Pumpkin Bundt Cake With Maple Brown-Butter Glaze

This is a very nice, moist cake - the olive oil recedes and the cardamom takes over in a very pleasant way. I halved the recipe (measured) and baked for 35 minutes in my small bundt pan. I used 2% greek yogurt in place of the sour cream and reduced the brown sugar a bit (200 g). The glaze hardens quickly so next time I would add more water. I did saute the pepitas with a tiny bit of oil and tossed them in sugar which made them crunchy and delicious. I will make this again.

halve recipe (200g br sugar); bake for 35 mins.... make glaze runnier than you would think as it hardens pretty much immediately; saute pepitas in tiny bit of oil and toss in sugar - really good cake

Hi. Will someone from the NYT — preferably either the actual baker of the recipe or the food stylist — tell us how to get such a thick, rich looking coating of icing? I’ve made this cake 6 times now (because it tastes so darn good) but have never once seen the icing look as it does in the publication’s photo.

I just gave this a go, pretty much following the recipe with the recommended thinning of the glaze a bit. The only other change was dusting the bundt pan with sugar and not flour. Really amazing fall feel to it. Taking time to properly brown the butter adds a complexity to the glaze that complements the pumpkin cake so well. Neighbors loved it and more importantly my wife did. I might bump the spices up a bit next time out, but this is a keeper.

This cake is amazing! Super moist. And oh my god the frosting is to DIE for. I did have to add a few drops of water to make it spread easier.

Since I prefer weight to volume especially when baking, I measured the brown sugar both ways because it seemed like a lot. I came up with 2 cups packed was 346 grams, not 440 grams. I find when I convert to weights I often double check between weights and volume. They often do not jibe in fact it's kind of like Celebrity Net Worth - untethered.

This bundt got rave reviews at thanksgiving. Did a few subs just because I didn’t have all ingredients. Used Greek yogurt instead of sour cream, added cloves and ground ginger in place of allspice and used dark brown sugar. Cut confectioners sugar in icing by half and it was perfect. Would definitely make again and the cardamom and black pepper gave it a great depth of flavor and warmth. Moist, delicious and not too sweet. Have already been asked to make it again.

Cakes have been made for a lot longer than there has been electricity! Of course you can do it with a hand held, too. You can even make it without a stand or hand mixer by beating the heck out of everything with a wooden spoon followed by a sturdy whisk. It's just more work to get everything creamed and fluffy.

Delicious, show-stopping cake! Served for brunch and it was a hit. The brown butter adds real depth and the pepitas shouldn’t be skipped. This will definitely be a fall tradition.

Since my dad is gluten intolerant, I replaced the all purpose flour with bob’s red mill 1 to 1 baking flour (in the blue bag)*. Cake was delicious and no one could tell it was gluten free. *Do NOT confuse with bob’s red mill gluten free all purpose flour. They are not the same.

I used 2% Greek yogurt in place of sour cream, and the cake was absolutely perfect. I learned a lesson about blindly following others' advice: I added just a little water to the glaze, but that made it way too thin and it all ran right off. I used organic powdered sugar, which doesn't contain cornstarch, and I think that was the difference. Water may be more helpful if using conventional powdered sugar with cornstarch.

I made it exactly as written and agree that it's a beautiful cake. My husband and guests loved it, but I confess to not caring for it very much. That surprised me because these are flavors I usually love. Perhaps boosting the quantity of spices would make me happier, so if I make it again, I'll give that a try. I love the idea of using maple syrup in the frosting, and will probably try that on other cakes I like more.

I made this cake for Thanksgiving and it was incredible. I made it two days early and kept it in an air-tight container and I suspect it was all the better for that. The texture is SO elegant and refined that I genuinely think it's ruined many of my former go-to cake recipes for me. I followed the recipe as written and the spice profile was perfect, complex, and bold. I sauted the pepitas in olive oil and sugar as suggested in comments but they still did nothing for us--too bad.

I cooled mine 20 minutes and it came right out. I don't have Nordic Ware though. I well buttered the pan and sprinkled with granulated sugar. The pan was not warm to the touch after 20 minutes but if anything it came out too easily.

Meh. A lot of work for only a so-so result. Disappointed because I love pumpkin desserts.