SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 28
why we still need the physical book and what digital research adds to its history Anne Welsh Lecturer in Library & Information Studies Paper in the brave new digital world: A painless introduction to ...
MA LIS / MA ARM / MA Digital Humanities http://www.ucl.ac.uk/infostudies/teaching/modules/instg012/
“ Bibliography is the discipline that studies texts as recorded forms, and the processes of their transmission, including their production and reception.” ~ D.F. McKenzie
Types of Bibliography ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The life of books
The bibliographer’s province
Communications Circuit Economic  & social conjuncture Author Publisher Printers: Compositors Pressmen Warehousemen Suppliers: Paper Ink  Type Labour Shippers: Agents Smugglers Entrepot Keeper Waggoner, etc. Booksellers: Wholesellers Retailers Peddlers Binders, etc. Readers: Purchasers Borrowers Clubs Libraries Political  &  legal sanctions Intellectual influences  & publicity After Darnton
Books at the forefront of technology
Recording watermarks From: http://watermark.kb.nl/
Electron radiography of watermarks From: http://watermark.kb.nl/
Online searchable watermark databases Also: http://www.wm-portal.net/niki/index.php From: http://watermark.kb.nl/
Other innovations ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Technology in the Brave New World
Homogenisation? ‘ There is nothing wrong in the whole wide world’ by Chris Cobb, 2005
As it’s Burns Night ... http://itunes.apple.com/
Versioning in the digital collection http://www.scottishcorpus.ac.uk/cmsw/burns/
 
“ Extreme Versioning” Barker & Lucas, “Wicked Bible” 1631 Borel’s  singes dactylographes  more likely to produce millions of errors than text of the quality of Shakespeare ... But is it the quantity or the quality of error that really matters?
More typical versioning
 
Store them? Preserve them? How?
Digital  versus  print?
Readers
 
 
Readers http://www.open.ac.uk/Arts/reading/recorddetails2.php?id=159
 
Picture credits Some of the pictures in these slides are copyright commons, some rights reserved: vince42,  http://www.flickr.com/photos/84609865@N00/3714671728/ posixeleni,  http://www.flickr.com/photos/posixeleni/3563513903/   Kaotiqua,  http://www.flickr.com/photos/kaotiqua/131701845/ Diorama Sky,  http://www.flickr.com/photos/diorama_sky/2975796332/ Librarian in Black,  http://www.flickr.com/photos/librarianinblack/1392970571/ Elizabeth Beers,  http://www.flickr.com/photos/brixton/150605829/ Topsy Qur’et,  http://www.flickr.com/photos/topsy/204929063/   goXuno Reviews,  http://www.flickr.com/photos/43602175@N06/4070018828/

More Related Content

Similar to Why physical books still matter in a digital world

Jabes 2008 - Session sponsor : OCLC en France : évolutions, projets et perspe...
Jabes 2008 - Session sponsor : OCLC en France : évolutions, projets et perspe...Jabes 2008 - Session sponsor : OCLC en France : évolutions, projets et perspe...
Jabes 2008 - Session sponsor : OCLC en France : évolutions, projets et perspe...ABES
 
"some crauen scruple/ Of thinking too precisely": democratization, dialogue, ...
"some crauen scruple/ Of thinking too precisely": democratization, dialogue, ..."some crauen scruple/ Of thinking too precisely": democratization, dialogue, ...
"some crauen scruple/ Of thinking too precisely": democratization, dialogue, ...Pip Willcox
 
Du Literary and linguistic computing aux Digital Humanities : retour sur 40 a...
Du Literary and linguistic computing aux Digital Humanities : retour sur 40 a...Du Literary and linguistic computing aux Digital Humanities : retour sur 40 a...
Du Literary and linguistic computing aux Digital Humanities : retour sur 40 a...OpenEdition
 
World book day 2 pdf
World book day 2 pdfWorld book day 2 pdf
World book day 2 pdfkanaka17swamy
 
Digital librarianship - BIALL/CLSIG/SLA Europe Open Day
Digital librarianship - BIALL/CLSIG/SLA Europe Open DayDigital librarianship - BIALL/CLSIG/SLA Europe Open Day
Digital librarianship - BIALL/CLSIG/SLA Europe Open DaySimon Bowie
 
