />

ymammWNX B ny'm 1 rciepamTmA cexperaph OpmmawwH 06"mew emm Hanue c ozo6pce~e<br />

6wmmcr"a rocyAApcre-yacmmHoa coMUacr KoNIbepCaHmo no o63opy rocyoapcl-y'lacmmioB.<br />

3. rlooxeaa nymt-roB 3-7 crantm 121 apuMcHEWFn B oDmme m pmTurrax a -lcll~mU s caay<br />

mo6ol nonpaux x CTaTy', paccMarpm=A Ha Kon4)epeazmw no o6sopy.


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

Roaeme<br />

Cramsx 12 4<br />

HeMYrp~ Ha OIOXCHoH nyKr 1 CTTb, 12, rocyApcmno, cr&tHOscb y'IqgcnKOm ACrMIeo<br />

CT,S. MOzCT 3&tafmffl, wrO o Tet'lHe ccMH nOT fHnci Inczcry it HS acw e,0 Cra a c. uy zA.n<br />

COllwteCrO 1'OCYapCTSa OHO He npN3HeT topHcrAmui Cyna a OTiOWmenm KarwopHE npCCnleOHa,<br />

yROMmaea4X B criTae 8, Kora, KaK npr foffarac', npcCTmYC coacpmielo cro rpaz amm Ha na<br />

Or* Tcppimopna. 3acaime no cNucJiy HamCmoiefl crams moxer rm cHro an io6oc speux. flooxemm<br />

Hacmrou xcl cTa<br />

CTanH 123.<br />

paccMapnaaxYM Ha KoHxepe muu no o63opy, couaacajoi a c oahrmwm c nyVrMM 1<br />

LCranm 125<br />

fnommeam., DSTHbHKHHs. flHT. iczame inIHaEC C<br />

1. HacroxnUf CTa&yr 6yner mpbr A, noAmmcajuia woao rocyJapcIUIm n Piae is umra-mpaTpe<br />

fpoRownxr hramot H Oewxoxo3%ifcrOmHxHof opr&mawm O6ewammmut HaxUl 17 moMz 1998 rona.<br />

3mvm oH 6yger mlpirr Ans noaAmcams B Mmmoeprc mocMpamlx n HTam a Peme Ao<br />

17 o0mTTpn 1998 o a. Hoc iaro min CmTyr 6yAe" ompht, nT uomnca.mz s a lempammax<br />

yapcznenmx OpraHN3aiWn 06,AxeHmat Hatafi B Ho-Ropxe Ao 31 ex6px 2000 roia.<br />

2. Havrosnuft Cralyr no~nexirr pane~m~bawm, npwanwo m yT3pz=CHHD rocyapcasMa,<br />

noJHCaUMM CTyr. Parm4)xaxwouKme IpamoT E R AOJCMeUI 0 n0UPHHHH HAM YCPXWmHM CABOT=<br />

Ha Xp MHHC remepabHlomy CeKpe pto Opraxn3agm 06eAKmoeHUX HaqRA.<br />

3. Hacroz g CaTyr owmp rT Ani npooe,,.Hetml scx mcynapCom. Ao1KYMCm o npc=MeMM<br />

Cnaor Ha xpaaeaae reaepamaoamy ccppcrapso Opa s 06 ", embx Hawfik.<br />

CraMs 126<br />

1. Hacrominuf CmyT5 acrynrer a cwy a nepxuaf Aei, mecma, cCeAonMero uocne 60-ro nA nocnC<br />

c.aIw Ha xpaneCm1e reaepammoy ceperapio Opraumawm 06wcmemm HaLu 60-fl pam vammnomiok<br />

ipSM0o7 Him nOKyMatei 0 np HMTKH, yHTaepJneMM HAM UpHCocQMHIC.HH<br />

2. 31)71 K xAoro rocyjapc~ea, KoTopOC pa&Taibc.pyer, npHHmMaerT, yraCpzaer HacToUit* Car tM<br />

npHcoeJCHHcscI K HeMy noue cla Ha xpaHCIme 60-FL pSmhbtHlaouloA rpamao um oumyaeara o<br />

lpIHMETrH, yaep=CM H IpHcoaBe4MeHHC, C aTY yri I CUM 3 ntpiufl<br />

c1c¢ym3oero nocre<br />

,e.s Mtcm=,<br />

6 0 -ro nAn nocne aim TaKtm rOCynapCTSOm csoef paTuirn a mOOO rpawmaO mT<br />

AKYMCI.TB 0 I.PHTl lH, Y'l CPOHI p Hmm npHcoCAHHeCH-<br />

Crai,.s 127<br />

1. JTo6oe rocyapcrao-y"acnm= MoeT atirm n3 HaCcrmero Crary, tHfpswnt reHCpahHoMy<br />

cerperapto Oprameagin 06teHmemwx Hauma cooTacmaywaxee mcwat oe YUCAOmDCHeC, BbzzoA scryrMe<br />

B CHEy RCPC3 rO nOde MGM no.y'CHH TRKOo yBe,ouztait, OCaH a yaCiuOueMM He yKa3boamtT 601CC<br />

.03H CPOK o<br />

,<br />

2. BiaxoA qa FIaeTOsfllrO CTyra Ht ocso6oxnaer rocynAipcm aor atmoateimh 06smaezacr


<strong>Volume</strong> <strong>2187</strong>, 1-<strong>38544</strong><br />

B1rxmCOUm H3 Hacloamero CTarTra, KOmOpIme BO'JHHKi B nlepaHo yqacTuw vro rocy apcIma B<br />

HacwheM Craiyrt, amue mo6u HimacowUC o6anrea, o6" ,M Kerophi MOreT Bo3pacrm. OH<br />

Taxe HeMICt aa ocy ec-rc u pyeHHe MTYJM UCCr C CyjeoM I IpoBeALMHHH yMAOHLUa paBCCeMoBaHH H<br />

pa36Mpam , OipmCewIrrlo K KO1OpSJM BLIxo Asm1e¢ rocyppcno duno o6x3aHo cOTpymluna H KOTOpIIC<br />

6,in Hnam jo Aamr BvC'ryZCmHm sLxo10a B cmuy, a Tatze 1momm o6pa3OM He HHOCHT yMCp6a<br />

npolXaioujemyc paccmodrpeOmo mo6oro sonpoca, KaoPopA HaxO8Jc He pacc1wrpCHH Cyaa .o 8T<br />

BcfryaCHMH BbIZOAJ B CHIY.<br />

CraiTh 128<br />

IoIouHHHm HBcroIIUCO CnTTyra, ITtXKCl KOTOpOrO Ha aurnlhiCKOM, fpaC.oM, HCnOIKOM,<br />

KHTaCKOM, PyCCKOM H 4#paHI OM X2MU S1IMMOMTC paIHO yateIM , C4ACC H XP8PHHC<br />

re'epa HoMy cxpexrapio Oprwa aw 06",,€eHam x HauMH, 1010pmi pa=UnCa 38 34CH e xom<br />

Hac'roEmero CTyra scem roCyApclla1m-<br />

B YXOCTOBEPEHIM E M,.eIoIIBcamx=C, HErO<br />

,OJMM 06pa30 H TO ynOjIMoMOqCHHC<br />

coxmH cooamer-YIoiMdm npamneflwraamm, noArMcaI HBaCODMf Crayr.<br />

COBEPMIEHO B P~me 17 moK 1998 roAa.<br />

[For the signatures, seep. 598 -- Pour les signatures, voir p. 598.]

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!