1 / 13

Activity Theory

Activity Theory. One Theoretical Framework for Arts Education Research. Overview. Pedagogy and Features of Arts Learning Artistic Meaning and Mediation Activity Theory/Activity System . Pedagogy versus Curricula. The overall goals of national curricula, internationally, look similar

deion
Download Presentation

Activity Theory

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Activity Theory One Theoretical Framework for Arts Education Research

  2. Overview • Pedagogy and Features of Arts Learning • Artistic Meaning and Mediation • Activity Theory/Activity System

  3. Pedagogy versus Curricula • The overall goals of national curricula, internationally, look similar • The distinction between good and bad arts practice lies predominantly in teacher beliefs and pedagogy (whether these are compatible; how they are implemented) • ‘Best examples’ of assessment methods in the arts lead the education field • E.g., Documentation through participant observation, process- and evidence-based learning, formative feedback… [but are ‘unrecognized’ by other disciplines, lack status and are scantily documented] • Arts ‘best practice’ cannot be uniform in content, assessment or expectations nor separated from context

  4. Unique Features of Arts Learning • 1. Tangible product (Imagination, Agency) • 2. Focus on emotion (Expression, Empathy) • 3. Ambiguity (Interpretation, Respect) • 4. Process orientation (Inquiry, Reflection) • 5. Connection (Engagement, Responsibility) Davis, J.H. (2008). Why our schools need the arts. NY: Teachers College Press (p. 50).

  5. Artistic Meaning: Relationships and Configurations • Paying attention to the way in which formis configured is a mode of thought that can be applied to all things made, theoretical or practical • The ‘composer’ (musician, painter…) creates relationships among a virtually infinite number of configurations • What constitutes the right qualitative relationship for any particular work is idiosyncratic to the particular work • Open ‘rules’/absence of an algorithm: paying attention to nuance, making choices, revising decisions – to achieve a ‘rightness of fit’ • Somatic knowledge/embodied experience – the composition feels right

  6. Mediating Tools: Mind and Culture • Learning and mediation require thinking within the medium we use • Each material imposes its own distinctive constraints and affordances (flute/piano, paint/clay, dance/gymnastics) • Education helps ‘design us’ • “Education is a process of learning how to become the architect of our own education. It is a process that does not terminate until we do” (Eisner)

  7. The Creative Process (Jongeward, 2009) • I work on something (action-interaction) • Something works in me (receptivity-transformation) • Something comes into being (emergent form) • I come to know something (emergent meaning) • Something becomes seen (visibility to others) • I see myself (self-visibility)

  8. Education is:(Abbs, 2003; Wright, 2010) • Existential in nature • is emotionally alluring • taps learner’s somatic, multimodal, metaphoric forms of representation • delves into transcendent, mythical and allegoric forms • A collaborative activity • animated dialogue, in the disciplined narrative of conversation between individuals engaged in the common pursuit of understanding (interlocutor) • A cultural activity which is deepened and extended • a progressive initiation into the culture of the discipline • the intimate connection between symbol and consciousness • emergent curriculum • shared construction of knowledge

  9. Activity Theory (YrjöEngeströmet al – Research Centre, U. of Helsinki) • Evolved from Vygotsky/Russian Psychologists who believed that • Human higher mental functions are products of mediated activity (material/mental tools + interpersonal communication) • Social-Constructivist Principles • Communication, collaboration, partnerships (teachers, artists, community), institutions and multi-disciplinarity • A.T. provides a conceptual aid to research or design of co-constructed learning environments • Relationships and flexible purposing • ‘Thick Descriptions’ with Semiotic Emphasis • Qualitative relationships and idiosyncratic judgements based on ‘rightness of fit’

  10. The Unit of Analysis is an Activity: An activity is Composed of: • A subject/participant: the person or a group engaged in an activity and whose point of view is taken in the analysis of the activity • An object (or "objective"): the target of the activity; it is held by the subject and motivates activity, giving it a specific direction • Instruments/tools: internal or external mediating artifacts which help to achieve the outcome of the activity; they can be material tools as well as mental tools, including culture, ways of thinking and language • ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- • Rules regulate actions and interactions within the activity system • Division of effort/labour is how tasks are divided horizontally between community members as well as vertical division of power and status • The outcome:Transforming the object into an outcome motivates the existence of an activity

  11. Activity System (variations in headings)

  12. Music, art, dance, drama, media… (tools/signs) Teachers, artists, students, families, groups Artifacts, performances, presentations, experiences, knowledge Safety, respect, collaboration, planning, discussion, reflection, critique Partnerships, industry, schools, institutions, profession, cultural agencies Co-learners, mentors, leaders, designers, trainers Outcome: success, well being, creativity, self esteem, unity, diversity, appreciation, communication, social responsibility, spiritual growth, culture

  13. International Monitoring and Comparative Research in Arts Education • Is there value in attempting to identify a theoretical framework that can help to clarify the objectives of the study (e.g. Activity Theory/Systems or some other framework)? • Are the categories/sub-categories the right ones?

More Related