Sr briefing paper_anderson
Sr briefing paper_andersonSr briefing paper_anderson
Sr briefing paper_andersonbriquetdelemos
 
It’S Been Geometric! Genco Ppt For Montreal Session
It’S Been Geometric! Genco Ppt For Montreal SessionIt’S Been Geometric! Genco Ppt For Montreal Session
It’S Been Geometric! Genco Ppt For Montreal Sessionbgenco
 
2 virtual library article 21 34
2 virtual library article 21 342 virtual library article 21 34
2 virtual library article 21 34prjpublications
 
Library as Place, Place as Library: Duality and the Power of Cooperation
Library as Place, Place as Library: Duality and the Power of CooperationLibrary as Place, Place as Library: Duality and the Power of Cooperation
Library as Place, Place as Library: Duality and the Power of CooperationKaren S Calhoun
 
Traveling Through Transitions Slovenia
Traveling Through Transitions SloveniaTraveling Through Transitions Slovenia
Traveling Through Transitions SloveniaKaren S Calhoun
 
New Horizons in ICT for Women
New Horizons in ICT for WomenNew Horizons in ICT for Women
New Horizons in ICT for WomenEWIL_EU
 
ICT Roles in Media Print Industry
ICT Roles in Media Print IndustryICT Roles in Media Print Industry
ICT Roles in Media Print IndustryRichardus Indrajit
 
Academic Libraries In The 21st Century
Academic Libraries In The 21st CenturyAcademic Libraries In The 21st Century
Academic Libraries In The 21st CenturyWilma Jones
 
Richard Wallis Linked Data
Richard Wallis Linked DataRichard Wallis Linked Data
Richard Wallis Linked DataIncisive_Events
 
Looking at Libraries, collections & technology
Looking at Libraries, collections & technologyLooking at Libraries, collections & technology
Looking at Libraries, collections & technologylisld
 
When the Web of Linked Data Arrives
When the Web of Linked Data ArrivesWhen the Web of Linked Data Arrives
When the Web of Linked Data ArrivesRichard Wallis
 

Similar to Why physical books still matter in a digital world (20)

Jabes 2008 - Session sponsor : OCLC en France : évolutions, projets et perspe...
Jabes 2008 - Session sponsor : OCLC en France : évolutions, projets et perspe...Jabes 2008 - Session sponsor : OCLC en France : évolutions, projets et perspe...
Jabes 2008 - Session sponsor : OCLC en France : évolutions, projets et perspe...
 
"some crauen scruple/ Of thinking too precisely": democratization, dialogue, ...
"some crauen scruple/ Of thinking too precisely": democratization, dialogue, ..."some crauen scruple/ Of thinking too precisely": democratization, dialogue, ...
"some crauen scruple/ Of thinking too precisely": democratization, dialogue, ...
 
Du Literary and linguistic computing aux Digital Humanities : retour sur 40 a...
Du Literary and linguistic computing aux Digital Humanities : retour sur 40 a...Du Literary and linguistic computing aux Digital Humanities : retour sur 40 a...
Du Literary and linguistic computing aux Digital Humanities : retour sur 40 a...
 
World book day 2 pdf
World book day 2 pdfWorld book day 2 pdf
World book day 2 pdf
 
Digital librarianship - BIALL/CLSIG/SLA Europe Open Day
Digital librarianship - BIALL/CLSIG/SLA Europe Open DayDigital librarianship - BIALL/CLSIG/SLA Europe Open Day
Digital librarianship - BIALL/CLSIG/SLA Europe Open Day
 
Sr briefing paper_anderson
Sr briefing paper_andersonSr briefing paper_anderson
Sr briefing paper_anderson
 
It’S Been Geometric! Genco Ppt For Montreal Session
It’S Been Geometric! Genco Ppt For Montreal SessionIt’S Been Geometric! Genco Ppt For Montreal Session
It’S Been Geometric! Genco Ppt For Montreal Session
 
31 36
31 3631 36
31 36
 
2 virtual library article 21 34
2 virtual library article 21 342 virtual library article 21 34
2 virtual library article 21 34
 
Library as Place, Place as Library: Duality and the Power of Cooperation
Library as Place, Place as Library: Duality and the Power of CooperationLibrary as Place, Place as Library: Duality and the Power of Cooperation
Library as Place, Place as Library: Duality and the Power of Cooperation
 
Traveling Through Transitions Slovenia
Traveling Through Transitions SloveniaTraveling Through Transitions Slovenia
Traveling Through Transitions Slovenia
 
New Horizons in ICT for Women
New Horizons in ICT for WomenNew Horizons in ICT for Women
New Horizons in ICT for Women
 
Trier
TrierTrier
Trier
 
ICT Roles in Media Print Industry
ICT Roles in Media Print IndustryICT Roles in Media Print Industry
ICT Roles in Media Print Industry
 
Academic Libraries In The 21st Century
Academic Libraries In The 21st CenturyAcademic Libraries In The 21st Century
Academic Libraries In The 21st Century
 
Richard Wallis Linked Data
Richard Wallis Linked DataRichard Wallis Linked Data
Richard Wallis Linked Data
 
Looking at Libraries, collections & technology
Looking at Libraries, collections & technologyLooking at Libraries, collections & technology
Looking at Libraries, collections & technology
 
When the Web of Linked Data Arrives
When the Web of Linked Data ArrivesWhen the Web of Linked Data Arrives
When the Web of Linked Data Arrives
 
The Ground Truth: Arabic Scientific Manuscripts Workshop
The Ground Truth: Arabic Scientific Manuscripts WorkshopThe Ground Truth: Arabic Scientific Manuscripts Workshop
The Ground Truth: Arabic Scientific Manuscripts Workshop
 
The Future Of Km
The Future Of KmThe Future Of Km
The Future Of Km
 

Why physical books still matter in a digital world

  • 1. why we still need the physical book and what digital research adds to its history Anne Welsh Lecturer in Library & Information Studies Paper in the brave new digital world: A painless introduction to ...
  • 2. MA LIS / MA ARM / MA Digital Humanities http://www.ucl.ac.uk/infostudies/teaching/modules/instg012/
  • 3. “ Bibliography is the discipline that studies texts as recorded forms, and the processes of their transmission, including their production and reception.” ~ D.F. McKenzie
  • 4.
  • 5. The life of books
  • 7. Communications Circuit Economic & social conjuncture Author Publisher Printers: Compositors Pressmen Warehousemen Suppliers: Paper Ink Type Labour Shippers: Agents Smugglers Entrepot Keeper Waggoner, etc. Booksellers: Wholesellers Retailers Peddlers Binders, etc. Readers: Purchasers Borrowers Clubs Libraries Political & legal sanctions Intellectual influences & publicity After Darnton
  • 8. Books at the forefront of technology
  • 9. Recording watermarks From: http://watermark.kb.nl/
  • 10. Electron radiography of watermarks From: http://watermark.kb.nl/
  • 11. Online searchable watermark databases Also: http://www.wm-portal.net/niki/index.php From: http://watermark.kb.nl/
  • 12.
  • 13. Technology in the Brave New World
  • 14. Homogenisation? ‘ There is nothing wrong in the whole wide world’ by Chris Cobb, 2005
  • 15. As it’s Burns Night ... http://itunes.apple.com/
  • 16. Versioning in the digital collection http://www.scottishcorpus.ac.uk/cmsw/burns/
  • 17.  
  • 18. “ Extreme Versioning” Barker & Lucas, “Wicked Bible” 1631 Borel’s singes dactylographes more likely to produce millions of errors than text of the quality of Shakespeare ... But is it the quantity or the quality of error that really matters?
  • 20.  
  • 21. Store them? Preserve them? How?
  • 22. Digital versus print?
  • 24.  
  • 25.  
  • 27.  
  • 28. Picture credits Some of the pictures in these slides are copyright commons, some rights reserved: vince42, http://www.flickr.com/photos/84609865@N00/3714671728/ posixeleni, http://www.flickr.com/photos/posixeleni/3563513903/ Kaotiqua, http://www.flickr.com/photos/kaotiqua/131701845/ Diorama Sky, http://www.flickr.com/photos/diorama_sky/2975796332/ Librarian in Black, http://www.flickr.com/photos/librarianinblack/1392970571/ Elizabeth Beers, http://www.flickr.com/photos/brixton/150605829/ Topsy Qur’et, http://www.flickr.com/photos/topsy/204929063/ goXuno Reviews, http://www.flickr.com/photos/43602175@N06/4070018828/